Minutes-PC 1957/01/21, ~ {
. . . . . _ .
~ ~ .. __ ___'___ -_'_" --
~ ._-_"--_"_ _.. _.". _ ...
. _ .__ _ _'-__ ' , X
i
'~
, ~ i : ~ f fi
'v J
~
t
~ ~
9
~
~
; S
Jarruarp 21, 1957 ~
I City Hail '
', Anaheim. California a
y1~ pF ~ A~]~R~D RE(QIAit .c~TI1~G QF 1~ CITY PIAl~NING CfY~4(ISSION i
pDJOURt~D Tf~e Ad~;awrncd IIegniar l6eetiag of tme CiiT Planning Comcrission was
g~~g ;.ailed to or~er at 2:I5 O'Clect P.M_ b9 CHAIRMAN S(II~4NERS, a quorum ;
I~STING be~B P~eseat_
~ pRggg~ ~AIg11~-p ~S, OdlaSSIU1~BS: Bates. ltonis, Thompson and
~ '
~
~~i •
~t n_!: P'!N'
? ~ ~C n
~~ c,i".caw =-T, I
~.vaialiuava nisc ~ `..L~ ..~~
~,p~S~I~R gapgood enbered the l4eeting at 2:50 U'Clock P.M. ;
ABSHNf )
~QSSIQi~R Gaaer. '
i
MINUTES a
The )ti~fies of tLe it~gnlzr laeeting of Jamiazy 7. 1957 were approved i
as prinbed_
'
VARIANC~ I4BLIC ~'~QT~. ~IITIQ~ snbnitted by G. D. EUCCQIA INYESTFffiNT
A~p, 6gg O~I,tiY, 1242 Lisoln A~e~e, A~hei~a, California, as Owaers, FRANIC
FR~i, 1315 Cberry Drzve, QranBe. eali=`ornia, as Authorized Agent, ;
reqnesti:g peiaission to erect a'~'ORFIRY DIRECTIONAL SIGN to 3
ad~erYi~e tbe sale o: ~es sa3 2ots in Tract No_ 2995. The sign
rill be lotated oa the SoatLe~~t corn~r of Enclid Avenue and Broad-
rray. Tract No_ 2995 is located 1325.20 feet Kest of Euclid Avenue
betreen i;*+~-oin ,~Aeme aad Bzwdrap aad contains 64 lats.
!do o~ apgeued for or against the grantiag of this Variance. TFIE
H£#lRI3~1G )l~1S Ct~S€~_
IIpoa a aotion by Oamissionex Tha~pson, seconded by Commissioner
l{orris, ~ ca+rried, it ras ~oved to grant Yariaace No. 688 sub-
jecf to t~e nine oonditiaas of tt~e Si~ Ordinance by RESOLUTION
2~0_ 141 - ~tIES 1956-5'.
VARIANCE p[TBLIC ~II~_ FETTIIOL~ satraitted by E. T. SCFi.'ROEDL, Villa
NO. b90 Rzviera Hotel, I;am~ Beach, Califo=n"s~, as O~mer, VICPOR E. PROSNESRI,
9Gg6 ~aott ilvenae, Ambeia, California. as Authorized Agent, reaues-
ting pero±siaa to erect a 40 b~ 20Q foot Ail Steel B[JILDING FOR
1~ FAB~IC~-Ti~i pF tnqQ(~ DRAII~OARDS_ The property is described
as being: ybe Soatherl7~ rectaagalar 1~ acres o.` tht coliowiag des-
cribed propert~: 'Ime 1~ of Slfs of Section 14, "t4S, R11W, S.R.S. & M.,
plot description as follws: Beo ++*++ng at a poin~ in the 1Kesterly
~;~ o,F said SecticA 14, S~ 15• 45" East 674.+2 feet from the W~
taraer af said Se~~tia~; ~~c ?~ 84° 36° SQ°f East, 6b2.84 feet;
theace S O~ 16° Fast 337_18 feet to a point; thence S 84~ 36* 40"
'~est 522.R7 i~eet to a point in the llester~y iine of said Section;
thence N 15' 45° liest 337.21 feet to the place of beginnir.g, reser-
ving y portim a0 the 7fest iaclr.~ded in tbe road, excepting there-
f=om thC 1QoitLCZly mta~s~r tw acres. The property i~ further
deseribed as beisg on the Fa~t side of Laott Avem~e, 1400 feet
Sonth of Oraa~e ~laeme- 'Ifae praPeztY is presently classifried as
R-A, RESID~~QiIAL A[3tII]TL'~fRP1L.
IIr. prosmesti, a:. Aat~oriued A~ent, appeared befo=e the Co~ission
;~~ ~:,~ .;o~a a.:. ~:_.~ ~~ .+~. ~=c.,.;..: a: :~e 2acatioa of the
snbject property, ichis nse roald a~Peaz to be of no detriment to
aay of tbe otLer properties ia tLe azea. IY would be scrtiened
fron the stre~t iry residrntiai property aad khe=e would be no smoke,
dnst or odor created bp this ase. Tf~ HE~RING 11WS CLOSED.
-1-
. !
, ~-
-
_ ~ -- ---------- -- ---- _ -. __ _ .
,.
; ..,~
~
~ ~
~,
~~
`
VARIANCB Upon a motion by Coaissioner 33n.rr"s.s. ~~g ~s~er
N0. 690 Bates, and carried, it iea.s mos~d t~st 4*~-n~ 3m_ ~aJD be ~aaLe~_
(CONP.) Commissioner Thompson brongi.. :,.~ !~e s~aesti,~ aa` ~e Catf snq~iriag
the deeding of propertq for stz~f a~dm3~g as a¢~Si~ a€
the Variance and stated tt,ai he D~ad aa c~anasm aa~ ffie Cstp Att
o~
et
L
_
that such procedure ~-as not legai_ ~ Sa~c:• u=W ~"~ ILLi
second during this discussiaa_ 3t ~~ti~ ~ tt~af re ~ve
been making such requiremeats far a p~r-r~ mrF ~3~ vezas ~ t~se
items are part of the Varia~:x ~etatiaa, ~a ~m~ iHoe ~, p~icaC ss
aware of the facts at the time ~e fi3es it~e ~e+~^~-p_ 3£~r
motion was made by Co~mmissio~z ldo~ris, ~**xsdr~ ~,y fl~ssi~er
Bates, arul cazried that Variaace Po_ €~'9'.'i ~ gr~aCed ixg ~~i
N0. 142 - SPRIES 1956-5T snbject #ac
1. The d+eeding of 10 feet to 1~e f3~g a~ ~a €as s~mt
widen~+~g purposes_
2. Engineering RequiremPnts_
VARIANGB PUBLIC HEARING. PETITION sabimit~ed ~by C_ ~ ZL19~BS' ?.2G! ifest
N0. 691 South Street, Anaheim, Cxlifaxaia, as C1~~rr~ ~Yffi' ~~IBt,. 726
South Los Angeles Street~ Aaaheim, (~1~F~+3~+ zc ~m3 dg~t,
requesting permission to =amstrnct amd ~ate ss ~i~30 ~ffiC
RBPAIR SHOP. The property is ~P~-~~~+ as_ ~ i€ha~ *+* seaF
property in tho Ci:k+,• ~f Anaiie3m, Canm3~ c~ ~e, S~te a€ r~~*-
fornia, beiaK ~`t~ Sox:t~es3y g22_+DO ~e~t r~¢` t~ ~~ aF ~ Y~t j
of D.::yfus and athers ~ ~a~t aa s ~ ~ ~"?~- =~_' :~s'w €~r '-
record in Los Angeles Coan#y, a copg af ~r~ as zeoa~d ~ P~grs ~
163, et seq, in Book 3, entii3ed '~us ~s~gePxs ~tr ~, secetds ?
of said Orange County, describe~ as fo33~s= ;
Beginning at the inYersectiaa of t~e Sa~~ Ea~e e£ Ttes~ Soat~ ¢
Street, 60.00 feet wi.de, said -_~thes3~ lia~ ~ t~e Sam~erFF p
line of that tertain stri~ af 3:.s~ r.~-~ ~. ~ a~~D a =-~ = ~
by deed recorded in Book 224~ 3'agP 330 ~' ID~, zg.s---',~~ a€ s~sd ~
Craage County; with the 14ester3.y 35me o~£ /t!h~ 3~d~ ~i~-,mt ia ~
Resolution #3193 of the City ib~mci3 ~' ~ CiY~ ~a .~md~i~ as >
recorded in Book 345E, ~sge 555 of t~f3ssa3 ~.ex~e~.s, rs~s oE sxid n
Orange County; thence South ].5~ 52• 3~" ~st, a]~ sa9~II ~~Ig a
line 263.00 feet to 4he Son~beriy 3~sae a~ t~ ~ao3 o~ed ba a
Conrad Albert Zimmerma~as desrribe~ i~ ~ffacaSte a+F 'Y~tE~ ~ ~
on file in the office af the RegistsBr a~ fiit~es e~ saa~ Orzmge i
County; thence North 740 22' OD" ~ast, aIIo~g sa~l S'ae~eslf 1tae,
60.00 feet; theace North ]3fl 52* ~~° lYr~, ~+n+w~'~ ~nit~ said ~fes-
teriq line, 263,00 fE~# tty saifl ~,...--~~3y 3~e ~~ S~~ S~a:;
taence South 74~ 22• 00" liest„ :.3.omg sa9a~ Saoo2~s3p Aise, Si!_~IT feet
to the point of beginaiag. Srbje=t ta ~~ r~mr~ai~~„
reservations, zestricrions, rrig~ts, r3g'~ c+~ ~g a~! ~ats, i€
any, of record.
Mr. Miller, 9s Avti~orized A„tat, ~'ar ~_ ~_ ~~ ~ he~- :
fore the Commission and sta3~ed t~at fie ~~~ am~ eses~ a e~a'2+i~,
30 by 40 feet to condnct a lm~+~~~ aQ ~ta~ ~~a~ ~r„ aaui
that there wouid be ao noise, odnrs ar smatt se c~ta~ rmt~a ~his
business. Mr. Henry 1~1av6, 107 lEa~ ~r~¢r l6a~:n¢. s~eaae~ ~ort
the Commission and presented a petit9.oa f~ ~:~ a~ess an
Mac Arthur Manor, Valencia SYreet, aad ~as~ Et~~ S~trt a~~IIg
26 names opposing the graatiag aF ~s maa~-s_ Se sL~ s~ t~at
the lot was not lazge en~ngh for liiis t~ ~a' ~msimess, ~ aczvs~
5rom the rear of. a Church and that ~'~t a~s am~s ~lR ~~2 feet_ !
He also stated that tse prager3y a3a~ 3os 3~age3e~ Stzeet canFaS m~
bc used for busi.ness as there azE deffi ~,~s p~ to ~
same and they do not eapise tmtil #~ y~ar ef 3~97_ !hr_ ffil2er j
again appeared befare ~he Co~i.ssi~ axd sfatr3 s~att tHPe psupeEtg 1
was 60 by 121 feet a~ that 3~e ~t yeas e~aam t~e a~3E r~sideace ~
now oa the propertq. His eaYzavu s~a~l be fr~ :~ ~•~ ca~g ~
with no f rontage on azry stree#_ ~drs_ lfe3r$ 39e ~~!~+~„ ~tl A6~+c sy~r ~
Manor, appeazed before the Coai.ssaam ~! ~~ t~a2 sach a~ess
would be undesirable in the nr~~~ !er_ ~, re~ ~
the United Bz2theren C,huzch, a.ppeared '~effa+a~e ~~~ reqme~
ting that the Variaace be ~raied ~s ~eg ~sg ~ te ~visg a ~
buainess in the aliey directl; be~sd td~e ~'1~ ~ f~3 Ci.U6~ED. '~
~Wy~
~.:
~
~
~
~
6
~
I
i
~
~
1
VARIANCE Upon a motion by Commissioner Auest, seconded by Co~issioner
N0. 691 Morris, and carried, it was moved by RHSOLUTION NO. 143 - SERIES
(CONT.) 1956-57 to deny Variance No. 691 due to the fact that Vaxiance
' No. 428 for the erection of a new and used car sales agency on
• the corner had c~xpired, and that if this project had been in
operation, tbc decision might have been reversed.
RBCIASSIPI- PUBLIC HEARING. FHTITION submitted by W. C. AND MATTIE LUQ MAR1iELL,
CATION 8741 Lincoln Avenue, Anaheim, Califomia, as Owaers, ~qnesting that
N0. P-56-57-15 the property described as SE~ of the SH~ of the SW4 of Section 12,
T4S, Ri1W, S.B.B. & M., having a frontage on Lincoln Avem~e of 664.63
feet and a frontage of Dale Avenue of 664.13 feet and further des-
cribed as the Northwest'corner of Lincoln and Dale Avenues, be
reclassified from R-A, RBSIDHNTIAL AGRICULTURAL to C-3, ~AVY
CObA~RCIAL at the corner for 200 feet by 200 feet and that the
bala.nce of the property be reclassified to C-2, GENERAL ~RCIAL.
Mr. Maxwell appeared before the Commission $nd stated that a plaa
had been prepared fQ the property by the McDaniel Engineering Coapaay.
He stated that he would like to keep the corner with the Service
Station for himself but that prospective purchasers of the property
apparently woaid like to get the whole parcel. Mr. L. B, Harbonr.
9731 Lincoln Avenne, of the tract immedia*ely to the We.st, stated
that without a doubt,'I.incoln Avenue would be commerc?-.al for a
certain depth, possib~.y 300 feet but that they could ~ot see extend-
ing :he Coaraercial zoae for 650 £eet which would piace ii direciiy
behind their subdivision which he considered Yo be o:.e of the finest
that has been put in the City of Anaheim and will contain, wher~
completed, 110 siagle family homes, ranging in the 17 to 18 thonc-++~
dollar class. A number of property owners who have purchased ho~es
directiy at the rear of the subject propertq appeared before the
Cosr~iss:oa protesting thz gran~ittg of tne Reclassiiicasioa. Mr.
Max.well called attention to other shop~mg centers in the City ~ahereby
resi('antial property was across the street from the shopping center
which a'p'parently had not been found to be detrimental. 1HE HEARING
WAS CLOSED.
Upon a motion by Commissioner Bates, seconded by Commissioner Thamp-
son, and carried, it was moved that Reclassification No. F-56-57-15
be continned until the next Meeting which wiii be haid on Pebruary
4, 1957 for further study, to see if any tqpe af buffer zone mnld
be developed next to the residential property.
RSCIASSIFI- PUBLIC FffiARING. PSTITION submitted by HULDA M, HElrOdERLIAIG AI~ID FJ~IA
CATION 1~GBR, 114 Coffman Avenue, Anaheim, California, as Owners, HITIDA
N0. F-56-57-39 M. HEMA~RLYNG, Same Address, as Authorized Agent, requesting that
the property described as: Approximatelq 20 acres in the East ~
of the NE4 of the I~~ of Section 17, T4S, R10W~ S.B.B. & Al.~ Covnty
of Orange, State of California, being further described as tLe iiest
g+_de of n„~~_~ eyA~~~o ~~ea F.iacoln eq_^.u~ ~.~ nr..~a;~;+ ~..° --
c'.assified from R-•A, RBSIDENTIAL AGRIQTLTURAL to C-3, HPAVY COIB~ffR-
CIAL for 150 by 150 feet at the Northeast corner for 4he erection
of a SHRVICE STATION and that the balance of the 20 aczes be ze-
classified to C-1, NHIGHBORHOOD ~MMERCIAL.
Mrs. Hemmeriing appeared before the Commission and stated tbat the
subject property con~ined 20 acres which would make for a good
deveiopment that would be an attractive addition to th~ City of
Anaheim. The only concrete plans for the developmeat at present
are the:egotiating with a major oil company for a Service Station
at the Southwest corner of Lincoln and Suclid. She also stated
that nothing would bc developed Chat would be objectionable.
-3-
~
~
3
;
i
i
,
. ~- -,----
- . t
i " •
---- ---- -----
~
~ ~ -~.. ------- . -
_
~
~ ,~
i.
-,~.
~
~
1 ~
RECIASSIFI-
Mrs. Thelma Murphy, representing two property owners on the South ~
~
CATION side of Broadwaq, directly across from the subject property,
N0. F-56-57-39 . P~elieved that if this reclass3fication ig granted, the3r proper-
(~pNfINUBD) ties ahould also be conaidered for Commercial uses. No Tentative
Plan for an~q proposed deveiop~ent were presented. No ratios of
bu3ldiag coverage in relatioaship to off-street parting were pre-
sented. No iadication of possible streets or what possible area '
might be served by this Commbrciai-project were presented. It ;
was indicated by the applicat that no tentative proposed develop- s
ment couid take place until after th~ property was reclassified. ~
Some of the Commissioners did not feel that this xas the case. y
TFIS HBARING WAS CIASBD. ~
F
Upon a motion by Commissioner Thompson, seconded by Com~issioner ~
Suwners, and carried, it was moved'that Reclassiiication No. F- ,'
56-57-39 be granted for the N} of the property with a C-3 classi- i
$cation far a Service Station at the Northeast corner, subject to:
'. 1. Tbe deeding of 20 feet along Euciid Avenue kor Street !
wideaing.
2. Bngineering Qequiremen:s.
I
The vote on the above Motion was as foilows:
6
AYSS: COL9~lISSIOI~ffiRS: Hapgood, Thompson and Surmners. ~
I:QES: C~:SSIOPffiRS: Auest, Ba:es, klorris and b.ungall. ~
ABSSNT: COMMISSIOI~RS: Gauer. ~
d
This means that this Reclassification will go to the City Council ;~
without any recommendation by the Planning Commission. ~
~C'i.'w333P3- ni3Y:xC iulA~3IvG. r`nTYTYOF suomitted by GBORu~ W. ASAWA AND BiLL T. ~
GTIQN ASAWA, 9732 Sta~ton Avenue, Anaheim, Californie, as Owners, HILL ~
N0. F-56-57-40 T. ASAWA, Same Address, as Authorized Agent, requeating that the
property described as: Starting at a point 20 feet South from the ~..
centeziines of Orange Avenue and Staaton Avenue; thence Sasteriy :
92 feet at right angies to Staaton 9venue to s point of beginniag; r
Thence Basteriy along the Southeriy right-of-way line of Orange
Avenue, a distance of 1240 feet, more or leas; thence Southeriy ~
at right angles to Orange Avenue, a distence of 1349.70 feet more ~
or less; thence Nesterly paraliel to Orange Avenue, a distance of ~
1240.feet,.more or less; thence Northerly along the Basterly right ~
Of-ii'dj~'3aZ8 6i S~dilt6ii A'vcAiIB~ 3 4'16LdIIC2 af 1349.70 i22i. u-i0i2 8Y +
lesa to the point of beginniag. There are 37.82 acres included in
the petition for reclasaification requested by the appiicant. The i
property owners are Lipyd A, and Zeida Marchali, 9622 Staaton A~eirue, •
Anaheim, California; Daany and Gioria Marchail, 234 Martha P1ace,
Puilerton, California; 8ad B, atti F. Nakamura, 8222 prange Aveaue,
Anaheim, Cet ifornia, be reclassified to C-2, GSI~RAL COMdBRCIAL. ~
Thp ~~n~.tn ae p*ese!+t?y cle.&gified as R A, Ri3SE~~!~'rrer nrqT{~r~g,er _ i
i
~
i
~
Mr. Biii T. Asawa as Authorized Agent for the property, appeared
~efore the Commission and stated that in March of 1955, an appli-
cation was made to the County to ~u! this acreage iato a Co~-ercial
nse but that the Bs11-Dale Annexat3on came into being and the
CounLy Plana3ng Commission wouid not coasider rezoniag same after
+.he anaexation had beea started. It is proposed to develop th3s
arPa with a Supermarket as a Ceatral Deveiopment wit2i subsidiary
storea, aad allowing not iesa than 4 to 1 ratio for off-street
parkiag and possibly•this ratio may be greAter. All existing
building on the property will be removed. No one appeared in
opposition of the Reclassification of this propertq. THE HEARING
WAS CIASBD.
-4-
a`
~ '
~
~
1
~
~
i
!
~
~, ~
~
' ~ •
.j; .
~:,~ .
_ L f~ ~' ~ .`I
~~ i
\1 ~
I
~EQASSIFI- IIpon a notioa by Commissioaer Auest, seconded 'oy Commissioner
~~~ Thoapson. and carried~ it was moved to recommend to the City
~g(r-57-40
1~ Couacil bq~RHSOLUTION N0. 144 - SBRIBS 1956-57 that Reclassifi-
,
(~~) cation No. F-56-5T-40 be approved for C-1, NSIGHBORHOOD COI~~RCIAL
aad not C-2 GHI~RAL COIri~~RCIAL as requested.
The pote on the above Resolution was as foilows:
A]IIS: COF~ISSYOI~RS: Auest, Sates, Morris, Summers, Thompson,
Hapgood and Mungali.
NQHS: C01~4lISSIOI~RS: None.
ABSHAPP; (~MFQSSIOI~ffiRS: Gauer.
~~ The Meeting Adjourned at 4:35 0'Clock P.M.
-5-
I
_~