Minutes-PC 1957/06/03r
t ( ~
;
!
~
i
~
...~~~ - ._..__. ~.::.~
~ 4
June 3, 1957
City Hall
Anaheiw, California
MIN[TfBS OF THB REGUTAR AffiETING OP THB CITY PIANNING COMMISSION
~ The Regular Meeting of the City Ylanning Commission was called to
~~ orde•r at 2:11 0'Ciock P.M. a quorum being present.
pltgSBNC CHAIRMAN SUI~AffiRS, COI~tISSIOI~ffiRS: Gauer, Mauerhan, Thompson and
Mungall.
COD9~fISSIOI~R Hapgood e~:e:ed the Meeting at 2:45 0°Clock P.M.
COD4~tISSIONffiR Morris entered the Meeting at 2:44 0'Ciock P.M.
COMMISSIONBR Thompson retired from the Meeting at 4:15 O'Clock P.M.
AgS81~ CO[~AlISSIOI~RS: Bates and DuBois.
,~
9
~
~
;'
i
~Q1~fgS The Minutes of the Adjourned Regular Fteeting of May 20, 1957 were
approved as printed.
Q/~R7AI~iCg ~ PUBLIC I~ffiARING. 'PBTITION submitted by CLARBNCB H. BAAGSTHN, 10162
~p. 74g placentia Avenue, Anaheim, California, as Owner, requesting permis-
sion to use the iots in Tract No. 3223 for Light Manufacturing uses.
This tract is iocated at the Northeast corner of South Piacentia Ave-
nue and Winston Road and is further described as the S+~ of the NW~ of
the NW~ of Section 24, T4S, R10W, S.B.B. & M. The property is present-
ly classified as R-A, RHSIDBNfIAL AGRICULTURAL.
~."
This Variance was held over from the Meeting of May 6, 1957 because
no specific use was requested for the property as required for a Vari-
aace. No plot plan was presented and no eievation plan of the pro-
posed building to be located on the property was fil~d. Mr. Bargsten,
as Owner, and Mr. Ribal, as Hngineer, appeared before the Commission
and presented plot plans of Lot 28 of Tract No. 3223 and after ques-
tioaing stated that the Manufacturing Plant proposed for this lot was
an electro-piating concern. They stated aiso that the piant had been
okayed by the Mayor and the City Administrator. They also presented
an artists rendering of the proposed plant, having a 10,000 square
foot area located on the property line.
1. He stated that the proposed_setbacks specified as a con-
dition on the Reclassification No. P-56-57-76 would be
detrimental to the appearance of the ne3ghborhood.
2, It wouid be too much landscaping for small industries
such as they proposed to establish in this tract.
3. It roaould cnt down available parking area.
4. A11 p~rtine would be at the rear according to their proposal.
S. That this is being done in similar industrial tracts in the
Citq of Santa Ana.
6. That the Sandscaping wouid not be kept up.
7. fihat Winston Road is not a major throughfare.
Mr. Higgins, representing the Pacific Scientific Companq, appeared
before the Commission and questioaed about the setback recommendation
under Reciassificatian No, P-56-57-?6 and stated that he understood
this wouid come before the City Council far consideration on ,June 18,
1957.. He also stated that their footings were 25 feet bac& of the pro-
perty line aad although they pianned a planter that might extend to
the 21 foot 13ne, this was not part of the building atrucxure but an
architectural addition to impruve the appearance of the buiiding aad
the street. It was pointed out by the Secretary that there are three
different conditions on the subject propertq at preaent.
1. A Tentative Map of Tract No. 2223 approved by the Commissian
on March 18, 1957 shows a 15 foot building liae setbsck from
the progerty line and also was approved sub,ject to the re-
zoning to M-1, Light Manufacturing and at that time, controla
as to architecture and so forth wauld be estabiished.
-1-
Y~1tLlR~ 2_ 8~ler tme Reclassificatioa to 1[-1, Light Mannfactnrias, con-
II~_ 749 sic~ered Sq th~ Caeissicr. on i(ay 20, 1957 it ras reeom~eaded
C~~.) ~o tlse C.itT Co~cil that the setbaet be 26 feet from the
p~Qatf 2~ne.
3_ II~er tais Qariance No. 749 there xill be ao building line
set6sct €zae tffi P=oPenY 2iae.
'~ ~ ~ E:FA6CD.
~pms a~otinm bf ~~;uioner ~aaer, seconded by Caoaisaioner Mauer-
~aa, ao~E c~xried, it ras naved to xitLhold action on this Variance
~Itsa after t~e Citf Coancil acts apa~ the Recaadendatioa sent to them
re~s~3siaB E~i~iag Iiae aetbacirs nnder Reclassification No. P-56-57-76.
~ l~IC E~3IIG_ ~FIITON snb~itted by the RHatC~l1NIZBD (~TRQi OF JBSUS
l~. 754 ~tYSP ~I'r IBfFF~ DAY SAI1~S, 1300 North Avo~ale Avemie, Anaheim,
i7~if~, as Aathor~ed Ageats, reqnesting permission to use 827
Sa~t~ ~t Street, further describeQ as Lot 118, Tract No. 1421 as
a~ ~~pestg is pxeseatiy classified as R-1. SINGI,S FAMILY
~
~'- .T~ ~- ~i-*, ~Ider,° appeared before the Comaissioa and sta4ed
t~at a1t ~e p~reseat theT plabaed to nse the existing d~eliing tr:a a Church
aoe3 51~p ScB,oo~t "-~Iding and tba4 it rill be possibiy 3 years befoze
t~e~ tiiEl ~e s~.t.-~.v Dniid a aerr bnildiag although tbey hope that this
~~Q befarr this tis^.. He aiso stated tt~at they proposed to tear
d~m t~e oI~ ~axa aor ez+..,ctivR on the property Nhieh is uaed f~r the
~~" ~€az~ ~r-~?~*~#s. Na oae appeared in oppositioa to the grant-
i~ aE t~i.t ra•~s~,••~n. THS F~ARII~iG 11AS CLU6HD.
~~ a~tic+~ t~ CaQissioaer -[aner~aan, seconded by Commissioner Hap-
~. as~t cazried. it ~~oved by RBSOIAfION N0. 241 - SHRIHS 1956-57,
Y~at gaa'inmcn !fc-_ TS4 be grauted for a period of 3 years subject to:
a- ~e remoaal of the oid bun at the rear of the property.
2- '!Se bIacr-tePPsn6 of a11 this portion of land Nhere the
t~sna is re~aved for off-street gartiag.
3_ ~eEiag of a fenze on the lfest s3de of tbe property.
4. I~co~at of tbe appearaace of the froat yard.
YAA7Al~ l~.IC ~_ ffi'TrIONi snlsitted bT POLLII~HQtN CONSTRUCfION
!~- 755 G~B. 3'!~1 ~ia Paloeino, Palos perdes Estates, California~ as
Leu+ee, ree~eestiag pez=issioa to erect a directional sign to ad-
ee~tise ZYact I~o_ 2825 in the City of Aaxbei', The snbdiviaion
o~faims 6fD E,ots. ~ siga vill be located at 125 North Piaceatia ~
A~eme, 3i~O feet I(ozth of Ceater Street on the 1(est side of Piacentia
i~ese_
8o ve ~ f~ ar against the graatiag of theapu isnce. TFffi
,~"~~ 11~5 ~,D_ '
~P~ a~~mm ~7r i~ar•sissioaez Gauer, seconded by Co~aisaioner Thomp-
so~. as~ caaied, i'l' nas ~avea t~ RBSOLVrION I~A. 242 - SffitIBS 1956-57
tsait ~~~ lro. TSS be graatea snb3ect to the ni~ conditioas inpoaed
~1 tbe C$tf t?~it for directioffii signs.
~A1t7111~ !~ B~B~_ H~ITI@I sltheitted b~ POSPffi~ ~ ElBISBIt C~ANY, ~
3i0. 755 D:~d L Isrsms I~Z9 Nagnolia A~e, Long Heach, California, as
. Les~ee, ~e~ti~ pa~isaioa to rebsild sad modernize ea ex3stiag
~ a~edooe advertisis~ stzaet~ae. The strncture is located at the 3onth-
: ost camer af Yiaato~ 8oed aad South Los AnseTes Street.
Der. D~~id L~aaa, zepeese~+~ Foster and Lleiser Co~pan7. aPPesred
tmfae t~e c~-:~{a.. ~Ctpcesented photographs of the sign in quee-
ti~ #a~ t~cs peoposa~d ta e1q¢Sstr abouY ?A feet. The reasoa for the
~eat 3a t3st il:t a~ itaelf is IocsteQ ia a P-L so~ rhich iies in
€r~ ~ ~ i~-~ wae. 2~ ~ARIi~ ~S i,:.OSBB.
_2_ '
~~ ~ - ~ .
i`Z ~ i ~ `~
~ ~ v 3
~
.
VARIANCB ~
~
Upon a motion by Co~issio~ner 'I~aa, semede~l! b~ ~~;«;mez
N0. 736 Mauerhan, aad carried, it rs ao~+d hp ~ PD_ 243 - S~IESS
(CONP,) 1956-57 that Var3aace 2Yo. 756 be ~a ted_
VARIAN~ YOffiIC I~ARII~. PBTITI~ snl~eitbed by SII~ FIG~SE FF~S, C Aeeri
N0. 737 can Health Stndios, 6624 Hoilyseood Boele+ud, Holl7ruad, G1ifa~aiz. ~
as Lessee, reqnesting peraissian to ese 729 lio~t~ Los Angeles Street, ~
funuar described as Lot 25, Ori~3mIl ~itT d~+~+~--3-,^p fcs a Iadies ~
Gpmnas~ rith the iastallatia~ af Stea Cabineta aad ~~aercise L~ppara- y
tus. The property is pr,eseatly cl~si+F9ed as C-2. ~EiL 0~8CIAL. t~
Mr. Rnberts appeared before the nomissim asd sLated tA~it tbe Qariance ~
covers only steam cabiaets faz ~ich a reoeet sariaaoe ~as graated for
~
the upstairs portion of t~e baiLdi~_ i~is fnshllitYan rill be dam
~ on the first floor affi for ~he roeea's ~*+^~ af tbe Lrsfth stodio.
Tf~ HBAitING iifAS Q~SED. i
1
Upon a mo#ion by C+~issiamer ~~, ~~ ts7 C,m~.i-~cia~er l~a11,
and cazried, it was nwed by BES~TI~i 1D_ ?44 -~ffi 1456-57
that~Variance No. 75T be graat~ed_
VAR7ANCB PUBLIC HaARYNG. PBTITI(8i sal~mitted by ~17AiG ~1RAS~<~ ::.~i, ~4 North
~
N0. 548 Pine Street, Anaheim, Cali€oraia, u O~er. seqsesti~,;;~xaissioa for
an euteasion of time c~ this vuiaeoe peaitta~ tbee to coavert a hoase
~
located at 41T North Pala Strect 3~o tro pcofessiaeal affioes. The
property is described as Lot 3, Trut !fu_ ~i, ~atbaIes Additim
,
and it is presently classified u~~, 1~II~AE F~QI.Y 3ESIDBNITAL. _
No oae appeared for or agaiast tbe Sratias of t~is ezieasYm of time_
TFffi I~ARII~G 1Q1S CLU6F~.
. Upon a motion by C.o~issimer 'mo~scu, secaa~ed L'! Oo~isss°ss 1[~
~all, and carried, it ws soved b~ BE~lI~ lO_ 245 - S~IES I956-5?,
that a six montb's eateasiam be gragted aa ~iria~ce lio. 548.
/UffiNIDHD PUBLIC HBARING. PETITI~1 sabsitted b~ 1Da- L_ ffiOADS, 2944 Allzed,
RBQASSIPI- Lakexood.Y311~ge, t~liforni;, as O~er, ~7 E_ ~, 12751 (~dea _
CATION Grove Boulevard, Garden Gro~e, Califa~ia, as AatLo~i~ed Ageat, ze-
N0. F-55-56-41 questing that the property described as beiag 33D.08 feet East fraa the
centerliae of Enclid Aveme, m tbe Soath side oE Lincola Aveane, be
, reclassified fram R~l, RESI~:lrI~L A[gi~L to C-3, ~AOY C~1~R-
CIAI. on fhe North 2T0 feet a~ tbe *+~~~~ progertT to R 3, laLTIPIE
PAMILY RESIDBNSIAL.
Mr. Ray Rhoads appeared before tLe C~.ssim aad stated tl~t they
have a survey prepare3 far thrm 'by L•x ~es7L Es~te 3e.search Cotpora-
tion rhich shows tbat tbe hi~est aad best sse for tt~e f=aatage of
their property on Lincoln Ave~e roald be far a lfotel tluch t~e~
now propose to bnild oa :Le propert~ af ~ pen3asion- TI:e7
presented plaas to the (;a_issim faz tLe grop~sed Natel rhsch rili
extend 270 feet bact fro^ T~~+~~ A~eme and sa~etae ia tbe fatnre
they gr~~rose to erttt R-3, l~ai#ip3e ~ail* ~eliis~s m tl~e tr~~~+.~-~
of the property to the South vit~ aa eatraaoe iato tbe pioperty fr~
Buciid Atreane. ~ ffiARI?~ 1@1S (,TAgD_
Upon a mo~ion by ~a~¢iss~^°~°= Ha~gmnd, s~d bf ~'~;«=+~aer
Morris, and carried, 3# ~s soRd b~ ~E90~fI0lf !b_ 246 - S68~S 1956-
57, to ;eco~end to tbe City ~Cmmcil t~at A~mded ~~c>>~ification No.
Fj.55=56-91 be approved for Cr3, Hea~ O~ercaal for tLe frmt 270
feet faciag on Lincoin Avem~e amd t~t tLe ~~'~ a~ tIIe progrrtT
to ttve rear be re-lassifi~ as A-3, Mnlti~~ Resil~ Aesideatial
subject to the deediag of 3a feet ~ tLe Sasth 13ae aE tbe pzoper-
ty for a fntnre street ~irh rill eztead t~ F~rSsft ~laea~.
The vote on the abovc Besol~ian vas as follass:
_3_
c ~ ~ '"~
AI~PIDBD A7BS: . COMMISSIOIIERS: Gauer, Hapgood, Mlsuerhaa, Morsis, S~ness„
1tBCIASSIPI- Thompsun and 1Hungall.
CATION ~ NDES: (70MMISSIOP~RS: None.
N0. F-56-S7-41 ABSSNf: COhA~tISSIOt~RS: Bates and DuSois.
(CONf . )
RBCIASSIPI- PUBLIC HfWRING. PBTITION submitted by PRSDBRIC~ D. and 31IalA ~ 8PffiS~fi-
CATION SON, 1927 Bast Ceater Street, Aaaheim, Caiifornia, and DA~ !d. amd
NU. F-56-57-77 DBIJA M. RIDBdVC, 1919 Hast Center Street, Affiheim, Califaraia, as
. Owners, requesting that the property described as 1927 East 3:ea~bes
Street and 19x9 Hast Center Street, Anat~e im, C:alifarnia, be =r~c3ass"a-
f ied from R-A, RHSIDENfIAL AQtTCULTURAL to C-1, 1~IC~fiBQtHO~ ~g,. _.
A representative of the applicant appeared before the Co~ass3,un amd
stated that this property is surrounded bq Commercial uses $t 2~
present time and that they have a commitmeat for retail sYore ~~mess-
es. Mrs. Hemmerling~ living on Coffman Avenae, qnestioned ~sr 3fieg
proposed to do with the property and stated ahe heazd that t~ey p]a~ed
to put a nightclub on the property.. It was pointed oug fo 9ars_ ~es-
ling that G-1~ Neighborhoc,d Commercial was asked for 3a ~is ~~~~~~-
fication which wanld permit no such use. Tf~ I~ARZIdG 1°AS ~3:DS~D_
Upoa a motion by Commissioner Gauer, seconded by Commi.ssinmer.~
and carried, it was moved by RSSOLLTION N0. 247 - S~tIBS 3~fi-Sl it~att
the Commission recommend to the City Council that Reclassifi~ti~ 310_
P-56-57-7? be approved for C-1, Neighborhood Commercial.
Thetiote on the above Resolution was as follows:
A7~S: CONAtISSIOI~RS: Gauer, Hapgood, Mauerhan, Morris,.~rs,
Thompson and Mungall.
NOBS: COMMISSIONBRS: None.
ABSIBNf; COh4~lISSIOPffiRS; Bates and DuBois.
RHCIASSIPI- PUBLIC HHARING. PBTITION submitted by QiAVBN WNSTRIICfION i~~8,
CATION 8736 Palm Avenue, Beliflower, ~alifornia, as Appiicaat, 3.. ~_ ~~8',
N0. P-56-57-78 127 FTes7 Broadway, Anaheim, Caiifornia, as Authorized Agea~, a+eg~sta~
that the property described as 9171 South Piaceatia Avenne, 3~e secHass~
fied from R-A, RBSIDBNPIAL AGRICULTURAL to R-3, NIITLTIPL~ ~AMi~Y ~~
DBNf IAL.
A reprasentatine of the appiicant appeared before the C~~~=ixm ~
stated that aii the residents from South Street to Moraga 3tmt weie
ia favor of R-3, Mul4iple Pamily Residential. Thdr propert3rs 3~eamg
located on a State highway, they feel it is not suitable ~~ sim~Se
famil~+ residenklal. Mr. Jce M. Brower, 183F Dianna Avemie, Y~=~
before the Commission and submitted a petition sigaed lry 69 3arag~z~ty
owaers opposing the reciassification to R-3, Multiple i~amii; ~+~~~^-
tial and requesting that it be rezoned to R-1, Single i~cma3~,Resn~-
tia1. Mr. Gii gluthe, residing on Placentia Aveane~ ap e~13~~e
the Commission a~ stated that he was~ in favor of R-3 an~~at i~e
has had his property up for sale and that no one wouid co~as9ffex a~t
for single family use b~t that it aould be sold for R-3 ~s_ 9~_
Daniel Stanford. 1802 Verde Piace atated that this is an 3s3aad a~"
R-A~ Residential Agriculturai aurrainded bq R-1 and tl~at ~e avem3d B~let
to see the property rezoned to R-1 and that this would slimivate 9~
propertq from coming up periodically for other uses. It ~as t~e
feeling of the Commission that the property, situated as i# is am a
ma3or throughfare was not suitable for singie f~ ily nse a~ t~at 7~e
uae requested shouia not be detrimentai 40 other properties an ~ffi
area. THH I~ffiARING WAS CIASED.
Upon a motion by Commiasioner Morris, seconded by C~mmissisaier~6eaer,
and ca.rried, it was moved by RBSOLUTION IdO. 248 - SBRISS 3955 S~ ~a#
the Commission recrnnmend to the City Council that Reclassif3cata'~ ]~_
F-56~57-78 be reclassified to R-3, subject to:
1. That a six foot wall be erected at the lqest I~ne s+f i~ie giro-
perty, where none exiats at the preaent time.
-4-
RSCIASSIPI- 2, That the buiidiaga be reatrieted to siagle atory in
GTION height.
N0. P-S6-57-78 3, That 20 feet sioag Piacentia Avenn~ be dedicated to the
(OONT.) Citq of Anaheim for street xidening.
,; 4. Fiagineering Requirementa.
,I
~ The vote on the above Reaolution was as follrnvs:
AYBS: COhAIISSIOI~RS: Gauer~ Hapgood, Morris~ Mauerhan, Sumne ra,
Thompson a~ Mu:g all.
NOHS: COHAlISSIOI~RS: None.
~ ABSBNf: COIYAlI3SIOI~iRS: Bates and DaHois.
TBNfATIVB MAY The subdividex is HINrZ CONSTRUCfIbN CONIPANY, 9901 Garden Grove
OP TRACE N0. Boulevard, Gardea Grove, Califernia. This subdiviaiun xill be loca-
2903 ted at Lhe Northwest corner of NinLh and Kate114 Avenues and will con-
tain 106 resideatisi lots.
No one appeared before the Commission repreaenting the subdivider or
Bagiaeer on this Tract. Mr. Vandenberg, a property ownes iocated on
the West aide of this tract aad Mr. Douglas, a propertiy oxner located
oa the North side of this tract appeared before the Co~ission. Theq
t~ere concerned with the pipe line presentiy extending acrosa the
property amd serving theis grovea with irrigation xater, They atated
that they had beea uaabie to get any commitment from Action Bngineer-
ing Compaay with regard to the relocatiea of thia pipelir.e snd ~+here
the atand pipes wouid be located. These stand pipes are presently 10
feet high and the liae is either 14'or 16 inchea in diaateter. They
also aLated for their own protection, that they would wuri: to aee the
aubdivider erect a 6 foota~lid concrete wali oa the South side of Mr.
Dougias~s property aad on the Bast side cf Mr. Vaffieaberg~a p~opertq~
with a chaia iiak fence extending Northxqrd along the Nleat aide of the
fiood controi channe! extending NorLheriy to the railroad tracts.
Upoa a motion bq Commissioner Gauer, secouded bq Commieaioner Mauerhan,
it was moved that Lhe Tentative Map of Tract No, 2903 be returaed to
the Actioa Hagiaeeriag Company aad the subdivider to aee if the differ-
ences between these two property awners and the aubdirider couid be
reconciled.
SUBJBCf: ~~ The Commieaion received a Letter fram Ccsa,misaioner poneld R. Hates
I requesting that his resignation from the Citq Plan,~ing Commisaioa be
DONA7D R. BATBS accepted due to the preasure of bnaiaess aad aiso due t~ ~he fact that
he ia moviag from the Citq of Aaaheim to Lemon Heighta.
Upon a motios. by Commisaioner Gauer, seconded bq Commiasioner Swnmera,
and carried, it was moved that the Reaignation of Commisaioner Bates
be accepted with regret and that he be commended for h~a able work
aad intereats whiie a Member of the Commiesion.
ADJdI~tI~Il~ffiNf The Meetiag Ad3ouraed at 4:32 0*Ciock P.M.
-5-
.:..~.,.r.,m ~,...,,,p~,--- --~ -
l J l_)