Minutes-PC 1956/11/19' * ~. ° . , r; ~.
. ;`` .
;~,
':~
~ - -- ----- ----~--.. _.-- - --- _ -- --.....-
t '~ tl ;;; %~
~ ~r ~ ~.,~
~
~
November 19, 195b
City Hall
Anaheim, California
i
i MINUTP,S OP Tf~ ADTdURNHD RB(iIJIAR MEETING OP Tf~ CITY PIANNING COMMISSION
i
ADJOURI~D Th~ Adjourned Regular Meetiag of the City Planning Commission was
RBG[JIAR called to order at 2:14 O'Clock P.!!. by CHAIRMAN SUI~RS, a quorua
~ MSSfING being present. .
pg~cnnrr wvA~P~HI R~u~w~~ ~ iwivnniw: niic3ir ~$fCS~ ~auer, MOLl18~
Thompson and Mungall.
COI~fYSSIONBR Hapgood entered the Meeting at 2;45 O'Clock P.M.
ABSBNT COtA~tISSI0N8R Schumacher.
MINUTBS The Mimites of the Regular -[eeting of November S. 1956 were approved
as printed.
MASTBR PLAN This is the area bounded by East La Palma P.~em~e, North Placentia Ave-
nue, Hast Sycamore Street and the East boundarq of Tract No, 1356.
Mr. Ed Mi11s; 100? North Placeatia, a*~ppared before the Cemaissioa
represeating Joe Hnarte, xhose property adjoins the Church pnoperty
on East La Palma Avemie aad requested that this property be reclassi-
fied to R-3, A9ULTIPI.& FATdIi'£ RESIDEhTIAL. Mr. Glenn Pry, Jr, , 13502
East La Palma Aveaue, rrhose property adjoins that of Mr. Huar+e,
asked that his property be reclassified to R-3, MULTIPLE FAMILY RBSI-
DBNTIAL aiso. lNrs. Jocelon P. Brorm, 708 Buttomvood, inquired as to
what rronld He peraitted in tlae R-3 zone aad stated that the street at
the rear of Buttomiood~ as shorn on the aap, would be a good buffer
betweea the Church property and these single famiiq homes. Chairman
Summers outiiaed from the code what ~ras permitted in the R-3 ciassi-
fication. 1dr, Barnes, representing the Griffith Pamily, owniag about
aeven acres facing on Ylacentia Aveaue, believed that their whole
parcel should be ~ade available for C-1 uses with the possible excep-
tioa of a buffer o: R-3 along the iPest ead of the propertq. He did
not believe that an R-2 and R-1 mould be logical zoning aloag East
Sycamore Street, but that a b~tter buffer from the siagle family homes
.^Y633 tise streef would "oe a fence or wail with tree planting aad
iaadscaping next to the street. He also stated that as per the Master
Plan, there xouid be only appro=imately txo aad one-half acres left
for Commercial use aad he did not feel that this was s»ffi.rient i*t ae
much as there ieere other parceis aa the adjoining cornery of the iatar-
secting streets that contaiaed aor2 acreage. Mr, Van der Veer, 1721
Sast Sycamore Street, could see no uae for an alieq back of his pro-
perty on Sast Sycaaore Street. Mrs. George Gte~ingham, 1840 Hast
Sqcamore Street. Mrs. Bradford Jones, 1850 Bast Sycamore Stree•, and
others, were all in favor of the Master Flan as presented. Father
Waish, representing the archdiocese„ stated that they wwld not put
in a street back cf the single faaiiy ho~es on Buttornvood Street, but
would erect a Masonry ~rall. He stated that they had approximately
eight acres of iand xith no assnrance tHat any of the property to the
Bast could be acquired. A Chnrch and Schooi are now being buiit and
other buiid3ngs are ccntesplated so that eight acres represents the
absolute mi~~sum thaE they feei carid be used for the present pro3ect
rrith the required of+f-street parting rrhich xould make the instaliation
of a streeL• aut of the qnesti~on, yr, Bro~m, subd;vider of the tract
,just direc:iy Sonth of the qmreh property. stated that a concrete wall
-1-
---. .-_-._-- ------- -~y
i
. . ! ~~~,.~~ .
.. _._..._ _. _..__._.._.-------'-...._.......~_ _....._........._.. . ---_.....----'-~---`-'.._~._.___._._..._..,..-- -
~( i~ ~ ! ~
F
MASTBR PIAN would be a suitable barrier between the Church property and the tract.
~(CONT.) M=s. Martha Zachaq, 702 Buttonwood Street, stated that they had inves-
ted in this property as a nice resideatiai area~ but that with the addi-
i , tion of a Church next door~ the traffic conditions might endanger chil-
~ dren li~ing in the tract. Albert E. Gray, ilin9 East Sqcamore, stated
~ that the area as shown on the map would vripe out his lot by crossing
' throngh the middie of same. Commissioner Thompson explained that the
~ map as presented, simply showed the proposed zoning at the varions lo-
;i cations in the arta but did aot represent the ultimate street plan for
!; the deveiopment of this acreage. The street plans rrill probabl be
Y
I aodified whea future development of the area takes place. He also
..j stated that the plaa as ahown appeared to be a layout that wou2d pro-
~ :~~: Yavii..St; .a~•_es aa #he ases, R'f7A 17RAATTTf` ~rec rrncs.n.
Upon a motion by Co~nissioner Thompson~ seconded bq Co~issioaer ldozris,
and carr3ed, it was moved that the iaformation as given by the varioas
property oraners be taken under coasideration bq the Cd~aission aad that
a further Public Hearing be held at a iater date.
RHCIASSIPI- PUBLIC HBARING. PETITION submitted by JOF~1 i. MC ELROY, 1912 Roliing
CATION Stone Lane, Santa Ana, California, as Owner, requesting that the pro-
N0. F-56-57-25 perty as described below be reclassified from R-3, MIILTIPLE FAMILY
RSSIDBNfIAL to M-1, LIGHT MANUPACNRING. This propertp.is described
as the Sasterlq ~ of Vineqard Lot G-1 aad furthez~described as commea-
cing at a point 33 feet from Bast Street on the Easteriy si~e of said
property and 193 feet from Santa Ana Street on the Northerly side of
. said property; thence Southerly 10 feet parallel to East Street; thence
Westeriy 44 feet parailel to 5aata Ans Street; thenca Noztherir ifl fret
parallel to Bast Street; thence Hasteriy 44 feet paraliel to Saata Ana
Street to the point of begianing. The parcel for rezoning is oniy tS~e
Hast 150 feet.
George L. Harzis, 557 Havea Drive, appeared before the Co~iss3on sud
stated #hat the property descriptian as advertised, cavered the xell
site only, on South Bast Street and that due to the iateness of receiv-
ing the notification of the Hearing. I~e beiieved that another date
should be had for this Hearing.
Upon a motion by Commissioner Thoapaoa, secoaded bq Commiss3oner Bates.
and ~arried, it was moved that Reclassificatioa No. F-56-57-25 be put
off until the Meeting of December 3, 1956 and that future notice be
seat to the resi6euts of this deferred rieariag. Mr. Brotien, suodivider
of Century Homes, opposed this reclassificatioa stating that in viex
of the single family dwellings that he had buiit and had had tronble
seiling, the property in question shouid be left as presently classi-
fied, aamely, R-3, h(ULTIPLE PAMILY RBSIDHNTIAL.
RBCIASSIPI- PUBLIC HBARIIVG. PSTITION sabmitted by BOB`S SUPER MARi~TS, INC. AND
C'ATION MARY S, MORGAN, 6001 5outh Grand Avemie. Buena Park, Califoraia, as
N0. F-56-5?-26 0lmers, I~DARIS-SMITH RBAL BSTATE, 433 West Center Street, Anabein,
California, as Autharized Agents, requesting that the property des-
cribed as the W~ of the NNf~ of the NW~ of Section 23, T4S, R11NT,
S.H.B. & M., except therefrom the South 120 feet of the North 170 feet
of the Sast 170 feet, be reclasaified from R-A, RBSIDHNTIAL AGRIQTL-
TURAL to G1, NBIGHBORHOOD-COA4~RCIAL.
Mr. Leonard Smith of Medaris-Smith Real Estate, appeartd before the Cos-
misaion as Authorized Agent for Bob's Super Martets and presented an
archifectuiral readeriag of the propoaed development that wuld be
similar to that at the ccrner of Ball and Snciid. He also stated tbat
C-1 deed restrictions had been prepared for preseatation aad that deeds
-2-
~
~
~
~, ~~__.__.___..._.__.~____~_.~.__. ........_._............_....-----•-•--•---..._.__.r__~~___-~a
1
l
i
i
i
~
[
J
E
i
~
/~
/
~ ~i
~
~ as r.~s -
~ C SIPI
CATION
~ N0. P-56-57-26
i (CONTJ-
I
!,
~
~..,....a
"~.: ~
. ~~ ~ ~
for street widening of Rnott Street and Ball Road had been pre-
pared. Mr. Bob Wetzler appeared before the Commission and stated
that there is a need :or a shopping center to serve this area as
there are no;- within a radioas of one and one-half miles of the
subject property. 1HH HEARING WAS CIASED.
Upon a aotion by Commissioner Thompson, seconded by Commissioner Gauer,
and carried, it was voted by RBSOLUTION N0. 93 - S&RISS 1956-57, to
recommend to the City Council thafi Reclassification No. P-56-57-26 be
approved.
The vote on the above Resolution was as follows:
A~nS: C"'u.i;.,iSSI0i1ERS: AU@3L ~ Sates, Gauer, Hapgood, Morris, Summers,
Thompson txnd Ma~ngall.
NOBS: COh9NISSI0I~RS: None.
AHSBNT: COhA4ISSI0NBRS: Schumacher. •
VARIANCH PUBLIC F~ARING. PHTITYON submitted by ALPRED J. MURPHY, 427 South
N0. 653 Arovista, Brea, California, as Owner, reqnesting permission to erect
a duplex dwelling on the property described as Lot 41 of Tract No. 14
and further described as 833 South Philadelphia Street. The property
is Qresently classified as R-2, ZWO FAMILY RBSIDHNTIAL and there is
presently a small single family residence on the rear of the lot.
Mr, Mucphy an~e3reQ tefe*e the Co:amj~sion and stated that the presenT
house is near the alley and that the lot is 150 feet deep and that a
nice duplex cotid be placed on the front of the lot. THE HEARING WAS
CI.OSBD. '
Upon a motion by Commissioner Thompson, seconded by Commissioner Bates,
and carried, it was moved by RHSOLUTIGN N0, 94 - SERIES 1956•-57, that
Variance No. 653 be granted.
.,
1
Y
~
1
;
VARIANCB PUBLIC HBARING. PSTITION submit4ed by R. L. C:OONS, ?.0. Box 591,
N0. 654 Anaheim, California, a3 Qwner, requesting permiasion t~ cut three lots
from a parce? presently classified as R-A, RESIDENTInL AGRICULIVRAL.
The property is described as the Northerly 154.06 feet o€ the W+} of ~
the NW~ of the SS~ of the SW~ of Section 2, T4S, R10W, S.S.B. & M., !
and further described as beiag on the South side of Romneya Drive, bet- !
ween Liberty Lane and Rosemont Street. ~
Mz. R. L. Coons appeared before the Commiasion and stated that the
appiication explained whut he desired to do which is to cut three lots.
• Mr. L. P. Canterbury appeared before the Commission and inquired about
tha size of the lots an~+ ±t !~es eYpiai!!ed tc him that the tH°c iots on
Romneya Drive would have an 85 foot frontage each and the one on Rose-
mont Street would have a 70 foot frontage. These all meet the code
requirements as to frontage. THR f~ARING iVAS CLOSED.
Upon a motion by Commissioner Hapgood, seconded by Commissioner Auest,
and carried, it was voted that Variance No. 554 be gra~~ted by RESOLUTION
N0. 95 - SBRISS 1956-57, subject to:
1. The installation of sidewaiks,
2. The payment of $25.00 per lot for the acquisition of park and
recreation sites.
3. The filing of a record of survey map with the City of Anaheim
and the County of Orange.
VARIANCS PUBLIC HBARING. PHTIfION submitted by PASSIBBNT MANQR, 3NC., 24I9
N0. 655 Marion Avenue, Anaheim, California, requeatiAg a waiver of rear ~;ard
setbacks on the following lota in Tract No. 3067, bounded by Orai;qe
Avenue on the North and Trident Street on the Weat, Lot 5 to 17.75
feet, Lot 8 to 15.00 feet, Lot 20 to 21.40 feet, Lot 29 to 23.OJ
feet and Lot 36 to 17.75 feet.
~
r;%
:U.'~~^ ` ~i :
"`^~!iol~!?~"~_. ,,, .._.~......`~
_3..
i
`
/
_. ... %
1 "... ._.."' "".._........ . ..._..._._._.... ... .-.._. .....--.~....._.__...___..... '_'~,...~ia
, : .~ .__.~...........~~_.~~~..~.~
~--
~
F
~
~
,, .
~
I ~ -
c
'
,
:~. <t
_._ _... .._ --_ ___.. _ ..
( : ~ ~~~
t.,:d ~ `-+
YARIANCB Mr. Middlebrook appeared before the Co~ission and stated that there
N0. 655 were only five lots invalved out of forty-three ia Trnct No. 30ti7
(CONT.) where they desired a wa_ver of rear yard setbacks due to the fact
that the houses were large and one of the bedrooms would eztend intc
the rear qard. ~tiE HSARING WAS CIASED,
Upon a motion by Commissioner Auest, seconded by Co~aissioner Morris,
and carried, it was moved by RESOLATTION N0. 96 - SERIES 1956-57, that
Variance No. 655 be granted fo.r a waive:. of rear yard setbacks for
lots 5, 8, 20, 29 and 36 for a walsrer of iear lots.
VARIANCH PUBLIC HSARINGS. PHTITIONS submitted by G~-DHBY'S E:ICHANTHD IA:~D, 3436
NOS. 656, ~Iorth Yerd+±go Rosd, Gler.c~ale, CeZifornin, a~ O:~ness, W:At T. DE~Z*?~'
657, 658, SIGNS, 5327 Valley Boulevard, Los Angl.es, California, as Authorized
659, 660, Agents, requesting permission to er~ct six temporarq directional signs
AND 665 10 by 25 feet, to advertise the first sale of lots a~ homes in Tract
No. 1979, These signs are located at:
1. The South side of Lincoln Avenue, 120 feet Sast of Loara
Street.
2. The 5outheast co:ne: of Hnclid aad Katella Avenues.
3. The East si3e of Huclid A~~enue, 1200 fee~ South of Orange
Avenue.
4. The North side of Lincoln Avenue, 600 feet West of Suclid
Avenue.
5. The Southeast corner ef ~uclid Avenue and Ball Road.
6. The Southeast corne: of West Street and Batella Avenue.
No one appeared for os against the granting of~these Variances. These
signs are to advertise the lots and hdmes in Tract Ho. 1979. THE
HHARING WAS CIASED.
Upon a motion by Commissioner Mnngall, seconded by Commissioner Gauer,
and carried, it was moved 4hat Variaace Noa. 656, 657, 658, 659 and
660 be approved and that Variance No. 6d5, being in the Disneyland
area where no signs are allowed, be denied ~y RESOLUTION NOS. 97, 98,
99, 100, 101 and 102 - SERIES 1956-57.
VARIANCS RJBLIC t~ARINGS. PETITIONS submitted by CQINTRY CUIJB ESTATES, 144
NOS. 661, South La Brea, Los Angeles, Caiifornia, as Owners, WRnV T. DEVINE SIGNS,
662, 663, 5327 Va11ey Boulevard, Los Angeles, Californis, as Autl.orized Agents,
AND 664 requesting permission to erect four, temporary directional aigns to
advertise the first sal.e of lots and homes 3.n Tract Nos. 2•~£9, 2575,
and 2576 at the folYowing locations.
1. A"V"'l~pe ~ign at the Southeast corner of Huclid and Batella
Avenues.
2. The Bast side of Stantott Avenne, 650 feet North of Lincoln
Avenue.
3, The West side of Euclid Avenue, approximately 1100 feet Soath
of Orange Avenue.
4. The West side of Harbor Boulevard, approximately 1000 feet
North of Ratella Avenue.
No on~ appea.ed for or against th2 arant~ug ~f ~he~c r&1i8f1C23. TH~
HEARING WAS CIASHD,
Upon a motion by Commiss?.oner Gauer, seconded by Commissioner Hapgood,
and carried, it was voted by RHSOLUTION NOS. 103~ 104, 105 aad 106 -
SERIE5 1956-57, to grant Variance Nos. 661, b62 and 663 aad to deny
dariance No. 664 as this is in the Dianeyland area where no signa are
allowect. Tract No. 2576 is not in the City and no signa can be uaed
to advertise this tract.
-4-
~
I
i
~
_~ _ _-------~__. ._...__...__ _ ._. _ _ ._ _. __ .--.._. .._...._..._ _,__._ ___.._,. _ ._ _...__. _..»---
..~ _ ' fA
~
~
~
1
(
~
~
~
3
~.
~
~
~
t
~
~
i
.
, i
•
~_~ ~_D ~
~=~ E~~.Y~ ~'A~_ ~Z~FfFF submitted by JACg D. MC CLEAN, 2156 Harbor
1D. 6Et St~le~, d~n~eia, Cafi€oraia, as Owner, CARL ARTHOPER, Same Address,
as A~eos~ Agemt, =xqaestiag permis3ion to have a temporary Real
~stite ad (~o~stzsctioa O~fice ia the present residence on the property
~ri~ as ffie Ncc:i~ ZOQ feet of the West 300 feet of the S~ of the
~ af ffie ~ af 3ecrioa 27, T4S, RSOC, ~.S.B. & M., and further des-
~-15~! ss being agp=o~ateip 200 feet ~~uih of ~raagetvood Avenue on
~ae ffasft ~id~ ofr Har6or Boulevar2. Tlr° propert~ ia present)y classi-
fser~ ag ~, ~F~4~ AC+ltICfTLiiJ-WL.
~r_ (~r~ ~€er appeared before the Commission and stated that he
~ze~di tn cse t~e pLeseat dvreilin; on the property which sets well
'~~ €~e ~ss~or Boulevard as a Re..: Estate Office and Construction
.Qan~c av ac csccien ai iae rear of tbe property for a~eriod oL one
ge:as_ ~ ~~RP1~G IfAS CE.OSED.
Y~ a~,rtfcm ~g Com~sissioaer Thompson. seconded by Commissioner
le~E, ~ cazrirS, st was moved by RSSOLUTION N0. 107 - SERIES
59~-57, lttrat Qasiaace Fo_ 666 be graated for a period of one year
raE~ a sig~ 6 hg ~ feet wi.th a four foot ground clearance to be
es~d om &~r6or 8ou2evard ia accordance with the Building Depa*t-
m~eEa ze~fia~aoas aa~ ~hat off-street parking be provided.
~s 3~[IC ~. PII'I~QN snbmitted bp MRS. IRANE CF~SLICK, 883 South
]ID_ :-. Ias ~:es Stzeet,ttaaheia, California, as Owner, N! SON-DYS CONSTRUC-
'~~ ~t~tE= E~SSE ~c2id Aoer+~e, ,4~?L+e_m rs13E•••Y:e, .. P.st~c:ize3
~t, a~~ag pe~fssi~t to construct an addition of~approximately
8~E9 s~ane feet t~ tIte eai;ti.ng building for additional rest home
=~S~~a €6s ~.Fatosy gnests aE tl~° above address on South Los
~e:des 3taeet. 'IIte property is described as the Basterly 114 feet
~ L~ot ~, 'Fract 1Cir- i244. The property is presently being used as
a=esft to~me ~des z~ariaace presently granted.
~s_ Ci~eslir.& ~eared 6efore :he Commission and stated th ~ the plans
ffes 1d~ae ~ addztion to her guest Fome for aged people had been
~smerd [r~ ffie Statc Fa.spector and that the plans had been okayed by
~.. '~E &~RElIk; V~PP~ Q.OSED.
~.~ a msiaom Esg Co~sssioner Anest, seconded by Commissioner M~rris,
za.' ~_--~, =t ~s vated by RESOLUTION NO. 208 - SHRIES 1556-57, the:
~asi~e 30. c6T be gzaated.
~L ~ A~ ~ aa~or~E D[eeting heid cn Friday, November 9, 1956, consideratiort
3~ ~~ ~.s ~~ea to Fedesai assistance in connectioa with the Proposed Ma~ter
~IEY ~d...~+a Eor ffie C.atf ~d :t t2eat time, it was suggested that a reco~mnen-
~tfims F~e ~de to ~he Citp Couacil to ~pply for such fnnds but that
mcffi mvfsoa~ ~~d ~ rade ~t a Regular C^~iasien Meeting.
~~e a~ofiaa b~qr Co~fr~siamer Hapgood, seconded by Commissioaer
~i~l, saa Eaasied, it was moved to recommend to 4he City Council
8~x1k s~rH3ca~aoa be made for an aliocation of Pederal Funds to ~e used
aa f~~-x~da~ aaED ezped~ting the prop~~ed Master Plan for the City.
~~ '~r.ne tasctrs aae i~ted at the No=thwest corner of East La Palma and
U& 339i3' ~_ 5~9m.'t_ '~e stsb~rFder is GIBIdALTB~ HOt~S INCORPORATBD, 720 Whittier
3ifls s~y ~~s,m s~ce~s, e~eis, CsFitoxai.a, Tract No. 3167 contains 122 lots and Tract
- " 3~_ 3Y6~ coa~#aiIIS 4~ ~ets_ Thep wiii have a 2,0 acre park site. Who
~~~la~ it isast yet lmawu. Six foot fences wi11 be a require-
~esite~ ti~ ~ant~ ssde of La4s 68 and 70 on account of the parking in
~meat ~ t~e Farir_
_5-
~4~.
-- --~•--•~.~.._ . _.. _._..--~--'--
. .. . _ _~ _ _ .. _- -~.._-_ _ _-
- . :. - ~ . -~ _ .,, ' -- '-... _ ---- - ~ ~ ~
%~
~
e
a
~
~
~
~
I
a
~
~~ ~
1BNTATIVB IdAP ~e St~+e3~as~y as~a~ ~e (i~s~ tt~atc s~et2rtl av2fa~ wss rete~xa
OF TRACP NOS. from ~he City ~~tll~e9 i~tt ~e actz~ ie~loea xt tbe Alcetia~ of lio~et
3167 APID 3168 ~er 5, 393de~ a~eae3~ t~e ~ssame ~~e Tmtst~~e MtQs. aas
tcoxr.) ~o-ss'~3y ~u3xt ta a 4~ ~r~8'. is as ssca as cae snea~.~-
3C~SS 1aL3~Z$ ?T.i~ ll~at~ l~.T. lfft ~!~ ffi~j t[~t 6t d2d IDDt ~R ~IIt SisC
1II =SZI'~OIP~
~J~01! 1 IDDk11~ $1~ ~' ~S ~7C~ ".DK~1 ..,p C`a~ a~n.*n't ~qpQ •
~ uss~sz3, iY r~s ~ve~ s~ a~z~ eL~e actaam tabtc ia t.~e Meet3a~ of
No~ 5, 3~JS~b ~eae~5' ~3 ~ss ~'~ tEm E~e '[ract I(oa. 3167 tad
31fib_
4W~^?~R.*L-~H!' r~,~. ~e#:~ a~ ~rar~ a7r a-3C~ LiR~ Y"~L
r
6!
c~,,,~,",,,~.
~
~
i
l
~'
--------._ .
~ ~
~