Golf 2003/12/04COMMISSIONERS PRESENT:
COMMISIONER ABSENT:
CITY STAFF PRESENT:
VALLEY CREST GOLF:
CALL TO ORDER
GOLF COMMISSION MINUTES
DECEMBER 4, 2003 - 4:00 P.M.
Community Services Department
Large Conference Room
Vice -Chairman Gaby
Commissioner Kresal
Commissioner Raab
Commissioner Wright
Chairman Schultz
Michael Lautenbach, Bob Johns, Dave Johansen and Gail Barruga
Bill Houlihan, Superintendent
Vice -Chairman Gaby called the meeting to order at 4:01 p.m.
APPROVAL OF THE MINUTES
The Minutes were approved on a Motion by Commissioner Wright and seconded by Commissioner
Raab.
ACTIVITY REPORT
Jack Kudron stated that there was no additional information for this item.
COURSE CONDITIONS REPORT
Dave Johansen stated JKB Construction started December 3, 2004 to remove the silt accumulation in the
lake at Anaheim Hills. The project includes building a dike system to divert the water around the lake to
allow their equipment to remove the silt. Jack Kudron stated that staff has researched this issue for a
more permanent solution. It would involve the construction of a system of drop structures upstream to
catch the silt which then could easily be removed using a backhoe. However, the cost associated is
prohibitive at this time.
Commissioner Raab stated she received a complaint about the conditions of the sand traps at Dad Miller.
The golfer stated he golfs early in the morning and there is a lot of mud in the traps. Bill Houlihan stated
the watering is done at night and the course has not had time to dry out for the early morning golfers.
Jack stated he would follow-up with the golfer.
Commissioner Wright asked if the bees had been removed on #10 at Dad Miller. Bill Houlihan stated
there was a hive inside a pipe and has been removed. Commissioner Wright also complimented staff on
the gorgeous condition of the greens at Anaheim Hills.
GOLF COMMISSION MINUTES
DECEMBER 4, 2003
Page Two
DIRECTOR OF GOLF'S REPORT
Bob Johns stated during the past month there were several incidents of vandalism at both courses. At
Dad Miller Golf Course Driving Range someone broke all the lights. At Anaheim Hills high schools
students broke into the cart area and damaged several of them. The Anaheim Police investigation has
several suspects. Bob Johns stated that some of the incidents have been caused by "former" employees
of the golf course.
Commissioner Gaby asked about the inventory for the new clubhouse golf shop. Bob stated that they are
in great shape.
FINANCIAL REPORT
A. October/November Financial Summaries
Jack Kudron stated that the October and November figures are down 4%. However, the preliminary
figures are up by 1,000 rounds for November. Jack Kudron stated our courses could be benefiting as
a result of the closure of several golf courses — Cypress and Hidden Valley.
Jack Kudron stated beginning January 1, 2004 the weekend (Saturday and Sunday) greens fees will
change. At the Hills the increase will be $5.00 for both residents and non-residents, and at Dad
Miller the increase will be $3.00 for non-residents and $2.00 for residents. This is the first rate
change in over four years.
Commissioner Wright asked for clarification of the rates stated on the sign at Dad Miller regarding
the resident green fee include "does not include cart." Bob Johns stated carts are not mandatory at
Dad Miller therefore the rates do not include the cost of a cart. However, if the golfer does want to
use a cart the rate is indicated separately.
OLD BUSINESS
A. Clubhouse Update
Jack Kudron reported Michael Lautenbach has been receiving deliveries of equipment for the
clubhouse and will be stored in temporary storage units until the clubhouse is available. Jack Kudron
stated there has been a delay due to various backorders and issues with sub -contractors which has a
domino effect. The contractor, KPRS stated the building will be ready for temporary occupancy on
December 19, 2003. The New Year's Eve party is still a possibility. The Grand Opening has been
rescheduled. Staff is waiting for approval from City Council prior to publishing the new dates.
GOLF COMMISSION MINUTES
DECEMBER 4, 2003
Page Three
Jack Kudron reported that the Oak tree was planted in the circular area in front of the clubhouse. It is
a multi -stemmed, 30 ft. high oak tree. All the concrete work is completed and the asphalt will be
installed this week.
Commissioner Wright asked about the number and location of handicap parking spots. Jack stated
there will be eight spots located to the left of the main entrance next to the cart barn.
B. Tiger Woods Learning Center Update
Jack Kudron reported the Tiger Woods Foundation's Conditional Use Permit (CUP) was approved by
the Planning Commission. There is a 30 day comment period the public may appeal to the Planning
Commission regarding the CUP. If there are no appeals, then the CUP is in effect. Jack stated there
were between 40 — 45 conditions. Staff continues to review their designs. The start date has been
moved to January 2004.
Jack Kudron stated the agreement continues to be negotiated between the Foundation and the City.
Until this agreement is approved, the City is unable to apply for the $1 million grant for the course
modification, and TWF cannot apply for a $400,000 grant from the City as part of the project.
NEW BUSINESS
A. Customer Service
Commissioner Wright requested information on the type of customer service training programs
available to the golf course employees. Jack Kudron reviewed the types of programs the City uses
which include videos and the secret shopper program. During the year there are two customer
training sessions for the Marshals and two or three customer training sessions for Bob Johns' staff
depending on the turnover rate. Jack stated part of the problem is the high rate of turnover.
Employees come in with higher expectations than what the actual job entails, become disillusioned
and leave. Bob Johns also stated that besides he and the two Pros all other employees are part-time,
who partially work for the perk of playing golf, and their focus is not the same as Bob's or the Pro's.
In today's market it is difficult to find employees who understand the "service" attitude.
Vice -Chairman Gaby left the meeting at 4:45 p.m.
B. Commissioner Golf Privileges
Jack Kudron distributed the annual golf passes for 2004 and reviewed the privileges with the
Commissioners which includes two rounds of golf per month preferably once at each course.
GOLF COMMISSION MINUTES
DECEMBER 4.2003
Page Four
Commissioner Wright stated that the Golf Outing was very good opportunity to meet the staff and
review the course and suggested that this should occur four times per year. Jack stated, that for the
outings, staff from both courses and the landscape maintenance vendor, Valley Crest, participate.
Jack stated he would put this on the agenda for the next meeting to have a discussion on future
outings.
ADJOURNMENT
There being no further business, a Motion was made by Commissioner Raab, seconded by Commissioner
Wright and unanimously approved to adjourn the Golf Commission meeting to Thursday, January 22,
2004 at 4:00 p.m. in the Civic Hall East 4th Floor Conference Room. The meeting adjourned at 4:55 p.m.