Minutes-PC 1939/02/17
_ _
x .
_ _..
i
~ ,~
,
~
)
f _
<
~ 1
L
f
;
i
l
~
!
e
i
i
P A P~ R ~
A;~I D
?' I 1: ?i i r S
P~RTI3,?c;;?T TO '.'"'.?~TI1'?G ~' ~'LD
Z,~~~~ . 17 ~ 19.39
;-~
t:
~:.
;
.
ii
~~, i
._.i
,~
r ;:i
~'t
; .;
~c~;.;
v,~.
;;;:
~:~°~
;9~r:{ ....
c
~,?I?',LT^S
IiOTICr OF '.~±~;FTIP~G
PROF~SrD A'~r;i~JLtENT r~TABLISF-?I~?'? Z01~?'G R-~
p~.npp~~.P A?'rt?T1'.iT',NT ES'PAPLISHIIJ:= "F.O]'~ OCCiIYATI01~5
L~sTTrR Tb TFi~ CITl' C(?Ur1CIL P:~OPOSII~!= ''?,ARIP:G
Qlauciina St. i.,et~~~een 'Y1~.11F.1171ne s,.r. Nor~h Sts.
Di~~~:o:::' ~t ,^est '; Cwrleto: 9vc..
t~ush S~. South o~' Center St.
s:i. . ~ _ _ .. ..~ _, ,..___~~, _ _._,~
`
~
~
..-
^a~
'
- i ~
~
-
-
'-._'-,-
" ,-r.-..,._....-r, ~,-'-.,~,,---•r-^- ~-
.~ .•- .--~~ . m-r
I
. ~
Anaheim, CaliPornia
February 17, 1939
MINUTES OF THE REGULAR UHEETING
OF
THE PLANNIN4~ COMI~IISSION
,~ Regular The ragu].a~-~ neeting ai The Flaniiing Cammiasion wae helci
~Ieeting
; ~~` at noon in the Marigold'Cafe with Dr. Bigham presidin~.
;,` Present Commiss~.onera Blgham, Pearaon (~rafton, ScYaumacsher, Qauer,
~
;: Engineer Parks and City Attio.rney
riis were presenb.
'
~,
Mlnutes The minutes of the lest meeting and thoae oY Dea. 16th,
~:" 1938 and of Nov. 18th, 1938 were approved as written.
~;
• T~ Hearin on
~ A motion to hold a ublia heari
p ng, ar~ provided by state
r= netitions law and the zoning ordiziance, in the matter of ahangea of
r zone raauested by three petiticns, i,o wit: one affecting
~, property on North Claudina St. between Y~11he].mir.a and Nortr
~ 3treets, ona afiecting property on Diamond Street west of
;: Carleion Avenue, and one affecting Lot 17, in Block d.
m_ Lorelei Traat, wae eeaonded and aarrled.
~;
-= ~~ Reaolution The ~ollowing resolution was adopted by the Planning
~~; aali3~ng Commiasion:
;:~ hearing WF~EA3 the Planning Commission conei@ers it expedient
;:~ to determine the attitude of the people in the matter of
changin~ the zone of the property abutting on S.Buah Street,
between Center St. and Broadway, from the single fa~ily
r:;' residence zone, (R-1). to the neighborhoad bus2nesa zane,
> (C-2), and
• WF~RF.AS it ie believed that the matter ia of intereat
to other than. o~vrsers of said property
~ THECtEFORE it is resolved by the Planning Commisaion
that a hearing in regard to eaid propoaed change of zone
be hel~i in accordance with the pronisiona of the zoning
ordinanae.
~ Mr. Veyiie~ s The re~~aee~ o~ A~L»e ?. Veyna. that ~~ausir.ess be a12e:~:s~
'" ~ ~ request in the old etore building located on Lot 12 of the Mary
d
G
T
oo
man
.ract, which property fronts on Swan Streeti, was
~;
~; de:~ied. No petition in the matter was ~'iled.
~
` Hi?genfeld Mr. H1lgenfeld filed a petition Yor a v~~iance effecting
-~! Petition the lot at the nortneast corner oY Weat St. and Broadway, but
''~
!,a decided, ~ust prior to the meeting, to cancel his petition
x;,; and build in accordanoe with the preeent zoning regul,atione.
~:
~
~~;i Proposed No action was taken in rega..~d to tho amendmente to the
•
~ Amendments zoning urdinance, namely "Zone R-2" and "Home Occupat9.ans" as
~. °urtuer study was aonstdered neceesasy.
Y~
•~ ~ Ad,~ournment There bein~ n4 further business the meetin~; was ad,~ouzned.
~
~
: ~
~
....,..
~~~,.,~ A Aeep
~~u'!7„y aubmlt~d,
;. ~
~
~ %f
$` .r~
.~ ~ -_- `
v- Secretary
l.~' .. _ , ~
. ~
- _ ~- ~ _ v.
~ ~ •
~?
~
!
~.
a
~
€
'~i
;
•
~
i
_ -„~
i::;
~:
i'
;!;•
,
,.
tI
;.i
.`~:
i~ f
~.;
~ :~;
~'
M1.~.
hi'...
tu .
k;~
3i::~-......
~
NaTICB
UB '
pi,~UiN'=Nt3 C01~[I83ION lI~TII~
R'0 '8~ ii~`LD •
ffRIDJ-Y ]IOON
F~. i7, 1939 ~
ysat - Ths m~itsntoe of the last meeLing are attaiotisd here8o.
Yes`!ag .
A lAtisLer eta~ing the Commlesions~ aiti~nde ~onard a ohan3e of
~nilerson zone or a sariaace on 8. ~ueh S~sesb nsa sent to the CiLy Counai}..
Patitioa lEr. 3trit~ aa.~* airaylate snot,~:er pelition.
for s
ltasvg8e Mr. Hi1~c+nteld, owne~ of the northesmt aorner of W. Broadway aad
~arlo~r Y~4et 8areet haa tilad e peL±tion for a rarianoe nrsd ~ey deaide to pebi4-
ioa for a chwn8e oi zone. a uee map oi the ~sren has beea made and gro-
Petitia ld Per ebt-bank lfae~ eatabliehad 1n aeaor3aue~ ~3t~ instzR:ntione to Ehe
- eagi~as~ ~.t. ~s last ~se~Liag.
Csr,uery `dP. Carscousa. operr~Lor o! the aaaaery on Adele 3~re~t nns circul-
Oa Adsim ~tad s pa~ition for a chan8e e~ zoae and will probablv preeeaE iL. A
Strest 3att~er trom t~e Oommiesion ta t~he Oity Connoil stated that the Oommie-
~1lon aonaidered tha cannery entlsely oat of plaoo. 7'hie aas done ia
crdsr thati tha Commiaaion~s attitude wonld ba ]rnown t~o the Connoil. The .
petitioa ia evideatly being ciroulaLed prior to any fhrther peraonsl
appsal.
f~aandt Ths 4baandt paLition iavolvinp~ a chaage o! sone on H. Claudinn Stireet
Pebitioa ' nl11 ba reooaeidered at the neuL mee4iag as a rasnlt of a moiiaa for
Oa North frirth3r study.
ClandinFS St.
A~oetition eigaed by 50~ of tha o-rnera of prooer~y fronting of
New Petit- D~amo~;i S3ra~eE ia the 1200 block axd aelcing t,:,at said block be reiconid
ioa on to permi4 8uplexee. was preaonted to the Oouaail and re~erred to ~he
Dismond Ooamiseio~l oa Jaauery 2~. A uee map of the area will ~e availabl.e a~
'~ Stss~t the ~eotina.
Petition on l~r. J. B. Coykeaflali of 882 9. I,oe Ang~iea S~reeL expeate to pre-
8outh Los een! a petitioa ior changSn~' f~he R-1 zoao oA 7~oe !-n~lea 3tree*_ bet~rson
,,-ngeles St. South atul ~ermant Stzeets Lo "8-2" or the A-j sone.
~~ Mr. f3. R, Holcanaoa~ of 81~k N. Olementin~ Street. is Auisioue to pro-
Parking eide auto parking eerviae on the vaoaut lote ~net south of La Palmn 1"ark•
IL oesme ttie~.t at oertain ximee t~iie ~i~hi be e~,,neoeeee~ry ser~ioe.
Snbdivieion Ialerestea par0lee ha~e been sernriag iaformation pertaini~g to
enbdividing bhe 8yist proporCp northweat o!' the CiLy Park~ and the praperty
~o:ih o± Y,ho Home Hi.~4ldsre Trsot ~usL weet oS Palm 34rest, wnich ia bs-
t~en ilor8h fltreet and the pxnp~red extendioa or t~. va~e 84raet.
A~,~~,w!! l~'Fp~o ~.a a aon~. ot a pr~poeed s~en8ment tio the Zonin6 Ordin-
• Propossd anos. Iti proviQae for an 8-2 sone ~hich wot.:~4 permll0 singleiamily ~n~
.'.-2 Sar.a nqse aau a+ea d~pis~ea. tpa haueaa aa a 2a:. a fl~22:ag aasd lielag qur_aSers
~ o~11r a 64raae. cr aq9.eU're:-Bemenb :or honsing not more ~~an two faimilier
oa a ein~e 3e'E. There ~re the nsnal oLh~r pi'ovieione ae to qarde, h~i~h~.
I ~L~~ ld~i
plo~ plans ior oorner iois. ~ 81~1a• 1i NOa~ T~e.~i s avi+v 'va vuro a..~
i~ Sn d~mastd• tos oer4tain areae nnd those areae will ise,ve Lo be defisrdaid
anfl Aesarified.
a: ~,~3•--- ---.~ _
~~; '
4~,a
, i
~~i:
tesr~--..~~~ . ....^--T-.++.,._~ ...-+-r^~+._ . . ..._". . .. . . . !"T . ~. ^ ."
- r-
,~
S '
~ ~-lso a~tachsd hereto ia en ontline af e propceed emendment p~r-
~~taons alttina a osrisi,a type cf °home oacupati~as" to bs ooadnoted in aa,~
resldeatial dist~iat. S'his !s avggesled se remec~y for aritio4em emd
~~ohiP Qanssd B? the Preeent etriot ragnlatione. Aa attampt has
1~S asds t~i distingnieh betweett "hoas ooo-~~atione" aad ~rofaseione.
p'~'D~~ ~ 1~ntheran ~uroh is aatiaipRting nurchaeing about oae acae of
~~001 F~~T tor a parochisl sohool. Repreeentativea csme in to ea~vc9Jy
~'O~ ~P• ~ eeen !6 tavor n loedtloa oa t~o :raet sfde of 1Cnet
$ts~Wt nbeet6 anw block IIorLh o!' Qeater BLYeet. A ohang~s of zone m~yy
hav~s ta ~e ~cuasider~d ?or this erea.
'~~~t ~r• ~iwer hias bsea reappninted to ssr~e oa the Planning Oommie_
saam for anoLher ionr year tera
i
~
-
- a
~
.-~.i
~•
- . . ~ , . .
,
~
~`..
~
~
~~ ~ •
"
~-• "'^ ~
Tx'
f
'~I
-
i
"'.. _ . . .._ . ., ... . ... . . . ~- -----
-.~ :5
. . _ .. ....--=-rr.~. ..- . ~ .
E
~
~
~,
[
~, . .
i "
~ ~ ~ ~
~ ~s~
' ~ OE~'.9~,i3`I~ ~
~stlfa~ 3s t~ie asdlaesfes aba12 D~ ~o eo~sLswQ aw to prqaa!
'IIa~ Oeao,~atioos" ia au s+~QBntial ~letsiet. A'IIoas Oean~alioa"
4~s tbs ~spow o! tkia os~dim~a~ ~hee~.I aaeaf m~ oaeop~tion 'usaeel~
1D' ~d a~-w•a~ri],~ eo~d~sl~ ia w r~i~stt~l 6.£~t~tfa!• ~nRir~9.Y
.~1h!!t ~a dw.liia~ aa~ ~e~ws~i- laiidia~ tl~rfloe oalY l~ onbere
at a la~il,t wbo m lwdar a3 pe~niais arsid~aty t}~re:~l, aqd
d~ll iae1~Y ~~!~ ~!'t m~tiri' p~~is~ ~tqo~r. Dsolo~s~
aoatraat~r es ~-s~tist°~ stvdio= ~eti~ e~ ~enlMi
~ s9ails~ osta ad~ia~ 3s mr qola4aa ot tM Pia~ Co~rsis~ioa
at+o aot ~~ otieos~o~ te ~s sw~rs. st i~sloesial to ~he pa~ritl
wllMa~. at i~ etier s~~liatts ia mo asl~tiaslLOOd. tban ~-op
aietSemra a~aw.
~~eeo ~atiar~ aieII 1~ aoadeeRxt aat~ ix aamyrse4ioa with
~s'M o~ ~rdd pe+o~t,~ a~e- ~~s1Tla~ atd ~o iiwlil~ r6a11 1~
awl ~taWrl~ fl~ t!s p~epe~e of ~ t 2~ e~a~qou0loa. •
~e1~ s ba^~ ~tL~a 1~ a~d~t. t~s l~tt~r~ of ~'hie~
ars taarf ~~1~sia~laP ~~i'~~ ~Ms o: loat2b ~sll ~1et D~ p~t~•
alt~M.
lbsa~ t9at1 ast ~ s ut~d g~ Io~sd ~te'Ialtas osrr fits L~orN
~o+~sr !a ~sl~w eit~ s~ l~o~ aedip~atld.
Its it ir ~~ ~t tlr lRs~a~a~ Qs~iseiou. e~ ~1~rplie~
lsaaf~ 9a r,e s~i~eastal ~ls~lae~ lseows ~ pa'ot~stiot. lwla~ls~
es iMti'!~, a 1.iMer dr+il 1e s~ia~d 1'dsrfe~ imd n~d licautN
~Sa~.t ~i ~ ZrAet ~ttl ~ a~~,~ is ~ ee t~ene ie
~ ~i ~at~eir as ~~.
. : ,~ .
~
. ~ .-
PROPOSED A][EFDMERT Ta TAE 201qIAIQ ORDIH~~tCB
ZOl~ R-2
;~a Zona R-2 no building, atruoture, csr portiaa2 there-
of dsai~x,ed~ arranged or intenaed to be ooc~ied ~r usad
~or iausy other purposes than those provided i~r os a~31.a~ea
in thie section, shall be erdoted, co~trn~te~, ~.ab3ls~d,
oonvarted, a5.tiexau ~r ^~?~lar~ed; and ao lot, t~nl3d~iagfstaQCtrse
or portion thrsr~of, in said ZGns R-2 sball be ~sed fo~ d.;
other purpose~ than those sFsai2'icaliy provided ior s~d g1-
lowed k~y this seotian.
(a) Any lat~ building, atruc~e, or portion fihereasg,
la 7one R-2 may be ueed Yor any pur~ose o~ asse Y~arlp
a~~oaed in Zone R-1.
(b) There may be established d~-ellings ~ar nu~t swre
~har, two f amilioe on any lot in Zane R-2 sais je~, 's~e~ers
i
'~: i
~y:.i
~; ~
~:1
;~~
},-;
~~;;a .__...
to the lurtber paavisions of thie aeotia~s.
( a) Any building ~r bui33ings ~~~~?i~la ~ a~ a't-2
ehal.l be sit•:~ated on a lot having a~idt~ ol nn~ less tban
iiitq (50} t`ee~ aiong i~he ad3o{~in8 s~ia~# ara~ d- ~~ a~
not leee than si:~ thousand ~5,~00) square teet, bat this
r^~rovis9.os~ ehe-11 n~~t apply to any lot of les$ t3~an 6,R'JO Bq.
txi~fln.
!t. in as~tc~~~at t~e 'cime tas~ t~±is ~~ea~$n~ ~~
teotive.
~a) On L~ts having an area ot 9,~ 8~'+~e iaet or avre
there may be eetabiished a dwel3.ing for oae Sa~ilT ~'~ ea~th
3,000 eq~iare leet of lot area. On l+~ts +a~i lesg tnan 9s~
equare i~e~, but more than 6,000 sqna3e teel, #h~e ebail
be pesmitted d~rellinga tor not mor~a tban t~aoo la~ie~.
(e) 1'here may be the uanF.I $uca~sori~~ ~~aa:3c~
nge permiesibl~ 3~, ~ona ~'t 2 3ac:l~ia~, ~aSa
~ sith buildi
x
, _~~ z_
t -~ 8~18.Q1°J SOl' AO~'i Ill63 C thBA ~OLIl 8E2L01SO~liCB. iSierl6 9^~ -' ~
~ ~,~A ` gasage spaoo ~~r at least ona car sor ~~a ~~i~ i~ _~~
_'- livtng quaxter~ are e~etabliehed on-~~~~~o~.
~
N
r:
~ _. --1 -- ~
~~~
~.
~~
~
~
~
~
I
., ~
r, I
;;.~
;; I
;` i '
~; , ~
%.R`f
.~
~;Sr. .......
~G
i~j Y~ aeparate d~e3lings are oor~etxucted on anq lot
im ~nne R-2 they ehall be aat leas tha.n ~i~teo~ (~5? fest
from esoh other; aoaeeaory buildinga r.~hall ba not leea ~ha,n
threA ?88t frOm ~ny Othe~ bulldlrg on the same lot.
:~~
fg; ~ia~ more than one sign; vlaoard, or other adve~tis-
!ng devioe may be ereoted, or p~.ini;ed on, or made a part of
any premises or etruoture in Zdne R-~2 and auc,h sign, plaoaxd,
or other advertiaing devioe ~hall not have a surfaoe area
oY more than two (2) ec1uare Feet.
~u; .r ?one R-2 yards as follows ehall ba requfred, sub-
~eot to the provisions of seation 1~ oi th3s ordinanoe.
1. There ehall be a Yront qard of not lees than
~' 25 feet eaaept where lots onmprieing fiYty peroentum (50`~)
,Y
or more of tho fr4ntag~ ~n any bl.c~ek have frant parc~a the
ciepths af whioh vary not more than eix ~6) feet, the average
deF~th so establiehed shall oonst~.tuta the depth of front
yards in said blook fr~ntage.
2. ~Phere shall be side ye~:3e eaah of whioh ahall
~~ have a width of not less than five *e~t.
~
3. There ehal: be a rea:4 yard of,not lese than
ten (10) leet; howaver, ~~ eeaond atory .dwel~li~i9in • may
w_x$e~nc~ i,nto the rear yard area, provlded that the ~irst
etorq ie not used for dwelling purpaees.
~i) On oorner lote in respeot to the end abutting the
atreet, +he above front yard pronieione sha11 applq, and
osi11~± ~a aha,ll aleo be loaated eo that the die~6anoe from
the eaterio~ side ].ot line to the nea:~s~ line ~
of any bui].,~ing or portion thareof, o;~ asid lot~ ehall be
~~ equa3 to eighteen peroentum (ld~i) oY the width ot the lot
on ell euo~. ~.ots Rhioh ase llity (5A) i~eei or lee~s in
Aid~h, and equ~,3 to twenty peroant~m- ~20y6} of the wiath ot
the lot on all euoh lote whioh are aver li~ty tSUj teet in
sridth.
2.
~~_"-
'
. ~ '_"'....- _
~T.j
.. .. . . . .. .-,~"-~.-rr.--ra . .^+~+.^^-+- -^ ~ . . .. . . . r . . . . .
_ ~.
1 ~
(~j Buildings and uaee permieeible in tae R-2 Gone
axe also permieet•blo in every other zone exoepting the
R-1 Zone.
(k) Not moro than one buildin~ shall b~ built, ereot~d
o~ es~Mb19ehe~ on r~y aorner ~ot in Zone R-2 until ~~a ap-
plioation ~or a b+iildtnG permit for auoh buildings together
wi$h a plot pgan ehall have baen ap~roved by the Planning
Oommiesioa.
(1) ThZ provisinne of Beo~icn 1~F of this ordinanoe
aha11 be aonsidered to ba ae muoh a part of thia seotion
as though eaoh portion oP eaid Seotion 14 ee~e in thic sub-
~; n ~
k•;
x~
~.~ I
#;, ~
;„
~~
x~
~;;
Y4:~' •
~4~~y
a~.,
.~:
~
~.,,
~
~n _.._....
- --~
j
~
~:
s
J:
~
J
~
C
iR-'
~
~S'
. ~..
aeotion Rri~ten.
~ ~myxo building, etruoture or part thereof in Zona R-~
sha1Z be higher thaa thirtq ~ive (35) ieet, nor ooneiat
af more thnn•teo etories.
:.. .._. ,
, ;..,: ~~~
2. On_lote >hav3~ "~sn area in e~oess oi~~equase ~
lmat Lhere ~~:yi~ba:.~ae~ze: than one dvrellint„ prooideii thnt oa e~,id
lot therc iff an t~.~s. r~ nct ~.es~ tl:~n ~O~G squr~ace te~t !or ee~ch d ~
dr-Rilii~~ ain Io~s ~evin~ fu. e..~e~. a~ +~r~r~ ~L:..~. ~^C~t r.K~.x,,:e `:~~~..:
~bhere .me.p be ;ane: dup7,ax houe~ ~ar each 60~^,4 e,u:,.r~s i'ee~ of area
of: sa.id:3ot,~. an lata havin~ an ar~a of mcre 4han ~~~OQ eqi~re feet
'~here mar ,ba a coa~~nstion af 3u~ie~ mo,i~aa r,ttd/ or dw~lli'~i~s~
prov~~ed that on aa~ii~. 1at t~ere ie sn area at' ncat lese ~~sw j~~u8
equara leet toz eaoh iamilv or house?ceeping.Uxi~ ,~~+x~-'kTiiah~han~ing
_ ~ ,. •.
~,.. .
~ - z.s,,~Aat~ n~ ~uak~ la~. ' .. .
~~a~ ' ` ` _
_ - +~c ~~,.,._ ._ , : _ . ~ ._ _
.~~'+` . .. ... . . . . . .. . . . ' ~ ~ ~
. ..+ .^-~~:.,:~. . ~.-, »?,^:.T.^^~,.-._ .--~-~--r.r ..-.+t+...~.c-^... . . . . .. . . ~--~.