Minutes-PC 1952/12/01,~~-.:_
~;°-
~~
~;:
~,=::.
~,..
~~:;
~~;::
''~w:..
;~'.
~
'e:
MINIITES OF REGUL~R 1~EETffiG OF THE CITY PI,AAAIR(~ COMMISSION
R~;}~iLA~ s 3egule.r Meeting of the Citv Planni~ Coa~iasion was ceslled to order by Chairman
TiEETIlIC} Summer~ st 2:10 o~clock P.k~., a qnorum being present.
PItESF~NT CHAI3MAA SU!(P~S, COMt~SISSI0NER5 Holyoka, Riutcel~ Schumacher, Schutte, Thompson and
Aiungall. Commissioner Ha~good enter.ed the ?deetin~ at 2:40 o~clocic P.tf. City Attorney
Preaton 'iuraer was also preaent Yar a go:tfon o4 the MeeLi~.
ABS~NT COM1hISSIOI~fi GAVES.
MINUTES The Minutea of t~e Eegn].ar Mesting of I~ovember 3, 195~, a~ aY the Special Called
Meeting oY l~ovember li, 1952. xere epproved ao priated.
9ARIANC~ This was the tiae set for the Public Hearin~ oa the 9ARIANCE PETITIO.+ N0. i77, filed
N0. 177 by Stanley W. Heaser, 138 ~oaita 5treai, nrcadia, i:aiiforaia, raquesicii;~ paawii~esioa
to r,ut trro ona-half acre lots from hie property at 2220 - 2226 Eaat La Paloa Avenue~
conQist3ng oS a oae-acre parcel. The property is presently zonc~d as R-A, Besidential-
A~ri~ultural. A possible purclsaser Yor the groper~y appeared beYore the Commiesion
an3 sta~ed t2~st he proti-~sed Eo erect a Si.r-gle Family -relling oa each one-half acre
lot. The Hearing vas closed.
IIpoa a motion bv Commisaioner Schutte, eecondea '~y Commisaioner Holyoka, and carried,
it rras vated bv Heeolution No. 22 - Series 195z-53, to grant VA3IF-P.CE N0. 177, aub~ect
to the eame conditiona as rrese roquired. on the one acre propertv to "the east, acted
Ljpon on ~,~~:st L4 ~ 1452 ~ r.ame:.y:
1. That the rssidenaes to be arecte~, con~arm to t~e prasent set-backs oY homes
131 ~@ C~CSIIt~~.
2. !Chat n:~ bailding be erecte9. oa the property over 160 Yeet frow the centar line
02' ~aBL i+e F'8ime 1-venue.
- ~-~
~~ ~
~":
~t.
3, 'PLat a Rseord af S•,~.wre~ :~.ap ~e 4±l.eb ~i'Eh the C±t~ 04 f-naheim aad w3th ~lze
Co~ty o4 drange.
The vote on t~e above RESCII+UTI02t P~O. 22 - S~IEB 1952-5~~ was as iollows:
A~S: ~Ot~it•ZISSIO~iiEBS: Fwl,roke, Riutcel, Schumacher, Scuutte, Swnmera, 'IIwmpson awd
2•fiusgal.l.
1~OES: COr~'!Z~SI.~NERS: 1Qone.
AaSENT: COT4•SY5SIONLRS: Gauer and ~apgood. _
9AT3IASC~ ~ie :ras the t:Wr, ~°t rcr tL•= ?_bZic :ieari:sg cr., Va??L°:.~CE *~0. i?8, 411e8 bc Fred S. ~
PD. 178 Joass~ 122 Sri,tti 4~i1 ~ireane, Muntebello, Californ£a, rec~uesting permieaian to erect i
a Puplea ~ugl~ing on tLe prn~ce~t~ lacated approalmately 2448 Yeet ionth ot the center sr
line of 'rles•t oermont Avemxa, running a2ang South Zoa Angeles Street 120 feet, extending:';
in a aeeterly directioa 563 feet to South Lemon Street.
N:r, Fred S. Jonee ap~oearel before the Commission and stated that he pnrahe~ed the pro- ~
perty beYara annea~-tioa to the City and 2hat 3t rras zoned at the~ti~e•o£ purchase as
B-t1~ by iae Counbv, ~mio~ al+rs~a ~"L2T.P~~ B`'d~LLu,GS. Hs dasi.es at th3~ ti.:.e to builfl _
a Duplez Dwelling on the South Yas 6ng~lea Street Yroatage oY the property.
Mr. B. F. Flynn, 9891 South Loc Angelea Street, appeared before the ~o~iesion oppoaing ~:;
tBe graating of the Qariance on the grounda tYiat MULTIPLE DtifELLINGS in the area would
depreciste 2~is prnperty. He ntatea that he 2~+.s± a very large Yiome on which lie paya a
very high taz rate, but on account oY its location, doubta iP it oovld be sold for
sesidentiel purooses again. 3e rrovld go along ~rith any orderly, well-thour,,ht-out plan ,
Yar the entire ~rea. The Hearing ~ cloaed.
Commleaioner Thompeon etated t2~t in viex of the faat there ie at present Mul.tiple ~
Faerily Heaidontial Zoning oa the east side oi South I,oe Angelee Street, he would moce '
{,,. a~.~ T^nna ~e^ e ~._ t~7a a~ v ..~~A ~+,~a .. ^a~i.lld•• ~C "~"`~~'~B ~,`.. ~ C+.w4Q p0 ~::.° ::
~y~yY ~~fY~VaY 1~V• Z~J VO YOLLL ^ G~~r~~v~ V u / J 1
~a~ A sr.~ vt r~ ~, v3~~r to uoesib2a ~CZ~.SS3~'IC :TIOA. '~hs wation ~s secaaled by Cnm- =
miasioner ScYmmacher and carried. A Eeport of said Sttu~p to be preseated at ~he Regu- ~
lar Meetiag ot aam~ary 5. 1953. ~'
~:
ti..
RESIDEATIAL The City Attorney, Mr. Preston 71~rner, bad prepared a Hesolution for the Commiaeion,
USES I2J 'P~ restricting ~SIDEHTIAL IISES IR 9.~i M-1 ZOIIE, wh3ch wae preaented. Coaunieaioner Thomp-
M-1 ZONE son raiaed the qneetioa tbat if the Co~ieeion arbitrarily zoac+d property for IHD~STRY
where no indnatry rss Ioca.ted at the time the aoai.ng raa establiahed~ and ahovld the
property not be acqnired by industry vithia a reasonab].e time~ and 1Y tne ow.ner t,riahed
±~ evii a,.~t, TT~rA~P ~or a~nbdivision, he aho~:7.d net be depri~veZ. o! thie privilege.
In ot :ar :a:.ia, i~ ~gh~ bs :.o :ai@e:v: t~t hs :~c bs;+~sg @ep*_~i°ed of Qe ~3s ~e~tie2
pmperty rightp .
Mr. 'l~rner xsss iavited to at.bend tha Meeting emd give h3s viexe on the propnser]. re-
etrictiona. It ~sas his oplaion t}~at, if la~l. vere zoned for IIQDUSTRY and should thie
$oning be mede on an orderly basia taking into conaideration Ehe location o~ the
City Ball
Anakleiin~ Ca].i~ornia
December 1, 19,52
. ?i -~ -
;{
i '
,... $
~ _.
, .. .._.. :+:
_.,.. _ ,:....... -
~ .. _~...~~.._._...,.~...,v .e...:......~.rt J .. _._ .f . .
~• ~ •~: ~ ~ ~
1r" ~ ,~ S
r~
.^t;
~
MINUTES 0~" REt}ULAR t~ETINS~ HELD DECEF~ffi 1, 1952 - Contimted.• (P~ 2~
~
~
FiESIDEIQTIAI, property, ite reletion to railroade and other utilitiea, L2rat the Conrts w?f1d
4SES IN THffi uphoid the restrict3on of RESIDE~rTIAL IISSS in the area. Es also stated t1~at fi
M-1 ZOA~ at an,y time an ovaer felt t2~at he xas being de~Mved of e pshgest; ri~t, 2ic co--„2d
.(Continued) ~pn1y to the Cos~3ss3oa 40: s Farir.aca ar a Beels$~itieatiou.
_ After a iull diecuasion, a motioa xas ma,d.e by Commiasioner Hapgood~ eeconded by
Commieaioner Schumacher, and oarried, tl~at by BESOLIITIOF H0. 23 - SS~S 1952-5?.
RESIDENTIAL IISES BH PROHIHITID IA T~ K-1,°LI{~ I9DIIST32dL Z~~ aad `,.h~ p-,~7 ia
~ Hearinga be held on January 5, 1953, ~ oa February 2, 1953.
i The vote oa abova BES07~TTIOR N0. 23 - SL~RIES 1952-53, ~~ follovs:
AYE~: COMMISSIONERS: Hapgood, Enlycke, Eiutcel, Schumacher, Schutte, Suaners a.nd
~' Mungail. •
~ NOES: COMMISSIONERS: Thompaoa.
F3SP,~T: CXiMMISSIORF'~5: C+auer.
PAE~HING AND Some diacuaeioa wea held oa clarification of the Parking Eeqnireaeats in the Zoaing
BUILDINQ Ordiraace and oa a Definitioa :or a Building~ but agreeaeat could not be reached
DEFINITION mithout fnrther stnap, ^here4ore, these txo it~s xere ~e2d over.
PI,ACERTIA Dates of u'emiary 5, 1953, and ~'ebraary 2~ ~953. xere sat for Pnblic Bearings oa
APENUE AN- ~he propoeed rezoning of the area included in the PLACE9TIA AYEHL'R A2~dTICH.
NESATION
~z~x~
1'ENTATII-E The aew ovraere of Tract No. 1618 propoae to bnild homes in this tract rnnaing ia
N,AP TBACT Yloor area frnm 1200 to 1378 Yeet. Because oY the ahallor depth of the lots 100 to
NQ. 1618 103 feet, and the large-eize homea, they deaired to obtain aa rsorees+aa o! opinioa
~ fzom the Commiasion Nhether or not a Variance in front yat~3 se~~ack Yroa 2$ to 20
6 ~2eet mig"ni oe granied. i'ne said nex oxnera propose io pni a ionr ~wj iooi sidex~Ia
aezt to ths curb. They mere advised to Yile a reqneat ior a Yarieace.
ACACIA ST, A request rrsa received irom the C3ty Council asking far a reco~ation frnm the
ANNE7CATION Co~iasion rith reference to the proposed ACACIA STBEST Nfb~SSTIOH.
A motion rras made by Co~isaioaer Sehutte~ secoaded by Co~iasioaer Hapgood~ and
carried~ tbat the Commieaion recommend to the C3ty Couac3l tbat the ares incltsded
in the proposeQ aCACIA S't'~ET ANNESATIOA ae eho~ra by 4he descr±ption inclnaed ia
the Petition, dated November 24, 1952, be conaidered Yor a:mezation to t~.e City oi
A.'~ahEis~.
BEVISED 4 Revised Tentative Map of Tract No. 1697, wae presented tu the Co~isaion. ghe
TERTATI9~ only change in thie Map was the r~vere8l oY the ~1-de-Sas streeta to a11o~c for '
MAP T1tACT bat0er drainege.
N0, 1697 Upon a potion by CommieAioner Schntte, eecoaded by Co~aisaioner Hapgood~ aad carried,
• it wae voted to approve the Revieed Teatative Hap oi Tra.ct Ho. 1697, snb~ect to
Engineering ~equireneaie.
ADJOIIRI~l1~T The Meeting ed~ouraed at 5~15 o~elock P.M.
. N. MfJHGAI.L ecretrsry
\„/
~aovav .o~ / f3
'~
=~
:~
~