01/09/2024ANAHEIM CITY COUNCIL
REGULAR MEETING OF JANUARY 9, 2024
The regular meeting of January 9, 2024 was called to order at 3:02 p.m. in the Council Chamber of
Anaheim City Hall, located at 200 S. Anaheim Boulevard. The meeting notice, agenda, and related
materials were duly posted on January 4, 2024.
MEMBERS PRESENT: Mayor Ashleigh E. Aitken and Council Members Norma Campos Kurtz,
Jose Diaz, Natalie Rubalcava, Stephen Faessel, and Natalie Meeks
MEMBERS ABSENT: Council Member Carlos A. Leon
STAFF PRESENT: City Manager Jim Vanderpool, City Attorney Robert Fabela, and City
Clerk Theresa Bass
ADDITIONS/DELETIONS TO CLOSED SESSION: None
PUBLIC COMMENTS ON CLOSED SESSION ITEMS: None
CLOSED SESSION: At 3:02 p.m., Mayor Aitken recessed to closed session for consideration of the
following:
CONFERENCE WITH LEGAL COUNSEL — EXISTING LITIGATION
(Subdivision (d)(1) of Section 54956.9 of the California Government Code)
Name of Case: Lopez et al. v. City of Anaheim, et al., USDC Case No. 8-22-cv-01351-JVS
2. CONFERENCE WITH LEGAL COUNSEL —ANTICIPATED LITIGATION
Initiation of litigation pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (d) of California
Government Code Section 54956.9: One potential case
3. AUDIT BY CALIFORNIA STATE AUDITOR'S OFFICE
Government Code Section 54956.75
At 5:05 p.m., Mayor Aitken reconvened the Anaheim City Council.
MEMBERS PRESENT:
MEMBERS ABSENT:
Mayor Ashleigh E. Aitken and Council Members Norma Campos Kurtz,
Jose Diaz, Natalie Rubalcava, Stephen Faessel, and Natalie Meeks
Council Member Carlos A. Leon
Mayor Aitken announced the absence of Council Member Leon due to a family loss.
INVOCATION:
FLAG SALUTE:
Sheikh Mohammad El Zahed, Islamic Institute of Orange County
Council Member Jose Diaz
PRESENTATIONS: Recognizing City of Anaheim Employee Retirees with 20+ years of service
Mayor Aitken highlighted the work of the City's dedicated employees. She thanked the retirees for
their service and wished them all a happy retirement. Director of Human Resources Linda Andal
thanked the Mayor, City Council, and City Manager for their continued recognition. She presented the
City Council Minutes of January 9, 2024
Page 2 of 19
recognitions to the retirees, Richard Hannum, Mi-Jae Kim, and Ralph McCaffrey. She also recognized
an additional retiree Dave Berry who was not in attendance.
Planning Commission Presentation
Planning Commission Chairperson Lucille Kring reported the Planning Commission is an advisory
body to the City Council on land use matters. She noted the Commission is comprised of seven (7)
members who are appointed by the City Council. The Commissioner's terms are concurrent with the
appointing Council Member's term. She reported the Commission meets every other Monday at 5:00
p.m. in the City Council Chamber. She presented the members of the Planning Commission, Vice -
Chair Grant Henninger, At -Large; Jeanne Tran-Martin, District 2; Michelle Lieberman, District 3;
LuisAndres Perez, District 4; Christopher Walker, District 5; and Amelia Castro, District 6. She
reported the City Charter grants duties to the Planning Commission to make recommendations to the
Council on the physical development of the City, to review subdivisions, zoning, building, and land
use matters, and to perform other functions delegated by the City Council. Additionally, in 2000 the
City Council approved a resolution adopting procedures and rules of order for the conduct of Planning
Commission meetings and outlining the process for public discussion with a specific order for
applicants, proponents, and opponents.
Mayor Aitken on behalf of the City Council thanked Chairperson Kring and the Planning Commission
for their work for the community.
ACCEPTANCE OF OTHER RECOGNITIONS iTo be presented at a later date):
Recognizing January 11, 2024, as Human Trafficking Awareness Day
Waymakers Victim Advocate Linda Tran thanked the Council on behalf of the Orange County Human
Trafficking Task Force and provided background information on the Task Force, noting it has been
federally recognized as one of the Top 50 nationally. She reported in 2022 the organization assisted
420 victims of human trafficking with about 40% of the sex trafficking victims being minors. She
added the top referral source is the Anaheim Police Department (APD) and commended their
partnership in helping the City lead the way Countywide.
APD Lieutenant Willie Triplett thanked the Council on behalf of the APD and credited the
collaboration with Waymakers, federal partners, and other regional police departments to the APD's
success.
Recognizing January 2024, as National Mentoring Month
Big Brothers Big Sisters Family Engagement Manager Jessica Gonzalez accepted the recognition
and spoke of the over 6,000 youths successfully impacted by its mentoring programs over the last 60
years. She reported the program is focused on justice, equity, diversity, and inclusion, focusing on the
needs of the youth. She reported the program focuses on four key outcomes social capital and
connectedness, social and emotional mental health, education and career success, and positive
behaviors and choices. She noted that 98% of their students graduate high school on time, many of
them being the first in their families to both do so and also attend college. She encouraged the
Council Members and the public to become youth mentors.
City Council Minutes of January 9, 2024
Page 3 of 19
ADDITIONS/DELETIONS TO THE AGENDA:
City Clerk Bass announced that Consent Calendar Item No. 08 was withdrawn from the agenda by
staff. Consent Calendar Item No. 15 was requested by staff to be continued to the January 23, 2024
Council meeting.
PUBLIC COMMENTS (all agenda itemsS. Prior to receipt of public comments, City Clerk Theresa
Bass provided an outline of procedures for public comments, notice of translation services, and a
brief decorum.
City Clerk Bass reported that a total of 11 public comments were received electronically prior to 5:00
p.m. related to City Council agenda items and matters within the jurisdiction of the Anaheim City
Council. [A final total of 13 public comments were received electronically, distributed to the City
Council, and made part of the official records]. — See Appendix.
Marlena Truong, a member of State Senator Tom Umberg's staff, reported Senator Umberg's office
has submitted a letter of support for the Little Arabia freeway signs in Item No. 16. She read the letter
expressing State Senator Umberg's enthusiasm for the positive impact the signs will have for Orange
County's Arab -American cultural hub as a celebration of the State's unique cultural tapestry. She
added recognizing Little Arabia through the designation fosters unity, supports local businesses, and
promotes the diverse heritage that makes California unique and a more inclusive and welcoming
state. The letter includes Senator Umberg's endorsement for the "Little Arabia District" sign.
Ahn Pham thanked the Council for its support of improving the Brookhurst Corridor. He
recommended placing a focus on safety as the Corridor is redeveloped and increasing both the
APD's ability to address crime on the Corridor and improving its physical condition. He reported
several incidents of graffiti. He added a pedestrian was recently killed on Brookhurst Street and noted
a center median could have assisted them while crossing the seven -lane street.
Mayor Aitken requested City Manager Vanderpool look into graffiti removal orders for a report
of the graffiti Mr. Pham discussed.
Ayah Shiadah, Program Manager for the Arab -American Civic Council, thanked the Council for
agendizing a Little Arabia freeway sign, adding such recognition has been a dream of many. She
encouraged the Council to approve the item.
Amin Nash paid his respects to Council Member Leon for the loss of his grandmother. He thanked the
Council and City staff for their work on behalf of Little Arabia. He stated the quest for a freeway sign
has been a wonderful adventure and added Anaheim will be the first place in the United States with a
Little Arabia freeway sign. He commended the City for investing in the community through this
initiative. He encouraged also adding a Little Arabia sign on California State Route 22.
Mahmoud Saad thanked the Council for its help in the Arab -American community. He mentioned he
moved to Anaheim from Northern California due to its diversity and inclusivity. He encouraged the
City Council to approve Item No. 16 to acknowledge the Arabic community.
Vern Nelson congratulated the Arabic community for the Little Arabia freeway signs, noting many
have supported it for decades. He encouraged the Arabic community to continue to come to Council
meetings to speak out in 2024 on Disneyland Forward and campaign finance reform. He decried the
high costs of running a successful District election campaign and added costs would not be inflated
with the correct campaign finance reform. He called for a new recusal rule or in its place a discussion
City Council Minutes of January 9, 2024
Page 4 of 19
of publicly -financed elections. He expressed hope the Council will fight in the interests of the
residents in the forthcoming Disneyland Forward discussions, with a Workshop scheduled for January
23rd. He expressed concerns about Disney's lack of assistance for affordable housing and the
company privatizing a pair of public streets. He added a 2% Gate Tax would go far to placate
concerned residents through the revenue it would generate.
Nathan Bass, a District Representative for State Senator Josh Newman, reported Senator Newman
has asked him to convey his strong support for Item No. 16, freeway signage for Little Arabia. He
reported on Senator Newman's enjoyable patronage of Little Arabia's businesses and his
appreciation for the community's place in Southern California's diversity. He reported the resolution's
adoption is the last statutory requirement for cultural destination freeway signs, adding how the signs
will bring sales revenue to Little Arabia.
Cassandra Perez, District Director for United States Congressman Lou Correa, read a letter from
Congressman Correa in support of Little Arabia and the freeway signage recognition in Item No. 16.
The letter credited the Council for enhancing the cultural vibrancy of the State through its recognition
of Little Arabia and promoting it with highway signs. Congressman Correa noted in the letter, as a
congressional representative in Anaheim, he feels a deep connection to the community and is
enthusiastic about the positive impact the signs will have on the community. He added Little Arabia
serves as a hub for Arab Americans offering a unique experience in Middle Eastern culture and
cuisine.
Adam Overton, an organizer for Clergy and Laity United for Economic Justice (CLUE), urged the
Council to support Item No. 16. He reported when he first moved to Orange County it took him two
years to discover Little Arabia's existence, time he considers lost and he now visits as often as
possible. He reported always feeling safe and welcome as a Jew in Little Arabia even in an era of
bloody conflict between Israel and Palestine. He thanked the Council for the overdue designation and
added it is now time to get signs up and invest in the area's beautification.
Rashad AI-Dabbagh, Executive Director of the Arab -American Civic Council, declared it is a beautiful
day for Anaheim and added it has been a long time coming. He mentioned when he moved to Los
Angeles County twenty years ago, he would drive two to three times a week to Little Arabia because
of the community. He called for a cease-fire in Gaza. He conveyed his long history of advocating for a
designation of Little Arabia beginning with an initial dismissal from then -Mayor Curt Pringle about 20
years ago. He expressed his excitement for the planned improvements and encouraged the Council
to approve Item No. 16.
Penelope Lopez, Organizing Director of Chispa Orange County, stated her support for Item No. 16.
She related how she and her Mexican immigrant family feel safe living near Little Arabia and it is
where she chooses to raise her daughter.
Afaf EI-Anan expressed her support for the Little Arabia freeway sign out of building community
identity and fostering support. She thanked the Council for their support of the item.
Ali EI-Anan offered his condolences to Council Member Leon. He expressed his appreciation for the
City's investment and support of one of its diverse units. He endorsed the highway signage and
thanked Mr. Nash for informing him Anaheim would be the first U.S. city to have such a sign.
Fawad M.S. Yacoob requested the Council approve Item No. 16 and commended the direction the
City has taken. He added Little Arabia can be a source of pride for Muslims and non -Muslims alike
through its celebration of Anaheim's diversity.
City Council Minutes of January 9, 2024
Page 5 of 19
Kenneth Batiste reported he grew up in the 1970s when the emphasis was on love over hate but
today issues like poverty and homelessness are growing and stated the City should be doing more
about it with its resources. He stated the City has to post Little Arabia signs to conceal intentions
regarding diversity and cited the City's approval of Indigenous Day. He theorized many denied the
designation of Little Arabia so as not to create competition for Disneyland. He stated Little Arabia has
added prosperity to an area in need of attention and Little Arabia's onset. He said the freeway signs
would be a positive sign of change.
Arlene Castro reported her now-96-year-old mother-in-law took out a Community Development Block
Grant (CDBG) loan from the City 20 years ago. She reported her mother-in-law explained the City
forgave the repayment because the workmanship was poor. She reported City staff recently found no
evidence of it being forgiven and reported her $47,710 loan will now be $73,516 to repay in addition
to there now being a City lien on the home despite never conveying this fact. She added the City later
notified her she would not have to pay this until her mother-in-law passes. She decried the lack of
transparency as she and her family struggled to pay over $30,000 of interest for which they were
never notified.
Mayor Aitken thanked Ms. Castro for sharing this information and requested City Manager
Vanderpool look into it.
Ruben G. Soto quoted a passage from the Bible admonishing people who disregard those in need.
He reported being mistreated by the APD and not receiving sufficient assistance through the City's
homeless programs. He stated people are using God for money.
Mark Richard Daniels expressed his condolences to Council Member Leon and his family. He
reported last night the National Weather Service issued a rare freeze warning for Southern California
yet people are enduring it on the streets in such a rich nation. He stated the nation has failed, noting
corporations, government, and individuals can do more for those in need. He encouraged distributing
blankets to the homeless community due to the cold weather.
Cecil Jordan Corkern stated he found his reports on alleged misconduct by the Walt Disney Company
and added he has been working on his report since 2017. He expressed hope his girlfriend would get
better. He reported speaking with Walt Disney who he stated was still alive. He encouraged anyone
concerned to pray for him.
Mike Robbins stated Disneyland is a thriving industrial complex in Anaheim. He noted how the theme
park continues to expand closer to his house. He stated the new proposed size of the park is foolish
and threatens to bring a cascade of problems to the neighborhoods around the park. He urged the
Council to consider the increased air and noise pollution impacts from the proposed expansion which
would come within 100 feet of homes. He reported every vote taken against the health of residents
will be sent to the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI), California Attorney General, and other
comparable offices due to the large amounts of money Disney contributes to the Council's
campaigns.
Jeanine Robbins expressed her concerns over the proposed expansion of Disneyland. She added
the theme park hurts the lives of the employees who contribute to its success as they struggle to
survive on their low salaries and sometimes even find themselves homeless despite having income
from their Disney jobs. She reported 10% of Disneyland employees grapple with homelessness and
50% are food insecure, needing public benefits despite working for a $150 billion corporation. She
stated Disney employees deserve better. She urged the Council to consider the well-being of Disney
employees as they discuss theme park expansion, including a discussion of affordable housing. She
City Council Minutes of January 9, 2024
Page 6 of 19
noted the project's Environmental Impact Report (EIR) has no provision for affordable housing for
either Disney's current or future employees of the expanded park. She decried adding more
employees who will also depend on Anaheim's public subsidies.
Matthew Duncan stated he is a staunch opponent of the City's coyote trapping program. He reported
the City demonizes coyotes as being wild and dangerous animals and sanitizes the City's methods of
killing trapped coyotes in a gas chamber. He reported the City's documentation claims its contractor,
Coyote, Wildlife and Pest Solutions, Inc., is the only company providing trapping services with the
endorsement of the California Department of Fish and Wildlife. He reported he spoke with the
contractor's owner, Jimmy Rizzo, but added Mr. Rizzo acknowledged he is not endorsed by the State.
He urged City staff to use caution in what it says while legitimizing its trapper.
Joe Otero reported he worked for the City of Norwalk for 26 years and Fullerton College before
retiring 11 years ago. He stated he has worked over the years to improve the area around Willow
Park, near his home, including working with the homeless and adding speed bumps and street
lighting. He added the homeless are returning to Willow Park and bemoaned that no one on the
current Council will help his neighborhood like former Council Member Jose Moreno used to. He
reported he worked in Public Works for Norwalk and has some expertise but the City's Public Works
staff disagrees with his assessment of a dead tree that recently shed a branch in front of his house.
He inquired what his next steps are to have the tree removed including hiring an arborist on his own.
Mayor Aitken requested a Public Works staff member meet with Mr. Otero to discuss the tree.
Denise Barnes thanked Mayor Aitken for attending an outreach event, adding it means a lot to
residents of the west side of Anaheim in particular when they see Council Members in person. She
thanked the Council for improvements to Maxwell Park and the City's annual Christmas Tree lighting.
She reported that Maxwell Dog Park needs attention, noting it is budgeted to have full grass and it
does not. She reported Union Pacific has been negligent in clearing the area under Interstate 5 at
Brookhurst Street. She reported when she served on the Council, she recommended holding Union
Pacific accountable for the area and recommended litigation like the City of Santa Ana. She thanked
the Council for their continued efforts toward transparency, however, recommended additional reform
including cell phone usage while the Council is in session. She decried the lack of comments from
Planning Commission meetings, particularly in light of Disneyland Forward on the horizon.
Marc Herbert stated the Council needs to continue addressing the corruption allegations amidst the
pleas of former Mayor Harry Sidhu and former Chamber of Commerce Chief Executive Officer Todd
Ament, who face lengthy prison sentences. He decried the Council for not holding a public workshop
dedicated to the independent investigator's findings. He added the FBI's corruption investigation
remains ongoing stating additional information is probably being recovered. He reported Orange
County District Attorney Todd Spitzer recently announced a new criminal investigation into Anaheim's
corruption and the State District Attorney's office will not confirm or deny whether their office is
currently investigating the City. He noted the State's audit of Visit Anaheim also remains pending a
month after its due date. He inquired if the Council will be streaming Planning Commission meetings.
He inquired about the conflict of interest presented recently by Council Member Rubalcava voting on
her husband's pay raise and not recusing herself from the vote, which has not been addressed. He
requested a solution on Fire Station No. 12. He inquired why there has not yet been a public
notification of the January 23rd Workshop on Disneyland Forward, noting Disney's public relations firm
announced the date of the event on December 28, 2023.
City Council Minutes of January 9, 2024
Page 7 of 19
COUNCIL COMMUNICATIONS:
Mayor Pro Tern Kurtz stated that sometimes it takes a holiday season to remind everyone that
"Together We Are Anaheim." She stated that Anaheim is its residents, workers, businesses, and City
staff. She thanked Community Services staff, residents, businesses, and workers in the resort area
because over 500 kids in District 4 received a special surprise in the weeks leading to Christmas.
With generous contributions from 15 hotels and restaurants in the resort area, support from Anaheim
Transportation Network (ATN), and assistance from the Anaheim Community Foundation, toys were
delivered to five different neighborhoods in District 4. She highlighted and shared photographs of toys
being delivered to Guinida Lane, Clifton Avenue, Dakota Street, Roberts Street, and Provential Drive.
Mayor Pro Tern Kurtz thanked The Anaheim Majestic Garden Hotel, Castle Inn & Suites, The
Anaheim Hotel, Grand Legacy At The Park, Courtyard by Marriott, Best Western Plus Stovall's Inn,
Hyatt House, Peacock Suites, The Desert Palms Hotel and Suites, The Pizza Press, Tropicana Inn
and Suites, Alpine Inn, The Westin Anaheim Resort, Cambria Hotel and Suites Anaheim Resort, Del
Sol Inn, and their employees for being a part of the community. She also thanked the Anaheim
Community Foundation team, the Target team at Lincoln Avenue and State College Boulevard, and
the ATN team and their driver Joey who changed his work schedule so he could participate at every
toy distribution. ATN decorated their bus, and the kids were able to enter the bus and select any toy
they wanted. Together, residents, businesses, organizations, labor, and City staff can make a
difference. She stated, "Somos Anaheim, We Are Anaheim."
Council Member Rubalcava wished everyone a Happy New Year and thanked everyone who
provided comments. She stated that she represents District 3, a diverse district that requires her and
her staff to be in the community frequently to understand the needs of residents. Council Member
Rubalcava highlighted and shared photographs of events she participated in. She, along with Council
Member Faessel attended a "Posada" event on Bush Street. Members from Public Utilities who are
also veterans also attended the event. Council Member Rubalcava thanked Jimmy who helped with
this event. She recognized community leader Sophia Romero who organized the event, as well as
City staff, and life-long residents and business owners Shawn and Silvia Albayati. She shared that
David from Vons Grocery Store was Santa Claus at the event. She recognized Colony Wine
Merchant and congratulated the business owners and District 3 residents Sonya, Mike, and family for
celebrating nine years of business in Anaheim. The Colony Wine Merchant has served as a place for
so many members of the community to gather and create joyful memories. The business survived
during the pandemic by delivering wine and charcuterie boards. District 3 hosted a Cops and Cocoa
event at Starbucks (Lincoln Avenue and Anaheim Boulevard). She recognized the members of the
community that engaged with the Community Police Team and highlighted how government and
businesses collaborate to reach out to the community. There were 50 community members in
attendance including Pastor Kyle Bonenberger from City Church. On December 22"d, Mondragon
Family Marget, a business that has been in the community for 45 years, hosted a toy giveaway. She
thanked Anaheim Fire and Rescue for donating 250 toys and the Police Association for donating 75
toys. Members of the Police and Fire Departments attended and welcomed families. On Christmas
Eve, K & A Catering located on Center Street Promenade hosted their 15t' annual community holiday
brunch. She thanked City staff because they played a significant role in making sure the event went
off without a hitch. The family had been experiencing health issues and had not planned on hosting
the event this year. However, in collaboration with the District 3 Office, the Police Department, and
the Fire and Rescue Department, K&A was able to host the event. Approximately 1,000 people
attended the event and received breakfast and had an opportunity to engage with the Police Mounted
Unit, SWAT Team, Anaheim Beautiful, and Anaheim Fire and Rescue. She thanked Anaheim Public
Utilities General Manager, Dukku Lee for attending on Christmas Eve with his family to host a booth
and engage with members of the community. On January 6th, she celebrated and hosted 250
individuals for Dia de los Reyes Magos, which is also known as Three Kings Day. The day is
City Council Minutes of January 9, 2024
Page 8 of 19
celebrated as the day the three wise men first saw baby Jesus and brought him gifts. January 6tn also
closes Christmas festivities. Council Member Rubalcava thanked the Community Services team who
helped secure the venue, the Anaheim Police Association for donating toys, Anaheim Fire and
Rescue, Northgate Market for the Rosca bread donation, K&A Catering for donating toys,
Congressman Lou Correa's Office, Anaheim Public Utilities for providing water, Orange County Labor
Federation for donating bread, Yesenia Rojas, Panaderia La Pequena for donating bread, District 3
Council Aides, and all the volunteers from Anaheim High School. She highlighted Madisson Romero
Alarcon who suggested the event and worked tirelessly to make it happen. There were a lot of
performers at the event as well as a local Girl Scout Troop. Council Member Rubalcava attended the
Anaheim High School ribbon -cutting ceremony for their new track and field. The new field was
developed using Measure A funds. There was a great show of support with attendees including
students, parents, former coaches, administrators, and alumni including Reuben Droughns who
graduated in 1996. He is a CIF wrestling champion, former NFL player, and philanthropist. Council
Member Rubalcava recognized former Anaheim Union High School District Board of Trustees
Member Al Jabbar and current Board of Trustees Member Jessica Guererro who made sure the
project was completed for the benefit of the students.
Council Member Faessel shared that he and his wife Susan are longtime supporters of the Orange
County Justice Center, formerly Anaheim Family Justice Center. This last Christmas Season, the
Orange County Justice Center adopted over 120 families. His wife Susan was instrumental in
handing out gift packages all day long. Council Member Faessel noted that he partnered with the
Anaheim Library Bookmobile and handed out toys at all the Bookmobile stops the week leading up to
Christmas in the Balsam Avenue, La Palma -Anna, and Glenhaven Avenue neighborhoods. He
attended the Grinchmas Celebration at the Sunkist Branch Library and there were over 300
participants. On December 22"d, Yesenia Rojas hosted a Posada event in the La Palma -Anna
neighborhood. Anaheim resident Mark Richard Daniels was Santa Claus. He thanked Fire Chief Pat
Russell for attending the event. Council Member Faessel stated that he was able to visit with his son
and grandkids during the Christmas and New Year's holidays. He stated that his New Year's
resolution is to see grandkids more often
Council Member Diaz wished everyone a Happy New Year. He stated that with every year there are
new challenges and new hopes but nothing that the City can't handle. He expressed condolences to
Council Member Leon for the passing of his grandmother and stated that it is difficult to lose family
members in another country.
Mayor Aitken wished everyone a Happy New Year. She highlighted and shared photographs of
events she attended including Coffee with a Cop in District 2. Those in attendance at the event were
able to decorate cookies and noted that there were many families interacting with the police officers.
She thanked the Anaheim Police Department for all the outreach that they do. Mayor Aitken shared
that she was sworn in as the District 4 Orange County Transportation Authority (OCTA)
Representative. She congratulated and thanked Council Member Diaz for all his hard work over the
past year at OCTA because everyone mentioned how hard working and remarkable, he was as a
Board Member. She stated that she has big shoes to fill but looks forward to guidance as she
assumes the role. Mayor Aitken hosted a Meet Your Mayor event at Home Depot. She thanked staff
at Home Depot for making her a personalized Home Depot apron and thanked everyone in West
Anaheim who attended the event and shared their concerns or shared their excitement regarding the
Brookhurst Corridor Study. In collaboration with the United Across Borders Foundation, Supervisor
Sarmiento's Office, and Ministerios Betesda, Mayor Aitken invited everyone to the Dia de los Reyes
toy giveaway on Thursday, January 11 at the Downtown Anaheim Youth Center
City Council Minutes of January 9, 2024
Page 9 of 19
CITY MANAGER'S UPDATE:
City Manager Vanderpool shared that Anaheim City streets and theme parks will be alive with runners
for the Disney Half Marathon weekend, January 11 -14, 2024. The weekend kicks off with a 5K
starting on Main Street and going through the theme parks. Then on Saturday, the 1 OK goes through
both parks and onto the streets of The Anaheim Resort. On Sunday, the half marathon covers both
parks and goes from The Anaheim Resort to the Platinum Triangle area including Angel Stadium,
ARTIC, and Honda Center. to Angel Stadium, Honda Center, and ARTIC. This marks the return of
these great runs for the first time since 2017. Teams across the City are working to ensure a smooth
event for runners, residents, and businesses. City staff have been sharing routes and other details
on the City's social media and on the homepage of Anaheim.net. For those not taking part, please be
aware of limited road impacts, particularly on Sunday morning. Most impacts are early, from 4:00 a.m.
to 10:00 a.m. Many streets will open by 9:00 a.m. or earlier. He thanked everyone for their patience
as the fun event is welcomed back and brings spending on hotels, dining, and shopping. Which is
funding used to serve the community with police, fire, libraries, community centers, parks, and other
services. City Manager Vanderpool stated that City staff have been gathering data from cities across
California that currently have street vending ordinances. Staff will be presenting a draft Street
Vending Ordinance for City Council consideration at the February 6, 2024 City Council meeting.
CONSENT CALENDAR: At 6:53 p.m., the Consent Calendar was considered with Mayor Pro
Tern Kurtz pulling Item Nos. 04, 05, 09, and 12 for further discussion.
Prior to the vote, Mayor Aitken requested instead of pulling Item No. 2 that staff reach out to Dr.
Christopher Downing to arrange for him to receive the. recognition at a future Council meeting. City
Manager Vanderpool confirmed this will be done.
MOTION: Council Member Faessel moved to waive reading of all ordinances and resolutions and
adopt the balance of the consent calendar as presented, in accordance with reports, certifications,
and recommendations furnished each City Council Member, seconded by Council Member Diaz.
ROLL CALL VOTE: AYES — 6 (Mayor Aitken and Council Members Kurtz, Diaz, Rubalcava, Faessel,
and Meeks); NOES — 0; ABSENT — 1 (Council Member Leon). Motion carried.
B105 1. Receive and file the minutes of the Public Utilities Board meeting of November 15, 2023.
D116 2. Approve the recognition of Dr. Christopher Downing for receiving the Quantum Impact
Courageous Leadership Award for Transformational Leadership.
D180 3• Authorize the Purchasing Agent, or designee, to increase the current master agreement with
Johnson Controls Fire Protection LP, from the amount of $438,508.40 to $684,268.40, to
perform a five-year certification and inspection of the fire sprinkler systems at the Anaheim
Convention Center.
6. Approve Contract Change Order No. 1 with Hampton Tedder Electric Company, in the amount
of $1,991,498.98, for the Overhead Electric Reliability Improvement Project Fiscal Year 21/22;
AGR-13342.0.1 and authorize the Director of Public Works to execute the Contract Change Order and take
the necessary actions to implement and administer the Contract Change Order.
7. Approve an agreement with DILO Production, Inc., dba DILO Direct, in an amount not to
AGR-14514 exceed $250,000 with a 15% contingency for as -needed extra services, for comprehensive
electrical equipment insulator gas management services for a five year term with an optional
12-month extension to complete in -progress services; and authorize the Public Utilities
City Council Minutes of January 9, 2024
Page 10 of 19
General Manager, or designees, to execute the agreement, and related documents, and to
take the necessary actions to implement, fund, and administer the agreement.
D160 8. Approve an agreement with Raftelis Financial Consultants, Inc., dba Raftelis, in an amount not
to exceed $185,000, to provide a strategic staffing study for the Police Department; and
authorize the Chief of Police to administer the agreement and execute and administer any
future amendments with non -substantive changes to the agreement, as determined by the
Office of the City Attorney.
Item No. 08 was withdrawn by staff.
10. RESOLUTION NO. 2024-001 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE
AGR-14515 CITY OF ANAHEIM appointing Elio Palacios as the City Hearing Officer pursuant to Section
1.12.110 of the Anaheim Municipal Code, and approving an agreement for hearing officer
services with Palacios Law Office [agreement in the compensation rate of $250 per hour, for a
three year term].
11. RESOLUTION NO. 2024-002 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE
D175 CITY OF ANAHEIM ratifying and approving the actions of the Anaheim Director of Public
Works, or designee, in submitting a grant application on behalf of the City of Anaheim to the
California Department of Transportation (Caltrans) for the Sustainable Communities Grant for
the update to the City of Anaheim Transit Master Plan and, authorizing the acceptance of
such grant on behalf of the City and amending the budget accordingly; and, determine that
these actions are exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) pursuant to
Guideline Section 15306 [grant funds in the amount of $400,000 and local match funds in the
amount of $51,824].
13. ORDINANCE NO. 6564 _(ADOPTION) AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF ANAHEIM
M142 repealing Sections 1.04.970 of Chapter 1.04 of Title 1 relating to the Anaheim Youth Commission.
[introduced at the Council meeting of December 12, 2023, Item No. 18].
D114 14. Approve minutes of the City Council meeting of June 27, 2023.
BUSINESS CALENDAR:
13180 4. Waive the sealed bid requirement of Council Policy 4.0 and authorize the Purchasing Agent,
or designee, to issue a master agreement to Siemens Industry, Inc., in the amount of
$94,329.59 plus a 15% contingency, to provide and install CO2 sensors at the Anaheim
Convention Center in accordance with the terms of Sourcewell Cooperative Agreement
#030421-SIE.
DISCUSSION: In response to Mayor Pro Tern Kurtz, Purchasing Agent Jered Rakosky clarified the
request to waive the bidding requirement is because the services are specific to Siemens. He added
another aspect of this request is because the anticipated value was not expected to exceed
$100,000. Public Works Director Rudy Emami added a hypothetical example of work on the Anaheim
Convention Center's 45 air conditioning units — all of a specific type and installed with the building — in
which if one of the units failed they would not want to replace it with one from a different manufacturer
potentially creating issues with either space, future repairs, or compatibility with the 44 others leading
to a lack of efficiency.
Mayor Pro Tem Kurtz commended on the thoughtful use of the policy to save money.
City Council Minutes of January 9, 2024
Page 11 of 19
MOTION: Mayor Pro Tem Kurtz moved to waive the sealed bid requirement of Council Policy 4.0 and
authorize the Purchasing Agent, or designee, to issue a master agreement to Siemens Industry, Inc.,
in the amount of $94,329.59 plus a 15% contingency, to provide and install CO2 sensors at the
Anaheim Convention Center in accordance with the terms of Sourcewell Cooperative Agreement
#030421-SIE, seconded by Council Member Meeks. ROLL CALL VOTE: AYES — 6 (Mayor Aitken
and Council Members Kurtz, Diaz, Rubalcava, Faessel, and Meeks); NOES — 0; ABSENT —1
(Council Member Leon). Motion carried.
D180 5. Authorize the Purchasing Agent, or designee, to execute a purchase order with TNVC, dba
Tactical Night Vision Company, in the amount of $428,960 plus applicable tax, for the
purchase of 40 binocular night vision devices and the associated helmet mounts for use by
Orange County Joint Hazardous Assessment Teams (JHAT) and Special Weapons and
Tactics (SWAT) teams (Bid#9746).
DISCUSSION: In response to Mayor Pro Tem Kurtz, Anaheim Police Chief Rick P. Armendariz
reported this grant is part of the Urban Areas Security Initiative (UASI) which provides security
throughout vital locations in Orange County, which includes multiple law enforcement agencies. He
confirmed the Anaheim Police Department (APD) is administrating the grant. He noted the APD,
Orange Police Department, Orange County Sheriff's Department, and the Garden Grove Police
Department are part of the JHAT.
MOTION: Mayor Pro Tem Kurtz moved to authorize the Purchasing Agent, or designee, to execute a
purchase order with TNVC, dba Tactical Night Vision Company, in the amount of $428,960 plus
applicable tax, for the purchase of 40 binocular night vision devices and the associated helmet
mounts for use by Orange County Joint Hazardous Assessment Teams (JHAT) and Special
Weapons and Tactics (SWAT) teams (Bid #9746), seconded by Council Member Meeks. ROLL
CALL VOTE: AYES — 6 (Mayor Aitken and Council Members Kurtz, Diaz, Rubalcava, Faessel, and
Meeks); NOES — 0; ABSENT — 1 (Council Member Leon). Motion carried.
9. Approve the First Amendment to Professional Services Agreement with Sign Age Identity
AGR-13804.1 Systems, Inc., to increase the not to exceed amount from $500,000 to $1,000,000, for on -call
wayfinding and banner signage design, fabrication, and installation services; authorize the
Director of Economic Development, or designee, to administer the amendment; and authorize
de minimis changes that do not substantially change the terms and conditions of the
agreement as determined by the Office of the City Attorney.
Director of Economic Development Sergio Ramirez reported the item is a request to increase the
contracting authority for on -call signage needs, noting Sign Age is one of three consultants who
assist the City with on -call signage Citywide. He reported Sign Age is currently implementing signage
for Center City and downtown parking structures. He added the additional funding is to complete the
current project and is required due to the increasing construction costs and change orders.
DISCUSSION: In response to Council Member Rubalcava, Director Ramirez added the focus of the
request is for Sign Age's current project at the Center Street parking structures. He added, since the
Department is requesting additional funding, staff is also including anticipated additional work along
the State College Boulevard, Beach Boulevard, and Brookhurst Street Corridors.
Council Member Rubalcava stated her concept of Economic Development is attracting business and
signage does not generate revenue or attract new business.
City Council Minutes of January 9, 2024
Page 12of19
Director Ramirez stated signage and branding are an important part of placemaking and urban
planning, including redevelopment and revitalization.
In response to Council Member Meeks, Property Development Manager Stephen Stoewer clarified
the City has three contracts for signage, with Sign Age's contract totaling $500,000 while the others
are for $300,000 and $200,000. He added all three are for two years with two two-year optional
extensions. He confirmed the City currently has $1,000,000 total of on -call signage authority amongst
the three contracts. He clarified the extension options for the three contracts can add time but not
additional funding authority.
Council Member Meeks stated that on -call signage projects should be for relatively small needs, such
as street banners for an event or if a road sign is struck by a car.
In response to Council Member Meeks, Director Ramirez confirmed the initial value of the Sign Age
contract was $350,000. Council Member Meeks expressed concerns that the contracts amounting to
or exceeding $350,000 deserve an individual bid.
In response to Council Member Meeks' inquiries, Director Ramirez confirmed the change orders for
the Center Street parking structures will cost between $19,000 to $30,000. Property Development
Manager Stoewer added staff conducts regular Requests for Proposal (RFP) to ensure the City is
receiving the lowest bid out of the three on -call contractors. He confirmed the other on -call
contractors did not have enough contract authority for the parking structure project.
Council Member Meeks stated the size of this request seems excessive. She stated she is willing to
approve the cost of the change orders for the garage project but is unwilling to add another $500,000
to the overall contract.
Director Ramirez stated an addition of between $50,000 to $100,000 to be able to complete the
project would be appreciated. He agreed with Council Member Rubalcava's comments about
returning to the Council relative to future projects.
In response to Council Member Diaz's hypothetical, Director Ramirez confirmed staff would conduct a
bidding process on the replacement of a $5,000 sign between the three contractors.
Council Member Diaz stated this request is not out of the City's control because it would include
signage for a vacant lot the City is looking to redevelop. He commended staff's three -contractor
process and noted his support for the item.
Mayor Pro Tem Kurtz expressed concern about doubling the contract amount and inquired about
future projects that would total the requested amount.
In response to Mayor Pro Tern Kurtz, Director Ramirez reported one of his top priorities was to
ensure all Successor Agency properties were well -identified to highlight potential development
opportunities. He reported decorative fence screenings were also added to many properties. He
reported in 2022 the City received a grant opportunity for the real-time parking information system
and the Sign Age contract allowed the City to implement the grant. He added, looking forward, staff
has discussed improvements to Beach Boulevard, Brookhurst Street, and State College Boulevard,
including, banners, signage, and entry monuments which is why staff is not only making this request
but also including a higher contracting authority in the upcoming budget. He confirmed this request
could potentially include signage for Little Arabia. He clarified the Tile Mile is an area on State
College where additional signage could be beneficial, noting there may be interest in creating a
City Council Minutes of January 9, 2024
Page 13 of 19
Business Improvement District (BID) in the area. He added signage could attract shoppers to the
northern portions of State College Boulevard.
Mayor Pro Tern Kurtz recommended including details like these in future staff reports for a better
understanding of where the funding will be allocated.
Council Member Rubalcava questioned if the request was being addressed in the proper order. She
questioned if Little Arabia signage would ultimately come out of Economic Development's budget as
opposed to other departments such as Public Works and Public Utilities. She stated she would
support an amended motion to approve only the $100,000 to finish the Center Street parking
structures but would prefer staff return with additional details on the overall signage strategy as it
looks to areas like Little Arabia and potentially creating a BID there.
In response to Mayor Aitken, Director Ramirez clarified it is on a case -by -case basis whether it is
easier and costlier for staff to use the three contractors instead of sending a global RFP for every
project. He added the three contractors help expedite the final work while noting the RFP process can
cast a wider net. He added projects for Economic Development tend to be on the smaller side and
the Center Street project's size is an anomaly for the department.
In response to Mayor Aitken, Property Development Manager Stoewer confirmed the grant that
applied to the parking project was for $190,000 from the Southern California Association of
Governments (SCAG). Director Ramirez clarified the $190,000 was combined with departmental
funds for the project and it is a matter of the Sign Age contract authority being utilized to complete the
work. He confirmed the necessary funds are available in the Fiscal Year 2023/24 budget.
Mayor Aitken noted the Economic Development budget is growing because the department is brand
new. She added as the department continues to grow it needs to have the fiscal flexibility to be
responsive. She stated signage is an important piece of community identity and conveys the
Council's vision of the future of the City to residents. She noted signage in the Anaheim Canyon
represents the community's identity while attracting new businesses and generating tax -based
revenue. She cited another example of a large vacant parcel at Anaheim Boulevard and Ball Road
having signage to communicate a commitment to the residents on the parcel's future. She
commended Director Ramirez's work with signage and expressed her support for the item.
Council Member Meeks clarified her only objection to the item is the Council has already approved
$1,000,000 for on -call signage services during the budget process. She stated the size and $400,000
cost of the parking project deserves specific approval by the Council as a separate bid. She noted her
intent is to be strategic and fair and that not every project is on -call.
Director Ramirez acknowledged it was a mistake to run this large of a project with on -call funds. He
added he would present Council with anything over $200,000 in the future and cited this as an
example of departmental learning pains.
In response to Council Member Meeks' inquiry, Director Ramirez confirmed the $100,000 would
complete the Center Street project and leave them with an additional buffer for the remaining year on
the current Sign Age contract term for unforeseen projects.
In response to Council Member Meeks, Property Development Manager Stoewer confirmed staff is
coming close to maximizing its two other contracts with about $46,000 remaining on each.
City Council Minutes of January 9, 2024
Page 14 of 19
Council Member Meeks stated this means staff will require the additional $500,000 to get through the
next year because they will inevitably have to come back to Council for more on -call signage funding.
She noted the intent behind on -call contracts is not to increase the contracting authority after the
bidding process.
In response to Mayor Aitken, Council Member Meeks stated she would be comfortable using 50% of
the on -call contract's amount as a threshold for staff returning to Council for separate approval of a
project. Mayor Aitken stated that is not an unreasonable request and requested staff can adopt that
process moving forward.
Director Ramirez confirmed he understood the Council's comments and agreed to handle projects
like this one differently moving forward. He added they can discuss the City's signage strategy further
as well as incorporating departments such as Public Works.
City Manager Vanderpool added staff can work internally to accomplish signage goals while also
being sensitive to the concerns aired by the Council.
Council Member Rubalcava noted there have been recent requests by the public to reduce staff
spending authorities in the name of transparency, noting this request would double the spending
authority in the contract. She stated signage does not generate business interest. She requested staff
be mindful of the concerns while developing the Department's strategy. She stated she would support
$100,000 to help complete this project but would vote against the entire request.
In response to Mayor Pro Tern Kurtz's inquiries, Property Development Manager Stoewer confirmed if
only $100,000 is approved it would seriously hurt their endeavors until the next budget cycle. Mayor
Pro Tern Kurtz commented while the signage may not generate additional business interests it serves
a purpose to retain the businesses in the area and attract customers.
In response to Mayor Pro Tern Kurtz's inquiries, Director Ramirez confirmed they would not have the
budget to do anything they would have planned for Tile Mile during the current budget cycle without
this approval.
Mayor Pro Tern Kurtz stated she would support the full increase for that reason.
Council Member Diaz clarified there is no under-the-table business going with the three contracted
vendors who compete with each other through a bidding process for the City's work. He noted others
can still bid for larger projects. He noted the project is specific and through the competitive bid
process the City receives the best prices. He commended the volume of helpful signage and fencing
added to vacant lots in District 1, bringing hopes the spaces will be developed and not continue to sit
empty. He expressed his support for the item. He added the signs on vacant lots can attract
developers to the City.
MOTION: Mayor Pro Tem Kurtz moved to approve the First Amendment to Professional Services
Agreement with Sign Age Identity Systems, Inc., to increase the not to exceed amount from $500,000
to $1,000,000, for on -call wayfinding and banner signage design, fabrication, and installation
services; authorize the Director of Economic Development, or designee, to administer the
amendment; and authorize de minimis changes that do not substantially change the terms and
conditions of the agreement as determined by the Office of the City Attorney, seconded by Council
Member Diaz. ROLL CALL VOTE: AYES — 5 (Mayor Aitken and Council Members Kurtz, Diaz,
Faessel, and Meeks); NOES — 1 (Council Member Rubalcava); ABSENT — 1 (Council Member Leon).
Motion carried.
City Council Minutes of January 9, 2024
Page 15 of 19
M142 12. ORDINANCE NO. 6565 (INTRODUCTION) AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF ANAHEIM
amending Section 1.11.050 (Email Retention) of Chapter 1.11 (Sunshine Provisions) of the Anaheim
Municipal Code to increase the email retention period.
ORDINANCE NO. 6566 _ —(INTRODUCTION) AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF ANAHEIM
amending Chapter 1.10 (Records Management) of the Anaheim Municipal Code to conform to
modern retention practices and other provisions of the Anaheim Municipal Code.
City Clerk Theresa Bass reported the item is the introduction of two ordinances to amend Sections
1.11.050 and Chapter 1.10 of the Anaheim Municipal Code (AMC) following the direction given at the
September 26, 2023 Council meeting to extend the email retention policy for the Council Members,
Executive Team, Chief Communications Officer, and any designated positions by the City Manager
and Executive Team from 90 days to two years. She reported emails will be deleted automatically
after two years unless they are required to be maintained for compliance with the AMC or other laws.
She added the proposed ordinance increases the default retention period for all other email accounts
managed within the City's email servers to two years unless the emails are discarded by the account
holder after it is established the emails are not required to be retained pursuant to the AMC or
provisions of law. She added corresponding changes also need to be made to the records -keeping
portion of the AMC in Chapter 1.10 to be consistent with City Council's direction and modern
retention for electronic communications. She stated staff is requesting the introduction of the two
proposed ordinances and subsequently will be agendized at the next City Council meeting for a
second reading. City Clerk Bass noted the staff report will include updates to the City's Administrative
Regulations and Information Technology policies as part of the City Council's direction at the
September 26, 2023 meeting.
DISCUSSION: Mayor Pro Tern Kurtz requested additional clarification on the retention period of each
inbox including sent and deleted emails.
In response to Mayor Pro Tern Kurtz, City Clerk Bass confirmed retained emails include messages
sent, received, and deleted. She added the two-year retention of deleted emails for the Council
Members and key staff mentioned in the proposed ordinance is a change from the current retention
period of 90 days unless the record was saved in a separate archive folder. City Clerk Bass clarified
the two-year retention period for received messages and deleted messages would be designated to
those outlined in the proposed ordinance and any designated staff.
Council Member Faessel requested a timeline for the implementation of the proposed ordinance.
In response to Council Member Faessel, City Clerk Bass clarified the current settings are for 90 days
and it would increase to two years from when the proposed ordinance takes effect. She confirmed the
two-year retention period will not be applicable to emails received prior to the ordinance's effective
date and would only be subject to the current 90-day retention period. She confirmed a text message
from a cellular phone is considered an electronic communication and subject to the Public Records
Act. Director of Finance Debbie Moreno clarified there was a policy decision made for a two year
retention period for text messages and staff will be using new City -controlled devices with firm rules of
usage providing staff access to those messages.
Council Member Faessel added that based on the explanations provided text messages would serve
as a form of electronic communication similar to emails.
In response to Council Member Faessel, City Clerk Bass clarified the policy decisions refer to the
Sunshine Ordinance. She clarified the proposed ordinances focus on City email retention. She
City Council Minutes of January 9, 2024
Page 16 of 19
clarified there will be regulations that will be presented to the City Council regarding the City's
Information Technology policies.
In response to Council Member Faessel, City Attorney Fabela clarified text messages are already
covered under the records management changes proposed in the ordinance. He explained that text
messages are electronic communications under the City's records management policy and are
required to be saved for two years. He added staff now has a mechanism to take control of the
preservation.
Council Member Faessel stated the text message component was not clear in what the Council
received for this item and thanked staff for the clarification.
MOTION: Mayor Pro Tern Kurtz moved to introduce ORDINANCE NO. 6565
(INTRODUCTION) AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF ANAHEIM amending Section 1.11.050 (Email
Retention) of Chapter 1.11 (Sunshine Provisions) of the Anaheim Municipal Code to increase the
email retention period and ORDINANCE NO. 6566 (INTRODUCTION) AN
ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF ANAHEIM amending Chapter 1.10 (Records Management) of the
Anaheim Municipal Code to conform to modern retention practices and other provisions of the
Anaheim Municipal Code, seconded by Council Member Rubalcava. ROLL CALL VOTE: AYES — 6
(Mayor Aitken and Council Members Kurtz, Diaz, Rubalcava, Faessel, and Meeks); NOES — 0;
ABSENT — 1 (Council Member Leon). Motion carried.
D125 15. Discuss recommendations on near -term improvements and potential next steps made as part
of the Brookhurst Corridor Study Report, and provide direction to staff, as necessary.
Item No. 15 was continued to the January 23, 2024 City Council meeting.
D125 16. RESOLUTION NO. 2024-003 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE
CITY OF ANAHEIM approving the installation of Little Arabia freeway signs on Interstate 5
and State Route 91 [The Little Arabia District].
Director Ramirez reported at the August 23, 2022 City Council meeting, the City Council designated a
portion of Brookhurst Street from Broadway to Ball Road as the Little Arabia District. He added at the
December 12, 2023 Workshop a Brookhurst Corridor Study (Study) was presented to the City Council
and Council Member Leon requested staff initiate the process of installing Little Arabia freeway
signage. He noted one of the findings of the Study was the desire by local stakeholders for freeway
signage at the Brookhurst exits to attract visitors to Little Arabia.
Director Ramirez reported California Streets and Highways Code Statute 101.12 includes specific
guidelines for the placement and maintenance of signs highlighting a cultural designation.
Additionally, the statute requires that the governing body adopt a resolution that designates the name
of the community that is to be used on the directional signs, the geographic boundaries of the
community, and a request for Caltrans to post the signs on the highway. He reported staff has
identified four locations on northbound and southbound Interstate 5 (1-5) and State Route 91 (SR-91)
freeways at the Brookhurst Street exits. He noted the proposed resolution will affirm the City's support
for placing directional signs on the highways adjacent to Little Arabia. He reported staff has a
consultant to help engage with Caltrans to expedite the process. He added several letters of support
have been received from elected officials including Congressman Correa, State Senator Umberg, and
County Supervisor Doug Chaffee, as well as others.
City Council Minutes of January 9, 2024
Page 17 of 19
DISCUSSION: Mayor Aitken read a statement from District 2 Council Member Leon who could not be
in attendance due to a family emergency.
"Due to a family emergency, I am not able to attend tonight's Council meeting. Mayor Aitken
has offered to read this statement on my behalf, of which I am appreciative of. I want to share
my strong support for Agenda Item No. 16 and join fellow elected officials from Congress, the
California State Senate, State Assembly, and the County Board of Supervisors in this
resolution to approve our application to Caltrans of placement of Little Arabia freeway signs on
Interstate 5 and State Route 91. 1 want to say thank you to our City staff for their important
and diligent work for this item including Economic Development, Public Works, and others, as
well as recognize members of our community for their continued efforts in helping us to come
together to further recognize Little Arabia and at the same time revitalize this important piece
of West Anaheim and our City. The immigrant story is one of hard work, sacrifice, boldness,
and courage. The Anaheim story is an immigrant story, Little Arabia is an immigrant story. We
are a richly diverse community and as a son of Mexican immigrants, it is important for me to
stand up and recognize the contributions that countless immigrants have made in our City
including the Middle Eastern businesses and restaurants in Little Arabia and Brookhurst that
make up the majority of economic activity throughout this Corridor. Our City is the only one in
California that has designated a region to celebrate the contributions of Arab, Middle Eastern,
and immigrant communities. By approving this item, we signal to our community that the City
of Anaheim is proud of our immigrant roots, our diversity, and that we celebrate the hard work
of dozens of small business owners who continue to work tirelessly to this day. As we look
forward towards the future, we have a unique opportunity to highlight and increase
awareness, visibility, and tourism into Little Arabia and West Anaheim and attract even more
businesses and restaurants of all cultures, traditions, and origins, while also celebrating and
continue to support businesses and restaurants that have become pillars and staples of our
community. This also serves as an important next step into validating the branding and
identity of this section of the Corridor, something that my office has heard loudly from the
community and was highlighted during the Brookhurst Corridor Study. Residents and business
owners alike have been advocating for the Little Arabia designation for decades. In 2022,
when the Council approved to designate Little Arabia, it was an acknowledgment of the
contributions and advocacy of those dedicated community members. This business item
represents the next step in the City affirming the designation and celebrating the immigrant
story, the Anaheim story. I stand firmly in support of this effort. I appreciate the leadership of
fellow elected leaders, business owners, community members, and residents in bringing much
deserved and much needed representation and identification to Little Arabia, Brookhurst,
District 2, and West Anaheim, and I ask all my colleagues for their support. Thank you."
Council Member Faessel expressed his condolences to Council Member Leon. He requested
consideration to place freeway signs on State Route 22 (SR-22).
In response to Council Member Faessel, Director Ramirez confirmed staff can look into whether
SR-22 is also a viable option for signage in its communications with Caltrans.
Council Member Faessel requested Council consensus on including SR-22 for consideration. Mayor
Aitken requested additional information on whether there is a geographical requirement for the sign
placement and if SR-22 was too close or too far from the designated Corridor.
City Council Minutes of January 9, 2024
Page 18 of 19
In response to Mayor Aitken, Director Emami noted the stretch of SR-22 where it meets Brookhurst
Street is in another City and has other cultural designation signs. He compared it to putting signs for
Disneyland in a neighboring City.
City Attorney Fabela stated the item is agendized as a discussion of freeway signs on 1-5 and SR-91,
he advised if the Council has a deeper discussion on signage for SR-22, it would have to be properly
agendized.
Council Member Faessel recognized City Attorney Fabela's concerns and noted that he had
addressed his suggestions.
Council Member Meeks stated they need to have a more finite vision for Little Arabia and the
Brookhurst Corridor before they decide what a freeway sign should say or look like. She suggested
establishing a vision document for the Corridor. She noted the Brookhurst Corridor Study discussed
the possibility of collaborating with other designated ethnic districts further south on Brookhurst Street
in other jurisdictions. She recommended putting more effort into their final vision for the Corridor,
including branding, and instead getting consistent freeway signage at a later date. She stated she
cannot support the item at this time.
Mayor Pro Tern Kurtz noted Caltrans' signs like the proposed ones all look the same with basic white
lettering on a green background and do not have designs.
In response to Mayor Pro Tern Kurtz, Director Ramirez confirmed the City must pay for the signs and
not Caltrans.
Mayor Pro Tern Kurtz noted this is an example of her previous comments on Item No. 09 where staff
has to be nimble due to unanticipated expenses. She stated staff could do the freeway signage apart
from the Brookhurst Street signage but echoed Council Member Meeks' request to finalize the
branding concepts within the District. She stated she would support the freeway signs.
Council Member Diaz reported the aspirations of those who encouraged the designation of Little
Arabia always included the vision of freeway signage. He stated this item is a milestone going hand -
in -hand with the designation itself.
In response to Council Member Diaz's inquiry, Director Ramirez clarified staff will work to expedite the
estimated timeline of 6-9 months for completion but added this is Caltrans' standard timeline for these
requests.
Council Member Diaz expressed support for the item.
Mayor Aitken stated she supports the item without any reservation, adding it is a long overdue
recognition for an important and vibrant segment of the community. She thanked the elected officials
for their letters of support along with residents who fought for years for this recognition. She looks
forward to welcoming the sign and standing with the community when the signage is unveiled.
MOTION: Mayor Aitken moved to approve RESOLUTION NO. 2024-003 A RESOLUTION
OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF ANAHEIM approving the installation of Little Arabia
freeway signs on Interstate 5 and State Route 91 [The Little Arabia District], seconded by Mayor Pro
Tern Kurtz. ROLL CALL VOTE: AYES — 5 (Mayor Aitken and Council Members Kurtz, Diaz,
Rubalcava, and Faessel); NOES — 1 (Council Member Meeks); ABSENT — 1 (Council Member Leon).
Motion carried.
City Council Minutes of January 9, 2024
Page 19 of 19
REPORT ON CLOSED SESSION ACTIONS: None
PUBLIC COMMENTS (non -agenda items): None
COUNCIL AGENDA SETTING:
Council Member Rubalcava requested an update on street vending, an overview of Workers'
Compensation claims, and recognition of Mondragon Market for their 45th year of business in
Anaheim.
Mayor Aitken requested recognitions for Al Baraka Restaurant and Kareem's Restaurant for making it
on the Los Angeles Time's 101 Best Restaurants list. She noted both restaurants are in Little Arabia.
ADJOURNMENT:
At 7:59 p.m., with no further business before the City Council, Mayor Aitken adjourned the City
Council in memory of Council Member Leon's grandmother Maria Esther Castro.
Respectfully submitted,
4
Th e a Bass, CIVIC
City C,erk Bass
Susana Barrios
From:
Sent:
To:
Cc:
Subject:
Margot Pierrong
Sunday, December 24, 2023 4:28 PM
Public Comment
Carlos A. Leon
[EXTERNAL] COMMENT RE: THE PROTESTING ON BROOKHURST AROUND "LITTLE
ARABIA" BUSINESSES
Some people who received this message don't often get email from
Lezirn why this is important
Warning: This email originated from outside the City of Anaheim. Do not click links or open attachments unless you
recognize the sender and are expecting the message.
I need to make a comment regarding the protesting going on around the Little Arabia
area on Brookhurst St. Anaheim 92804 — BECAUSE I read that the City of Anaheim is
thinking about investing a lot of money into centering this area as a "designation area"
My friends from out of town were visiting & going to DisneyLand & Knott's Berry Farm
& encountered the protesting going on on Brookhurst St. & were appalled & somewhat
frightened by what they saw.- I was absolutely embarrassed by this situation. It is
embarrassing enough to see all these illegal unlicensed sidewalk sellers with their
handwritten signs that are an eyesore — but to have to put up with a disruptive
political protest like this?....horrible.
This great City of Anaheim is supposed to be "the happiest place on earth" --- & a
welcome city for tourists to `come & leave all their troubles behind'....not to be
reminded of the terrible on -going world happenings.
I would be totally against any idea of enlarging this Little Arabia area - & totally
against spending any city tax dollars to make is a designation area. The traffic in this
area is a mess anyway without it being a "designation area"'....
I realize that protesting is a right — but I am appalled that this area of middle eastern
businesses would even enter into a political protest like this ! And I hope that the
project of enlarging this area will be put up to the city of Anaheim residents to vote on
it. Thank you for listening. And thank you, Mr. Leon for reading this, if you did.......
Margot Pierrong
Orange Ave resident — Anaheim 92804
Susana Barrios
From: Ammar ALKHODR
Sent: Monday, January 8, 2024 IS9 PM
To: Public Comment
Subject: [EXTERNAL] Little Arabia freeway signs
[You don't often get email from Learn why this is important at
https://aka.ms/LearnAboutSenderldentification ]
Warning: This email originated from outside the City of Anaheim. Do not click links or open attachments unless you
recognize the sender and are expecting the message.
This email is to support the placement of Little Arabia freeway signs.
Thanks
Susana Barrios
From: Michael Wauschek
Sent: Monday, January 8, :1
To: Public Comment
Subject: [EXTERNAL] Little Arabia support
You don't often get email from earn why this is important
Warning: This email originated from outside the City of Anaheim. Do not click links or open attachments unless you
recognize the sender and are expecting the message.
Hello my name is Michael wauschek we differently need a sign for it especially doing these recently times of the
genocide in gaze. By having this sign it will help Arabia community of a place to gather & to do business at. It`s so that
orange country is community vs division. Yes their division but by it will make our Arabia community stronger as well
pride of who they are thanks
Sent from Yahoo Mail - Shoo Smart. Shop oreanized
Susana Barrios
From: Ryan Clark
Sent: Monday, January 8, 2024 3:05 PM
To: Public Comment
Subject: [EXTERNAL] Caltrans little arabia freeway sign
[You don't often get email fro Learn why this is important at
https://aka.ms/LearnAboutSenderldenti{ication ]
Warning: This email originated from outside the City of Anaheim. Do not click links or open attachments unless you
recognize the sender and are expecting the message.
Dear Anaheim City Council, I would like to vocalize support for caltrans to install freeway signs for Little Arabia. I believe
this will benefit Anaheim for increase of business, tax dollars, and highlight a wonderful part of our city. Thank you for
your service and care.
Ryan Clark
Sent from my iPhone
Susana Barrios
From: jod iemosley
Sent: Thursday, January 4, 2024 6:59 PM
To: Public Comment; City Manager
Subject: [EXTERNAL] Item #16
You don't often get email from Learn why this is important
Warning: This email originated from outside the City of Anaheim. Do not click links or open attachments unless you
recognize the sender and are expecting the message.
Installing freeway signs that welcome you to LITTLE ARABIA is not necessary.
Those in our community who prefer diversity over a single ethnic preference believe it is only going to squeeze out all
other businesses that are not Arabic.
Its common sense to welcome EVERY culture. NOT JUST ONE..
PLEASE SAY NO TO THIS.
Sent from my T-Mobile 5G Device
Susana Barrios
From: Santana, Richard <richard.santana@ocgov.com>
Sent: Monday, January 8, 2024 3:24 PM
To: Public Comment
Subject: [EXTERNAL] Support for Item 16 - Little Arabia Freeway Signs
Attachments: CalTrans Support Letter.pdf
You don't often get email from richard.santana@ocgov.com. Learn why this is important
Warning: This email originated from outside the City of Anaheim. ❑o not click links or open attachments unless you
recognize the sender and are expecting the message.
Dear City Clerk Theresa Bass,
I hope this email finds you well. I am writing to express Supervisor Sarmiento's support for Item 16 on the business
calendar —a resolution approving the installation of Little Arabia freeway signs on Interstate 5 and State Route 91 within
The Little Arabia District.
Kindly find the attached letter outlining our endorsement and rationale for supporting this initiative.
Thank you for your time and consideration.
Best regards,
Richard Santana
Richard Santana
Community Outreach Manager
Office of Vicente Sarmiento
Supervisor, Second District
400 W. Civic Center Drive, Sixth Floor
Santa Ana, CA 92701
Office: 714-3 34-3220
E-mail correspondence, along with any attachments, may be subject to the California Public Records Act, and
as such may be subject to public disclosure unless otherwise exempt under the Act.
VICENTE SARMIENTO
ORANGE COUNTY BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
SUPERVISOR, SECOND DISTRICT
COUNTY ADMINISTRATION NORTH BUILDING
400 W. CIVIC CENTER DRIVE. SANTA ANA, CALIFORNIA 92701
PHONE (714) 834-3220
January 08, 2024
Dear California Department of Transportation,
As the Orange County Supervisor for the 2nd District, I represent a portion of the City of
Anaheim and feel a deep connection to the Arab Americans that have contributed to the
vitality of this community. I fully support the installation of Little Arabia District signs within
prominent locations managed by your agency.
Little Arabia serves as the cultural hub for Orange County's Arab Americans, offering a
unique blend of different Middle Eastern traditions, cultures, and cuisine. It is a prominent
local destination that the City of Anaheim has now formally recognized and is in the
process of supporting. I wholeheartedly endorse the City of Anaheim's request for the
"Little Arabia District Sign" and believe that your support will contribute to the flourishing
of a community that holds a special place in the hearts of many.
A dedicated freeway sign is a small investment with far-reaching benefits for the small
businesses that make this cultural hub thrive. In addition to the economic impact, a
prominent freeway sign signals an investment in the preservation of cultural heritage and
in creating a more inclusive California. I am hopeful aboutthe positive impactthis signage
will have on our community.
Supporting this initiative aligns with the values of our diverse constituency and contributes
to the cultural mosaic that makes California a unique and welcoming place for all.
Sincerely,
Vicente Sarmiento
Orange County Board Supervisor, 2nd ❑istrict
Susana Barrios
From: Adam I
Sent: Monday, January 8, 2024 2:52 PM
To: Public Comment
Subject: [EXTERNAL] Little Arabia freeway signs 1/9 Meeting
[You don't often get email from Learn why this is important at
https://aka.ms/LearnAboutSenderldentification ]
Warning: This email originated from outside the City of Anaheim. Do not click links or open attachments unless you
recognize the sender and are expecting the message.
Hello,
My name is Adam Ibrahim, long time Anaheim resident and patron of many small businesses along Brookhurst st. and
the surrounding areas. I strongly support and look forward to seeing the Little Arabia signage's completion.
Thank you for the consideration
Adam I.
Susana Barrios
From: Maece Seirafi
Sent: Monday, January 8, 2024 2:48 PM
To: Public Comment
Subject: [EXTERNAL] Freeway signs for little Arabia
[You don't often get email from Learn why this is important at
https://aka.ms/LearnAboutSenderldenti{ication ]
Warning: This email originated from outside the City of Anaheim. Do not click links or open attachments unless you
recognize the sender and are expecting the message.
Hello city of Anaheim,
I'm Maece Seirafi a resident of Orange County. I frequent Little Arabia quite often and would love to see the freeway
signs mention Little Arabia.
Best,
Maece Seirafi
Sent from my iPhone
Susana Barrios
From:
Sent: Monday, January 8, 2024 7:47 PM
To: Public Comment
Subject: [EXTERNAL] Little Arabia
[You don't often get email from Learn why this is important at
https://aka.ms/LearnAboutSenderldenti{ication ]
Warning: This email originated from outside the City of Anaheim. Do not click links or open attachments unless you
recognize the sender and are expecting the message.
Dear City of Anaheim council
I support the placement of Little Arabia freeway signs
Thank you for your great work
Amad A. Albadri
Susana Barrios
From:
SHAFU DEWAN
Sent:
Monday, January 8, 2024 6:03 PM
To:
Public Comment
Subject:
[EXTERNAL] Little Arabia sign
[You don't often get email from Learn why this is important at
https://aka.ms/LearnAboutSenderldenti{ication ]
Warning: This email originated from outside the City of Anaheim. Do not click links or open attachments unless you
recognize the sender and are expecting the message.
Greetings,
I would like to request the council to support the placement of the "Little Arabia" sign to acknowledge the presence of
the middle eastern population in Anaheim. This will prove that City of Anaheim promotes diversity and honors its
residents. This will also attract more businesses to open shops here.
Thanks in advance
Shafa at Dewan
Sent from my iPhone
Anaheim Police Association
3156 E. La Palma Avenue, Ste. B I Anaheim, California 92806
Telephone: (714) 635-02.72
January 07, 2024
Dear California Department of Transportation,
This letter is written in support for the Little Arabia District Designation Sign in western
Anaheim, California. As an association president for the Anaheim Police Association,
which represents over 400 police officers in the City of Anaheim, I feel a deep
connection to the communities we serve, and I am enthusiastic about the positive
impact this signage will have on our diverse community.
Little Arabia serves as a cultural hub for Orange County's Arab Americans, offering a
unique experience in Middle Eastern culture and cuisine. This designation is not just
about signage but a celebration of our state's rich cultural tapestry. It fosters unity,
supports local businesses, and promotes the diverse heritage that makes California
unique.
Recognizing Little Arabia through a dedicated freeway sign is a small investment with
far-reaching benefits. It is an investment in the small businesses that make this cultural
hub thrive in the preservation of cultural heritage and in creating a more inclusive and
welcoming California.
wholeheartedly endorse the City of Anaheim's request for the "Little Arabia District
Sign" and believe that your support will contribute to the flourishing of a community that
holds a special place in the hearts of many.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and dedication to enhancing our state's cultural
vibrancy. We believe that supporting this initiative aligns with the values of our diverse
constituency and contributes to the cultural mosaic that makes California a unique and
welcoming place for all.
Sincerely,
Jose Duran, President
Anaheim Police Association
Susana Barrios
From: Arias Miller, Tina <Tina.AriasMiller@asm.ca.gov?
Sent: Tuesday, January 9, 2024 4:52 PM
To: Public Comment
Subject: [EXTERNAL] letter to City Council regarding Little Arabia recognition
Attachments: Anaheim City Council letter Asm Valencia.pdf
You don't often get email from tina.ariasmiller@asm.ca.gov. Learn why this is important
Warning: This email originated from outside the City of Anaheim. ❑o not click links or open attachments unless you
recognize the sender and are expecting the message.
Please see attached for distribution to Anaheim Mayor and City Council, as well as inclusion in attachments/exhibit for
minutes.
Thank you!
Tina Arias Miller
District Director
Assembly Member Avelino Valencia I AD 68
District Office: 2400 East Kate IIa Ave
Ste 640 Anaheim, CA 92806
Main 714-939-8469
Ti n a.Ari asM i I I e r@ as m .ca.gov
A.
W
N IN
STATE CAPITOL
P.O. BOX 942849
SACRAMENTO, CA 94249-0068
(916) 319-2068
FAX (916) 319-2168
January 9, 2024
AssembIv
Gtifurnin
5'rAy f
F.
Pf1� 9
AVELINO VALENCIA
ASSEMBLYMEMBER. SIXTY-EIGHTH DISTRICT
Dear Honorable Mayor and City Council;
On the Council agenda today is an item to discuss signage designating the Little Arabia district.
I write to express my openness to help facilitate communications between the City of Anaheim and the
California Department of Transportation throughout the application process to potentially install
signage along highway corridors in the District.
Thank you for your time, and consideration, and for your dedication to the City.
Sincere
Avelino Valencia
California State AssemblymemberAD-68
lbrr+frd •+�r Kra N• f'-dPar" I
f
CAPITOL OFFICE
STANDING COMMI (TEES
1021 O STREET, SUITE 6730
JUDICIARY
SAGFiAMENTQ. CA 958I4
+
CHAIR
(916) 651-4034
y� {.� ray
�LI 1 ,��'4 L Li:i �
HOUSING
O)ST RIGT OFrICE
C/
TRANSPORTATION
1000 E. SANTA ANA BLVD., STE, 2209
SENATOR MILITARY
& VETERAN AFFAIRS
SANTA ANA.. CA, 52701
JOINT COMMITTEES
(714)558.3785
THOMAS J. UMSERG
RULES
WWW SENATE.CA.GOVIUMBERG
THIRTY-FOURTH SENATE ❑iSTRICT
SEN ATOR.UMBERGfSSENATE.CA.GOV
Yi
(•�
Z.
Submitted at Anaheim
City Council meeting
January 9th, 2024
of __ pl as LoZ
Item# __his
Director Tony Tavares
California Department of Transportation
1120 N Street
Sacramento, CA 95814
RE: Little Arabia Designation Signage
Dear Director Tavares:
This letter is written in support for the Little Arabia District Designation Sign in western
Anaheim, California. As the areas State Senator and long-time representative, I feel a deep
connection to the communities we serve, and l am enthusiastic about the positive impact this
si,,nage will have on our diverse community -
Little Arabia serves as a cultural hub for Orange County's Arab Americans, offering a unique
experience in Middle Eastern culture and cuisine. This designation is not just about signage but a
celebration of our state's rich cultural tapestry. It fosters unity, supports local businesses, and
promotes the diverse heritage that makes California unique.
Recognizing Little Arabia through a dedicated freeway sign is a small investment with far-
reaching benefits. It is an investment in the small businesses that make this cultural hub thrive,
an investment in the preservation of cultural heritage, and an investment in creating a more
inclusive and welcoming California.
I wholeheartedly endorse the City of Anaheim's request for the "Little Arabia District" sign and
know that your support will contribute to the flourishing of a community that holds a special
place in the hearts of many.
Thank you for your time, consideration, and dedication to enhancing the cultural vibrancy of our
state. We believe that supporting this initiative aligns with the values of our diverse constituency
and contributes to the cultural mosai: that makes California a unique and wcicorning place for
all.
Sincerely,
Senator Tom Urnberg
California State Senator, District 34