Loading...
Attachment 7 - Noise StudyVeneklasen Associates Consultants in Acoustics | Noise | Vibration | AV | IT 1711 Sixteenth Street • Santa Monica California 90404 • tel: 310.450.1733 • fax: 310.396.3424 • www.veneklasen.com September 27, 2022 Red Hook Capital Partners 2120 East Grand Ave, Suite #135 El Segundo, CA 90245 Attention: Ingrid Canedo | Project Manager Subject: 2780 East Wagner Anaheim, California Property Line Noise Assessment Veneklasen Project No. 6338-005 Dear Ingrid, Veneklasen Associates, Inc. (Veneklasen) provides the following assessment of the expected noise due to the future operation of the proposed 2780 East Wagner project and how it affects adjacent residential properties located west of the proposed space. Noise is compared to the City of Anaheim noise criteria, as applicable. This report documents our acoustical comments. 1.0 INTRODUCTION This study was conducted to determine the impact of the expected noise due to the future operation of the 2780 East Wagner project in Anaheim, California. Veneklasen’s scope of work included calculating the expected future exterior noise levels impacting the site, comparing them against existing conditions and determining the method, if any, required to reduce the interior and exterior sound levels to meet the applicable code requirements of the City of Anaheim. The project is an Educational Institution-General Use proposed by Scholarship Prep Public Schools at an existing church and school site. The project is bounded by East Wagner Ave to the north, existing residential uses to the west, and a flood basin to the east and south. Orange freeway (CA-57) is located at the west side three blocks away. 2.0 NOISE CRITERIA Leq (equivalent continuous sound level) is defined as the steady sound pressure level which, over a given period of time, has the same total energy as the actual fluctuating noise. 2.1 Municipal Code The Anaheim Municipal Code, Chapter 6.70 Sound Pressure Levels, Section 6.70.010, Established, states this: No person shall within the City create any sound radiated for extended periods from any premises which produces a sound pressure level at any point on the property line in excess of sixty decibels (Re 0.0002 Microbar) read on the A-scale of a sound level meter. Readings shall be taken in accordance with the instrument manufacturer’s instructions, using the slowest meter response. The sound level measuring microphone shall be placed at any point on the property line, but not closer than three (3) feet from any wall and not less than three (3) feet above the ground, where the above listed maximum sound pressure level shall apply. At any point the measured level shall be the average of not less than three (3) readings taken at two (2) minute intervals. To have valid readings, the levels must be five (5) decibels or more above the levels prevailing at the same point when the source’s of the alleged objectionable sound are not operating. ATTACHMENT NO. 7 Veneklasen Associates 2780 East Wagner; Anaheim, California Property Line Noise Assessment Veneklasen Project No. 6338-005 September 27, 2022–Page 2 www.veneklasen.com In summary, the project noise levels (children’s activities over an extended period) shall not raise the noise level on the adjacent residential property to more than 60 dBA. 3.0 EXTERIOR NOISE ENVIRONMENT 3.1 Noise Measurements Veneklasen visited the site on Tuesday, April 12, 2022 and completed short-term noise measurements using an NTi XL2 Sound Level Meter. Appendix II provides additional information related to the noise measurements. Table 1 and Figure 1 show the location and summary of the noise measurements, based on the current facility operations and the expected future noise sources. Table 1 – Measured Sound Levels Location Description Leq dBA S1 Loud chat of kids at snack time, 5 feet away. 72 S2 Ambient background noise levels, between spaces 61 S3 Ambient background noise levels, open area 58 S4 Teenagers playing basketball, freeway noise at distance 63 Figure 1 – Aerial View of Project Site Showing Measurement Locations 3.2 Computer Modeling Veneklasen has utilized computer noise modeling software in order to predict noise levels from future school activities from locations marked in the new design. Veneklasen Associates 2780 East Wagner; Anaheim, California Property Line Noise Assessment Veneklasen Project No. 6338-005 September 27, 2022–Page 3 www.veneklasen.com The primary purpose of the computer model was to determine the noise levels at the property line of the residential area to the west of the project site due to the new number of students and outdoor activities. Table 2 shows the outdoor activities and their number of students as provided by the client. Table 2 – Outdoor Activities Information Outdoor Activity # of students Electives 120 – 180 Recess 120 – 180 Lunch 60 – 120 Afterschool program Up 120 Drop-off/Pickup Up 480 The information shown in Table 2 was used in the calculations. Appendix I provide the simulation of expected noise levels for different scenarios for the area surrounding the project site. The values shown in figures on Appendix I do not include the background noise levels at site. 3.3 Noise Assessment Veneklasen assessed the potential noise due to the noise sources and the new number of students attending Scholarship Prep at East Wagner Avenue. By using the scenarios from the simulations, Veneklasen has predicted the expected noise at the property line of concern. The analysis was completed with taking into account the reduction in sound level due to distance and shielding from buildings. Noise levels obtained from the S1 and S4 measurements were used as sample of noise to recreate Recess, Lunch, Electives and Afterschool program activities. A noise measurement taken recently from another school project was used to recreate the Drop-off/pick-up noise levels. The extended expected levels at the property line, as determined from the computer model were used in the calculation of the expected noise levels due to the new layout. The client specified that the outside use of intercom or bell system won’t be implemented for this project. The results expected at the residential property line, after considering the new number of students per activity and their predicted exterior noise levels due the new layout is 60 dBA or less. This result takes into consideration the city requirement for a 15 ft setback from the property line, the existing solid wall along the property line, the orientation of the buildings, and the background noise levels combined with the results obtained from the simulations presented in Appendix I. The predicted noise levels under the new layout is not expected to exceed 60 dBA over an extended period of time, which is in compliance to the noise criteria set by the City of Anaheim noise ordinance. 4.0 SUMMARY Veneklasen was contracted to assess any potential noise disturbance to an adjacent receptor due to the proposed new design and increase of number of students to 480. Acoustical measurements were taken of typical current exterior noise activities in the existing space and used to calculate expected receiver noise levels at the sensitive neighboring residential properties. According to our calculations, noise levels at the residential area are expected to be in compliance with the City of Anaheim Municipal Code requirements summarized above without any modifications to the proposed design. Veneklasen Associates 2780 East Wagner; Anaheim, California Property Line Noise Assessment Veneklasen Project No. 6338-005 September 27, 2022–Page 4 www.veneklasen.com If you have any questions or comments regarding this report, please do not hesitate to contact us. Sincerely, Veneklasen Associates, Inc. Colin Spohr, Cathleen Novak Senior Associate Associate Veneklasen Associates 2780 East Wagner; Anaheim, California Property Line Noise Assessment Veneklasen Project No. 6338-005 September 27, 2022–Page 5 www.veneklasen.com APPENDIX I – SIMULATION OF ACTIVITIES NOISE LEVELS Figure 2 – Simulation of Drop-off/Pick-up (90/120 students) Noise Levels, Leq, dBA *note that the light blue box in Figure 2 denotes pick up and drop off area Figure 3 – Simulation of Drop-off/Pick-up (up to 480 students) Noise Levels, Leq, dBA *note that the light blue box in Figure 3 denotes pick up and drop off area Veneklasen Associates 2780 East Wagner; Anaheim, California Property Line Noise Assessment Veneklasen Project No. 6338-005 September 27, 2022–Page 6 www.veneklasen.com Figure 4 – Simulation of Play Areas (90/120 students) Noise Levels, Leq, dBA *note that the light blue box in Figure 4 denotes student play area Figure 5 – Simulation of Play Areas (up to 180 students) Noise Levels, Leq, dBA *note that the light blue box in Figure 4 denotes student play area Veneklasen Associates 2780 East Wagner; Anaheim, California Property Line Noise Assessment Veneklasen Project No. 6338-005 September 27, 2022–Page 7 www.veneklasen.com APPENDIX II – MEASURED HOURLY NOISE LEVELS Location Start Time Duration LAeq S1 3:19 pm 0:04:00 72 S2 3:28 pm 0:10:00 61 S3 3:41 pm 0:18:00 58 S4 4:32 pm 0:02:30 63