Loading...
29 (4) Public Comment From:Meridith Gill <meridith@diversifiedhoa.com> Sent:Tuesday, August 9, 2022 10:29 AM To:Public Comment Subject:\[EXTERNAL\] City Meeting August 9, 2022 Agenda Item Attachments:Parkdale THOA Letter to the City of Anaheim 8-8-22.docx; City of Buena Park Sewer Plans.pdf; Parkdale THOA Attorney Letter 8-8-22.pdf Warning: This email originated from outside the City of Anaheim. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and are expecting the message. Good afternoon. Please see attached items I would like to submit to the City Council on behalf of myself and Parkdale THOA in regard to agenda item – 1442 N. Dale Ave. Thank you, Meridith Gill | Senior HOA Manager, Diversified Association Management cell: | main: 714.544.7755 ext. 114 180 E. Main St. Ste. 101 | Tustin, CA 92708 Office hours: Mon-Fri 8:30 am-4:30 pm. Disclaimer The information contained in this communication from the sender is confidential. It is intended solely for use by the recipient and others authorized to receive it. If you are not the recipient, you are hereby notified that any disclosure, copying, distribution or taking action in relation of the contents of this information is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful. 1 Parkdale THOA has not approved nor agreed to proposed plans. • Adequate notice has not been given to Parkdale THOA homeowners by the City of Anaheim notifying them of the meeting date for appeal. • Public records requested for sewer and water lines not provided in an adequate time by the City of Anaheim. • Outreach the developer has made to Parkdale THOA has been solely for the benefit of the developer only and appears to be an obligation to meet requirements for development. • Board members and homeowners need to protect their biggest investment and the integrity of their community. • The sole responsibility to draft a maintenance agreement is the burden of the developer, not the HOA. • Developer has not submitted any agreements in writing for maintenance prior to approval as requested by homeowners and in an open forum at the July 6, 2022 City Planning Meeting. This includes but is not limited to street, sewer, public utilities. • A demand has been made by Parkdale's attorney to the developer requesting a maintenance plan in writing. • Communications via email and in writing will be provided upon request. COMMUNICATION OUTREACH September 7, 2021: Developer met with Board, Homeowners, and Management on-site to inform them of proposed plans and purchase. This was not at a scheduled Board meeting. October 6, 2021: Parkdale’s THOA’s attorney contacted developer. Maintenance and utility plans were not submitted by the developer for review. November 3, 2021: Developer attended monthly Parkdale THOA meeting and discussed concerns and proposed plans with homeowners. Items of concerns and plans discussed with the homeowners and developer were not submitted in writing by the developer. December January 19, 2022: Meridith Gill emailed developer and City of Anaheim Planning Department list of concerns homeowners have regarding proposed project (access to the community, drainage, parking, perimeter wall height, construction, requesting a copy of the environmental impact report, safety concerns, and utility connections). January 20, 2022: ZOOM meeting with City of Anaheim, Developer and Parkdale THOA Board Member and Management. Direct concerns regarding The City of Buena Park access to lines within the community were discussed by Meridith Gill. Developer stated Ken Kim at the City of Buena Park was contacted and will work with the City. Agreement was not met by Parkdale THOA to access lines. January 21, 2022: Walden & Associates emailed Meridith Gill (Parkdale’s manager) a proposed utility plan that was presented at the meeting. Environmental impact report and a written maintenance plan were not submitted. June 29, 2022: ZOOM Meeting with Parkdale THOA homeowners, Tary Loomis-Therrian (HOA’s attorney), Meridith Gill (manager) and Developer. Homeowners directly discussed the affect accessing water and sewer lines will have on Parkdale THOA as they have been exclusively used by Parkdale THOA homeowners for over 40 years. Developer discussed City of Anaheim approval to access lines on shared easement and stated their plans for sewer and water access on shared easement were public record and could be accessed at the City. A written maintenance plan was not submitted by the developer and requested. CITY OF ANAHEIM COMMUNICATION – APPEAL July 6, 2022: City Planning Meeting held. July 13, 2022: Appeal filed by Parkdale THOA. Meridith Gill filed on behalf of Parkdale THOA in person and was told by the City Clerk a public meeting would be held within 60 days of filing. A calendar of the City Meeting schedule was given to Meridith Gill by the City Clerk, and she was told the City would contact her to confirm appeal and date. July 14, 2022: Judy Boiseranc text a homeowner in Parkdale she had received notice of appeal and was told by the City the meeting was to be held on 8-9-22. July 26, 2022: Management emailed City Clerk stating an appeal of the Planning Commission’s decision was filed on July 13, 2022 requesting additional information on the appeal and for the meeting date it will discussed. July 28, 2022: At 6:08 P.M. City Clerk emailed Meridith Gill a copy of the letter in regard to the appeal with the meeting date (August 9, 2022). August 1, 2022: Notice posted on a street light pole on Dale St. for Public Hearing. Pole on the exterior of the community. NOTICE POSTED LESS THAN 10 DAYS BEFORE MEETING (8 days prior). August 3, 2022: Parkdale THOA homeowner received meeting notice from the City of Anaheim in the mail. LESS THAN 10 DAYS BEFORE MEETING (5 days prior). August 4, 2022: Meridith Gill received meeting notice from the City of Anaheim in the mail. LESS THAN 10 DAYS BEFORE MEETING (4 days prior). UTILITIES COMMUNICATION January 21, 2022-May 11, 2022: Walden & Associates and Developer started an email chain with The City of Buena Park and Management. Walden & Associates stated an agreement with The City of Anaheim and Diversified/Parkdale HOA was made regarding the development of the Project on Dale and all parties agreed on the proposed connections for the Sewer and Water lines within the existing HOA. This was not approved by Parkdale THOA and the details and shared costs were not resolved. May 2, 2022: City of Buena Park sent response letter to Developer, subject: WATER AND SEWER WILL-SERVE LETTER AT 1442 N. DALE AVE. Letter in response to request for a will-serve letter. In addition, the sewer and water plans will need to be approved by Buena Park as well as Anaheim. If there are any pressure or capacity deficiencies to the water and sewer mains, the developer shall mitigate the deficiencies. July 13, 2022: Meridith Gill attempted to access plans submitted to the City by the Developer to access the sewer and water lines as well as a flow meter test. July 26, 2022: Meridith Gill was told by Public Works they may not be public record, and they would verify. July 26, 2022: Public Works emailed Meridith Gill sewer sizing for Dale project directly from the City. Flow test was not preformed, only by analysis. Water line access plans were not provided 8/8/22, 11:59 AM Sewer Plans https://www.buenapark.com/city_departments/public_works/engineering_services/sewer_plans.php 1/1 Sewer Plans The City of Buena Park Sewer Services Division is responsible for operating and maintaining more than 200 miles of sanitary sewer mains each year, as well as well as more than 3,400 manholes. The Division provides routine and emergency main line cleaning and helps to review sewer lines for maintenance and repairs. This includes the video inspection of approximately 200,000 feet of sewer line each year. Use the map below to view sewer lines within the city, or open the whole map in it's own tab here. Note that you can click on a sewer line or point to display information about that item, including a link to download the available plans for that item. City of Anaheim, City of Fullerton, County of Los Angeles, Bureau of L… 300ft300ft300ft300ft300ft Find address or place -117.983 33.855 Degrees + – Sewer Services Mapping App with Web AppBuilder for ArcGIS Phone: (949) 459-0906 Fax: (949) 459-0916 LAW OFFICE OF TARY C. LOOMIS-THERRIEN 23272 Mill Creek Dr., Ste 130 Laguna Hills, California 92653 August 8, 2022 e-mail: tary@tloomislaw.com Via First Class Mail and Email to: chris@bonannidevelopment.com Chris Segesman Bonanni Development 5500 Bolsa Avenue, Suite 120 Huntington Beach, CA 92649 Re: New Development at 1442 N. Dale, Anaheim, CA My Client: Parkdale Town Home Owners Association Dear Mr. Segesman; Pursuant to our discussion at last month’s special meeting, I am legal counsel for the Parkdale Town Home Owners Association. My client objects to the utility and access easement you are claiming and intending to use over and under my client’s property, for the new development at 1442 N. Dale in the City of Anaheim, without adequate assurances, compensation and protection for, and arising from those uses (including mitigation of the negative impact on my client’s property). Although you list your “community outreach” efforts for the City, any claim to have provided assurances and solutions for my client are misleading: to date this has only been vague talk, with no documentation or formalization of any agreement or terms. Community outreach, regardless of how extensive, if it does not resolve my client’s objections and issues, it is inadequate. To resolve the dispute, my client proposes that Bonanni Development (and its new development at 1442 N. Dale in Anaheim, the “Development”) and my client enter into a maintenance agreement, which will control the terms of use and provide for the maintenance of those proposed shared amenities and the adjacent facilities on my client’s property. The following is an initial list of terms to be included. This list is not complete, as it is understood that during the drafting of the maintenance agreement, further concerns will arise and be addressed. 1. The new easement and maintenance agreement will be generally set forth in the CC&RS of the Development; 2. The Development’s CC&Rs shall provide that owners, residents, tenants and their family members, guests and invitees, will not use Peppertree Dr. nor the alley other than for ingress and engress; 3. The Development’s CC&Rs shall disclose that the Development is a separate residential development from Parkdale Town Home Owners Association, and there are no rights of use of any of, but not including the Parkdale’s common areas, recreational facilities, and parking; Chris Segesman Bonanni Development August 8, 2022 Page 2 of 2 4.The Block wall will be constructed to a height of 6' or 8'. The Development’s CC&Rs shall provide that the Development shall maintain, repair and replace the Block wall in first class condition at all times, as originally built including, but not limited to the same design, location, length, height and width; 5. Plans and contracts for access, installation, use, maintenance, and repair of utility tie- ins, shall be mutually agreed upon by both parties before submitting for permits or commencing work; the exception being in the case of emergencies where damage to persons or property is occurring or imminent; 6. Original installation of utility tie-ins will not unreasonably block ingress and egress to Parkdale Town Home Owners Association; sidewalks will be made accessible to pedestrians, and streets will be made accessible for pedestrians and vehicles during the hours of 5:00 p.m. each evening to 7:30 a.m. each morning, Monday-Friday; and the whole of Saturday and Sunday, and all holidays. This will be accomplished by back filling and leveling all completed areas to make them safe for ingress and egress, and using steel plates over open trenches, making the entire area safe for ingress and egress. Upon completion of original installation, all impacted areas, including but not limited to streets, landscaping, sidewalks, and walkways, will be restored to new condition by Bonanni Devolvement - this requires replacement of the asphalt street the length and width of Peppertree Dr. up to and including the intersection of Weeping Willow and also the alley (if the same is impacted by the utility tie-in work) all to new condition, and slurry coat the remaining of Peppertree Dr, and all intersecting streets; 7. Complete, finished, detailed architectural, engineering, fire protection, electrical, sewer, and all utilities plans or contract documents, for all improvements, present and future, to the Easement, including but not limited to all special improvements or additions required for building purposes, must be submitted to by client; and 8.The Development will pay (after original installation) 10.1% for all future costs of maintenance, repair and replacement of utility lines and tie-ins in the easement, and for the asphalt maintenance, repair and periodic replacement of the alley access easement. Please get back to me the first of next week, with your agreement to beginning working on and drafting the proposed maintenance agreement. My client requests that this maintenance agreement be completed and signed by all parties before any work commences for the Development. Very truly yours, Tary C. Loomis-Therrien TCLT: T:\0137\000\1442 Dale Developement\Segesman - Bonanni L01.wpd