Minutes-PC 1958/04/21~
, _
_. _ ._... ___..____.._..._.._,..~.~.w:._____._......------. ,__.._---~ ---
~~ ~__~ ~ ,
;
, __ ~.
~ City Hall
E Anaheim, California
~ April 21, 1958
t
t
MINUTBB OP AD~ ~URPIDD RHG'UTAR hQi8TI1VG, CTTY PLANNING COMMISSION
nnJounr~n
RBGULAR I~ffiSfING - An Adjourned Regular Meeting of the City Pianning Commissioa was
called to orde~ at 2:10 0'Clock P.M, by Chairman Gauer, a quorum
being preseat.
YRB38Nf; CHAIRMAN GAUBR, COMMISSIOI~RS: DuBois, Mauerhan, Summers, Thompson
and Mungall,
COI~AtI3SIQi~HR Ail;ed entered the Meeting at 2:15 0'Cic,clt Y.M.
CONPdI83I0NBR Morris entered the Meetiag at 2:50 0°Ciock P.M.
COI~S13SIONSR !~spgood entered the Meeting at 4:15 0`Clock P.M.
MINUfBg - The minutes of the Regular Meeting of April 7, 1958 were approved
as printed, with two minoz changes.
RBSOLUTION N0. - Due to the oppositioa of the present operators of Drive-In and Waik-
161 Up Restaurants, and whereas these apparent differences will be
eliminated by the adoption of the new Commercial 2ones, the Commis-
ston decided to do noth3ng at the presea: time rQlative to the
pl.acing of these new uses in the C-3, Heavy Commereial Zone.
VARIANCB N0. 948 - PUB~IC H~ARING„ PBTITION submitted by ANAHBIM CONGdtBGATION OP
J~iUVAH°S WTTNBSSBS, INCORPORATHD, Harry B, Baker, 812 Txving Place,
Anaheim, California, as Authorized Agent, requesting permission to
I HRBC.T A CHUR~I ON A PARCBL QF IAND LBSS THAN ONS (1) ACRB IN ARBA;
also to supply oii-street parting for said use, on the property
deucribed as 1751 Orange Avenue, on the north side of said street
be.~tween Fann Stree: and Culber~son Drive. TLe property is presentiq
ciassified R-A, RHSIffiNfIAL AGRICULTURAL.
IRr. Harry H. Baker, 812 Irving Place, appeared before the Commission
ns /~uthorized Agent for the Anaheim Congregatioa of Jehovah°s Wit-
I •nesses, Incorporated, and stated that he understood a petition had
been filed by pxoperty owaers in the area protestiag the graating
of this variaace, for the reason that their properties would be
devaluated by the zntrusion of this uae. He stated that in taiking
with appraisers ans realtozs~ they do not believe that a church
devaluates adjoiniag properties. He stated that the people most
vitally affected would be thoA: an Pann Strest, whose rear yard
would back up to the church property, and they propoae to erect a
stona or cement block wa11 that would protect these properties from
any noise or glare from h~:adlights. He also stated that their
principal evening meetind during the week ie on Priday night, and
that this is over by 9;3~ p,M. Mr. Baker went into deteil 3a des-
cribing the building to l~e erected~ stating that it would be ve=p
presentable from Orange A.yenue, with a stone front, and with parkiag
on the sides and rear of the property. Mr. Paul B, Clark, 1760
West Orange Avenue, apr,eared beEore the Commission ia oppositioa to
the granting of the .~ariance, ca the grc~:.ds that the area was eom-
posed of all single familq residencea a~d that there would be oaly
a narrow entrance into the church parking ir,t, and that there would
probabl.y be parkiag along the street aise. He alsn stated that he
was not opposed to a community church in Lhe area, but they appar-
Patly had no members in the immediate vicinity who vmuld be attending
thia church without driv3ng to it. Mr. Don L. Raworth, 1790 West
Orange, stated that the shape of the parcel was not auitable for a
church, and that he had been connected with 4he eatablishment of
three churches, and a parcei slightly under an acre was not large
enongh for this use, especially in an area where there might be a
devaluation of homes. He stated that the homes in this area run
between $20~000. aad E21.000 each in vaiue.
-1-
G
~
$:
___._._____- --- __ ._
~ ~, ~
~
._ _ _ . __ -- --.___--- -.. ____ ..__--.
„,
I
Y ~ ~~
' ~
~ ADJU[?g,*Lp aEgJLl4R 1kBSPING, CITY PLANNING CONAfISSION, APRIL 21, 1958, CONf'D:
yAR7llI~1C$ I~iO. 948 - Nr. Ray Coada~ 5~? Faan Street, stated that his home had a rear
(Coxitianed) liviag room and pa.tio, which would bact up to the church property~
affi that he purchased the property with the expectation that after
8 p.M. in the evenings he could have privacy. He stated that al-
though they stated 9:30 P.M, was the closing hour, aothing could
prevent them from running until 11 P.M, or later. Mr. Louis
Humphery, 1772 West Orange, stated that the realtors told him there
Nou2n certaialy be a property dEVaiuation in the area if a church -
rieze permitted. Mr. Sam Snodgrass, 1779 West Orange, gtated that
he purchased his psoperty while it was still in the couaty~ aad '
that the developmeat that has taken place since that time has oniy '
been single familq residences. : reciassification of this particu-
lar propertq for R-3 was recently requested, and this use also was
protested by the residents in the area. Mr. J• H. Stroh, 505 Pann
Stzeet, stated that all the property owaers except one on Fann
St=eet backing up to thia property are opposed to this use on ,
accovnt of loss of privacy, as they all have iiving roams a# the
rear of their dwellings. Mr. Saker was given the priviler,e of
aasrering the argumeats presented by the opponents to tY.is use of
the property, and stated that the parking rec~uiremeats were suff i-
cient aad that the rules of their. church limit the nusner of
people to approx3mately 150 pes church. This obviate~; the necess-
ity of building a big church when any of their parisaes reach about
150 people, then they begin to find a new site. The driving in and
out of the parking lot of 35 cass maximum would be within a period
of probably 30 miautes, so t hat the traff ic in and out would oniy
be an occasional car, as services are held at 3 O'Clock in the
afte=nooa aad ?:15 at night. He reiterated the stateQeat that he
did not think that ihe church bui~ding would devaluate surrounding
propertiea; and thst in the~r survey of the area, they believe that
this 2ot is large enough to meet their requirements. THH F~ARING
MA3 CIASBD.
Upon a motion by Commissioner Mauerhan, seconded by Commissioner
DnBois, and carried, it was moved by Resolutioa No. 234, Series ~
1457-58, that Variance No. 948 be denied, becaase the property in '~
qnestion contaias less than one full acre. Por the mat~er of ~
record, the above motion carried ty a vote of five Commissioners #
ia favor, three Commissioners aga3nst, and oae Commissioner abseat. ,
VABEAlR~ NO. 949 - P[iBLZC HBARING. PHTITION sabmitted by RI(~iARD D, and GLADYS J.
DHAR, 4327 Louisiaaa Street, San Diego, California, as Ownera,
requesting permission to lease, for use as a RSAL BSTATB OPPICH,
the property described as 9082 Lincoln Avenue, on the sou4h side
of said street betvrpen Gilbert Street and Magnolia Aveaue. The
propertq is pzesently classified as R-A, RHSIDHNfIAL AGRICIJLTURAL.
James Utterbach appeazed befose the Commissioa as Authorized Agent
for the Owaers, and stated that the property to the Bast aad West
is presentiy zoned as C-1, Neighborhood Comne rcial. He also stated
that no one in the area ia against the proposed use, which wili be
ia the dweiling which is on the oroperty at the preaent time. TtID
F~ARING MIAS CLOSBD.
Upon a motion bq Commiasioner Thompaon, seconded by Com~isaioner ~
Alired, aad carried, it was moved by Reaolution No. 235, Series • ;
1957-58~ that Variance No. 949 be gran4ed, subject to the providing ~
of four off-street improved parking spaces upoa the property, and ",•
liniting aay advertising sigas to not over two, four feet by ten
feet. ?
VARIAI~B PA. 950 - PIIBLIC HHA.RING. PSfITION riubmitted by °BNNBTH R. KII~S, 525 iVeat
Hampshire, Anab{eim, Califosnia, as Owuer, re~uesting permisaion to
QON3fRUCT A 31 UNIT MO~TBL, with Maaager's residence and awimming
pool, oa the property described as lying on the north side of
~Z_
;
_
a ,,~ -- --- _.__ _ _ _ . ... ..__. .. .._ _ _ ..,... _....___._..__._._._.......... ..__._... - ---__ i
. ~
_ ~
.: '
_ .,
, .__.___ .
S_ .- : ~ ~
± ~€ v
~~ ~~g ~~3 c~y ~ E~Ig5If11~, A~PRIL Z:t, 1958, CONf'D.
r
.~jA,~ ~. ~-=,nt~2 b~, a~_gg fer; dest cf ~bor ~auleward. The property
;~) =s ~°'"'*~ ~~a~fie~ C-_, PFEI(~OOD COd~RCIAL.
~. ~S ~~y~ ~ga:e ~e ,C•,~*aQ*oQ aad preaeated plana of the
~f I~e ~d ze, V-tct cs t~e $atr,~ct groperty. TH& FiSARiNG
~S ~.
~pp~, ; ~•,~ ~ ~C~ ~;~c~r Dba~ris, secoaded bp Commissioner
~s~sed! ~ad ~~~it3~ i~ ~•i ~cs~d hq 8esc2ution No. 236, Series
~~-Sg~ ~~ p~:~--t ~. 95ED tr~ grsmted~ suDject to:
y„ g3r dc~r3~g ~: E~ `:'e~: ~zom tIIe ceater3ine of gatella
g~eme to ~e Cizg cf Am~ei~ €~or street wideaing.
T~. Bagir~eer~i ='et~a:=t~e~ts.
~A.~ IlaD_ 952 - Fitii~.LC ~83~G. ffiY8T~f1t ~i::ecII hg A. DBAN und RUTFi NARATH,
~T,~ gy~„~ ~:, ,9~~eim, C~Iliffor~, as Owaers, requeating
p~is~sica m]I13~ 3~~1F BESiID&PiFFAL HOUSB on the rear of
~t n u7Z ~~sz~~ S;reet, a,m t~e Ea.st s~de of sa:d street, between
c+~.+~ ~~ 9sea~es_ 'YYtoee gropertp is presently classi-
€iai 1~, 3~53~Q'+fYd1i. B~i~t1H..
l~rs,. ~ Barat~ a,~,~,earzd Tme€c~e tL~e Co~rtissfoa aad ~tated that they
ar~Zme ~ ffi~ ; s~?~. ffioa~se fro~ t2ce other side pf Haster Street
te tfie re=r ~ y~ei= praa~ectg ~ tme ea~t side of Haster Street,
~I tbst a33 af. :~en.: 9efg~s are agzeeatrie to thfs use of the
gza~eri-: _~~~,oe~~ ~secII £a~rm acro~a the street wonid be f or
lErs_ 3~.~azi•s ~~ts. 'Y~ nttt~ yi{~AS CF.OSBD.
Eppo¢ a aozi~ ~uq ,C~n~-E~r Dmau~ezlsa~, seconded by Commissioner
~ali; aa8 ~r~, i~ a~as ~a~¢~cE 4sg aesolution No. 237, Series
Ic~jj-jg, ~2 Zr~rj9MA Il~. 95n IDe agg=oved to permit the location
~~~sz ~~ ~:~ :~a~ cft tiee su~Ject groperty as shown on
tffi g2~ glaa.
~R7liII~ IlYD. 952 -~.iC ~'s=•~-. ffi~'I@o s~L~ttedl b+g SANL iTICBNTB BUILD$RS, INCOR-
~, 123 *Ea,~~ p3~ea:~ Acc~re~ Aaahe3.~, California, as Lessee,
g,~rg L~er, ~~ s~~ssf ~s ftwaer, =equesting perQission to erect
~~r~s7 ~~~-i ~ i~Oe p=op~eztg desc=ibed as '121 Nor4h Pla-
~ati3 Ayr~e, aa3 ff~-~s ~eacriiaecII as Zging oa the west side of
eT~ ~ree: bet~er~ Cea~z Strreet affit xedwood Avenue. The property
is grese~~.p ~~as~sffi &-~1.. RFS~IAL /iG&ICQLTtTRAL.
NO eo~ a~pe-~se~d gaa m: against tke grantting of this variaace. THB
~ ~ Q33gIf.
t~pon i ao~im by c~~ieoer AE2red, secoaded by Commissioaer
'ffio~s,~, aad u~ae~_ i~ ~sas maved hy Sesoiution No, 238, Sesies
Y957-SS, ~a2 ~'~z~~~~ Il~. 9S2 ~e g=aateQ, subject to limitiag any
f2oo3li~htia~ of said ss~ to ZQ O~Clocf~ F.M.
~ D~_ g53 - pQ$,~C ~13~_ ~i'I~IQQ sabmitte~ ~tg SA6[ COSTHLLO, 217G Sall
~~ ~i~, ~ifaruia= as S.essees Fre~ Miiler; same esidress, as
p~eer, =eqnestis+~ ~;Q"~+ 1to instap2 a Keaa SIGN an the property
~~*'~ as 27;3~ Bali tea~. ~i €arthes described as lyiag on the
santh s"s3s o~ sa:~4 s:~eert beto~eea Broothurst Street and Nutwood
Ave~_ ~e ..~ i.~ pae~eat~g cZass€fied Gl, NBIQiB0RFI00D
iJ3f0~L~
3re ooe apg~ear~d fcr ~a agaiast t2se graating of this variance. THS
~8tt~6 ~Li S Q0:4a.
It os ~t oe'. at t~:. ~eariag that these stores are iocated some
'P6~ feet ~ast ~raa tt~e pzapeai~ IIime~ ~ that it is the deaire of
ti~e a~gi;~~# tn ~ve tt~ sigm oa the f=oat of the building at
t~e pxrsest 23~e ama~l p3a,x it on the Sail Boad frontage where it
can be aeen_
~~
------ - -
-' a:
~`~
~
~
~
[
t
i
t
k
~:
~
~ ?
z
,;~~
~
MIN[Tf86 ~ ADJO[JRt~ffiD RSf~T7Jl8 M88P3lH~, 3'1Z~3' H''~ ~~ gL, I458, C~TL' D:
VARIANCB N0. 953 - Upon a mot3aa ~y ~: ~~ IIg Coafsafoaer
(Continued) Thompaaa, and ss:x~., ~ s~s ~a~ tipg ~ Nc. 23g, geries
1957-3B, ~~ ~+g,~~...~ ~. ~ ~ ~~_
YARIANCB N0. 954 - P[JBLIC ~~1 ~ hjg ~:'ff~' ~g, g~_~ 1200
1Pest Ball ~oaff, .~ ~~~ ~ ~cr, se~~st~ag Peraissioa
to operats a~. ~~~ t~ ~mpertg ~scrfbed as Lot 1, ,
of Tract No. 1~B1., $ad rFs..^~ ~ as 2ZQQ gest gg.tL RoaQ,
the sonthuesf ~~~a1:7 ~~g p~S~t ~t_ Tae property
ia pxseatl~ ala~s3~~ ~-Il„ ~ E~g' ~L.
Mz. $icliarfl ~;, ~~~ t~ r~~:a~{,,.. aad atated
that he smd=xsta~nd fhat ~ ffi~~~t gosaftrig ob ject
to t2~e graatiag .~ ~•rar~,, 5~ tBat ~ aalg se2ls vacant
propert3e~ aad sanlfl ~~$~~ H~ stated Lhat
Le has a~~b ~~y T.~ ~~~ F~ froat lawa,
stat3.ng thaf ~e 3~ ~~„ ~C ~~x~ ~ ig zeqgired by
state la~v. ~ a13su ~ar~:d ~~~~e .~ tE~ a~g a~ that faces
Ball 3toafl, and fhat ~is ~ m~ ws~ usff as a eadei lsome
for a peri~i s~ t~e ~~mrt'~ ts~e ~ was ~I~ aat. He atated
that tbe iimise 3~ ~'~ am~ £mc ~g2~ ~~iig resideatial
uae nn atccnat s~ 2`Le ~~.+,.,..* a~ tr~ic a¢ Hz.EI BoaQ. O~tr,
Jo~ J. ~e~r1, ~~ t~tl.a~t ~,. ~xgeared tiefore the
~O~ ~d ~~ ~~ wa~ ~ tII~ Cm~s~f.oa a petitioa
BiS~d ~%7 33 ~~~~~ gsatestiag t.~ae graatiag of .
tY1~8 YBS~ wnro ~~DI 2~C II•~_~~ rsdsQt++~a
1. T~at ~ ra~ az v~ £~ ~ffS ~t~te Offfce wonlQ
~=F='~ ~z^-~°""~ ~+^*~ mm tS2~ t~ct, aad taat the
$ra~3ng a~ Y~ rs~-'e~„~,~,e ~~ I~ t~ uBES CtLter thsa
2n~;~+..,,~r3a1 3a ~ ~„
2. 3~~t 2~~~ ~~_.-_--.-a=r axesa a4aiSa6Ic in the
Ci2-~ _~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ estaD2~tred,
3, That i. ~nu1fl ~*+~ ~~-~s,- ~ aaise to the
ne3ghDnri~ ~ ~_
He also .staYzd 2~~ ffiae Hm~ ~~ Y.~ t~c Fzopertg, aad
haa a siga ~E 3aahe~ ~- ~~s ~ t2~ S~a~t £~ the Iara at the
preee~ tiee., a~ ~uS~ ~ ttn l5e a a~a:F~t~ Tlsere is
alao no n~'~~ ~~~ s~e ~g. 6tr. James P.
BlacJ~bnra, 3Z11 Smri~ ~~„ ~~£are tLe Co~saioa
as be3ag ~e ~~*~* ~~ t~c ti~as p~tF. aa~ xf.aheQ to go
on recosd as 3s3ag m,~ tha t~ ~~_ ~ atso state~ that
there arae ao ~•~.:++~a~ m~' ~'-~ ~r~ag a~ the pro~esty.
Atr. RicharII ~~ ~~~~ t~e ~o~ affi sta4eQ
that tLert a.ou13 ~e ~~~~ ffas ~~ess ~2oa~ tI~e atreet,
as he xas ~s~amt3ag ~~~ ~~ T~..r ~ect_ He fttrther
siateQ ~hat t'he ~exx3 ~-a --~ ,.T'9° s~ tE~ s~eet ta tII~ Ha&t
would not ~e aiseII ffar ~~. 'CGe reafdeat of tiie
~~ Pr~~9 ~~! ~~ x~~ec~ g~s~ezC}r ~ aat tept up and
reas more a~ lrss aF an ~ 7m s~e ~ a£ t~Le propestiea of
this ~razt_ 3~ ~ i~ ~~~~
A motiom ~aas ~affe ~y ~~ ~, ~~ ~ C~Baioner
)(orr3s, aad ~~ _~ m?Y ~ 3~ ~,~"r Ser~es 2457-58,
Variaact 3Qo. i~ ~e ~ ~ ~mc
1. 34~e appn~t3aa aff 53 ~yq ~ to t8e estaD2fa~en! of
~his a~se a~' ~ ar~~ ~
2. 3~a4 no s$'ff~ ~ aamII~ ~e xe~rsr~ra aa the anbject
Pt~'3-
VARIANCB N0. 956 - PITBLIC ~~ ~iIT~li ~~ ~ ~ ~I@i COAf-
PANY, 1111 ~eae~l,y ~a~II,. i~sa„ ~S~£~, as ftsdee~
requestiag pe~,ffi ~a ~~ a~~~Q~ SI6K adver-
-~4-
~
F
~
i
~~ _~
'ti~
~.~
~
^,~
r.!
-.j
;~
;j
..-- ~ . __. _ .__.. _ . ...,,._~.__, _ . ,.._...,......_ .. ~..,....~..u~,...~.,,~........... __.___- -- -
~ g ~~ ;°i
~~ _
MINUTB3, ADJOURI~D RBG[1IAR t.~SfING, CTTY PLANNING C01~9dISSION, APRIL 21, 1958, O~Nr'D:
VARIANGS N0. 956 - tising sale of homes in Tract Na. 1812, in the Citq of Anaheis,
(Cont3nued) containing 51 lots, on the property described as being betxeen Mest
Street and Harbor Boulevard, lying 200 feet Bast of 12142 Yateila
Avenue. The property is presentiq ciassified R~,, RHSIDHNPIAL
AQtICULTURAL.
No one appeared for or against the granting of this variaace. TF~
HBAIt12iG WAS CLOSBD.
Upon a motion by Commissioner Mauerhan, seconded bp Comaissioner
Morris, and car:ied, it was moved by Resolutioa No. 242, Series
1957-SS, that Variance No. 956 be denied, inasmuch as this siga
would be in the Disneyland area, where such signs have been res-
tricted.
VARIANCB NO. 955 - PUBLIC HBARING. PETITIOK aubm3ttpd by IARAMORB CONSfRUCfIOi~I CW~!-
ppNY, illl Bever.ly Boulevard, Whittie=, California, as Lessee,
requesting permission to erect a temporary directioaal SIQi adver-
tising the sale of homes in Tract No. 1812, in the City of Anaheia,
containing 51 lo*s, oa the property describeA as the soutbeast
corner of Walnut and Ratella Avenues. The property is presently
classified R A, RHSIDBNfIAL AGRICULTURAL.
No one appeared for or against the granting of this variance. 1HB
HBARING WAS CIASBD.
Upon a motion by Commissioner Summezs, seconded by Cos~issioaer
Hapgood, apd carried, it was moved by Res~lution No. 241, Series
1957-58, that Variance No. 955 be granted, subject to the niae
conditioas estabiished by the City Council for sueh directional
signs.
RHCIASSIFICATION - PUBLIC F~ARING. PSfITION submitted by HSNRY and Cf~tISTII~ YRAIBR,
NO. P-57~58-33 LIONBL H. BROWN, HARLBY L. HOSRINS, and DR. HDWARD J. FIORHLIA, of
321, 125, 205 and 111 North Placentia Avenue, respectively, and
~IORGAN McCOLLWGH, 649 ~outh Oiiva StreeF, Los Aageles 14, Cali-
fornia, as Owaers, requeeting that the property described as lil,
121, 125, and 205 North Placentia Avenue be reclassified froa R-A,
RBSIDHNfIAL AGRICIJLTURAL to Gl, NBIC~iBORFi00D COAO~ffiRCIAL.
Reclassification No. P~57-58-33 was scheduled for a Heariag on this
date, due to a faulty legal description of the properties as ori-
ginally published. At this Hearing it was brought out that the
Brown and Hoskins properties at 125 and 205 North Placeatia Aveaue,
respectively, desired to be left out of this proposed Reciassifica-
t iaai.
L'pon a motion by Commissioner Mungail, aeconded by Commissioaer
Summe=s, and carried. it was moved that Reclassification No.
P~57-58~33 be held over for one month or until the Meeting of I4ay
19, 1958.
RBCLA3SIPICATION - RJBLIC HBARING. PSfITION submitted bq HBHItY DAYIDSd2i anfi SI"i,i.nY
NO. P-57-58-37 McMURDO. 5124 On3crest Drive, Los Angeles 43, California, as Orners,
requesting thet the propertq descrlbed as Lots 1 through 18 of Ten-
tative Tract No. 1988, being an extension of Archer Street to tLe
North, and further described as lying 330~feet Bast -f Brookhurst
Avenue on the North side of Orange Avenue, haviag a frmtage on
Orange Avenue of 335 feet aad a depth of 701.64 feet, be recla~si-
fied from R-A, RBSIDHNTIAL AGRICULTURAL, to R-3, M[TLTIPIB FAMILY
RBSIDBNfIAL.
Z~vo representatives of the applicant appeazed before the Coaission
and atated their reasons for believing that the Reclassificr.tion
ahould be granted. These reasons were, namely:
-5-
- - ._
~,
~
~~
~
;
I ~
~ ~
~
- -,y
~} ~ ~
ADJOURI~ffiD RBGUTAR MBSfING, CITY PI.ANNING COI~+IlNISSION, APRIL 21, 1958, MINUTBS, CONf'D:
R~ICIASSIPICATION - 1. The properLy is a Sogical btlffer zone betweea the C-1 prop-
N0. P-57-58-3? erty aa the West and the R~1 on the Bast.
(Continued) 2. The dwellinga planned for the multiple family reaidential
unita rvi11 be better than average.
3, There will be ra windows in these uaits on the aecond atory
facing 9ast. •
4. The alley will act as an additional 'buffer.
5. If left as R-1~ this will put saagle-familq next to C-1,
which is not good plaaniag.
A representative of property owaers on Valley Street appeared be_°ore
the Commiasion. He presented a petition containing 39 names of
ownera on this etreet objectiag to the proposed reclassification,
and stated that on the $outh side of the street, Hawaiian Viliage
has a subdivision next to C-l with $20,000, homes~ and no buffer.
He also stated that these homes range at approximately ~17,000. in
this tract just Sast of the proposed reclassification, and that
they were interested in looking at the rear of other homes, rather
than apartments with a blank wall. Mr. Geae Poweli, 409 Valley Street
appeared before the Commission and etated that he understood that
the su~w~ivider would sell lots, and if this is the case~ what assur-
snce have the property avners that attractive buildings would be
erected, Mrs. Wayae B. Blate, 429 Valleq Street, appeared be£ore
the Commission and stated that they objected to the alley next to
thie property, as an alley usually has many trash cans and is very
unattractive, Mr. A. R. McDaniels, as Bngineer for the aubdivider,
appeared before the Commission and stated that with condition with
regard to the Niells' propertq on the south s3de of the street was
somewha~ different, as they own the R-1 subdivisioa and also own
the land which is presently zaned C-1, Neighborhood Commercial,
and that they can control the C-1, which is placed on their property.
He also stated that good planning called for G-1 with aa R-3 buffer
between commercial and residential, and that with a 20 foot alley,
and car ports, all traffic would come in through the alley. He
also stated that it would be agreeable to the aubdividers to set np
aa Architectuxal Committee so that the type of dwelliags ~rected
would be in keeping with the area. TFffi 1~ARING WAS ~IASHD.
Upon a motion by Commissioner Mauerhan, seconded by Commissioncr
Allred, and carried~ it was moved by Resolutioa No. 243, Series
1957-58, that Reclassification IVo, F-57-SS-37 be recommeaded to
the City Couacil for apprcval for R-3~ Multiple Pamily Reaidentiai~
and aubject to:
I. That lots 1- 9 be kept for dwellings only one aLory in
height.
2. That the ailey on the Bast ai.de of the property be eiiminated.
3. That the Standard R-3 Deed Restrictions of the City of Anaheim
be recorded on the propertq.
The vote oa the above Resolution was as follows:
AYBS: COMMISBIONBRS: Allred, DuBois, Gauer, Hapgood, Mauerhan,
Morris, Sumsers~ Thoespsot! aad Mungell.
NOBB: COMMISSIONIDRS: None.
ABBHNT: COhUlISSIONSRS: None.
RBCIABSIPICATION - YUBLIC HBARING. PSfITiQN aubmitted by ROBBRT L. WBTZLHR, 929 Spriag
NO. F-57-58-47 Street, Aaaheim, California, as applicant, Steve Gallagher, Califor-
nia Bant Building, Aaahetm, Califoraia as Authorized Ageat, requeat-
ing that the propertq deacribed as 8052 Ball Road, aa the south aide
of said street between Staatoa aad Daie Avenuea, be seciassified from
R A, RSSIDHNTIAL AGRICULTIIRAL to Gl, NBIGIiSORHUOD COhAIDRCIAL.
-6-
,~ ----- - _ ~ _ ._._ . ...__--- _ .. __-- ---_..__ _--__ _..____.~
---- -- - -- - ----------- - -
,- -
f
~ ` „~ , n
j ~_. f ~, _
MIN[TTBS, ADJOURI~D RBGUTAR hffiSTING, CITY pLANNING COMMISSION, April 21, 1958, CONf'D:
RBQA~SIPICATION - Mr. Robert Wetzler appeared before the Commissioa and explained
N0. F-S7-58-47 that thia parcel is oae which was iacluded in a previaua zeclasai-
CContiaued) ficatioa, which was abandoned because some of the other propertq
owners in the area wouid aot agree to the improvements requeated by
the City. No one appeared in oppoaition tothe graating of the
reclassifieation. TH8 HBARING WAS CLOSBD,
Upon a motion by Commiasioner Morris, seconded by Commissioner
Allred, and carried, it was moved by Resolution No. 244, &eriea
1957-58, that Reclasaificatioa No. P-59-58-47 be recommended to the
City Council for approval for reclassification to C-1, tieighborhood
Comruercial, aubject to;
1. Deedi-tg of 53 feet from the centerliae of Bali Road to the
City of Anaheim for street widening.
2, The filing of S'tandard C-1 Deed Restrictions of the City of
Anaheim.
3, The installati.on of all improvements as required by the City
Bngineer,
The vote on the above Resolution was as fo2lows:
AYBS: COMMISSIONIDRS: Alired, DuBois, Gauer, Hapgood, Mauerhan,
Morris, Summers, Thompson and Mungall.
NOBSf COMMI3SIONBR~.: Nono.
ABSENT: CQMMISSIONBRS: Noae.
RBCIASSIPICATION - PUHLIC 1~ARING. At the request of Mrs, Chris Menzie, the Authorized
N0, F-57-58-48 Agent for Lhe applicant, postponement of the Hearing on thia Reclass-
ification was requested until the next meeting, which wiil be May
5, 1958.
MAC~IOLIA SCHOOL - A letter was received from Rex S. Nereson, Husiaess Manager of the
DISfRICf Magnolia School Distriet, requeating that the Commieaion approve
two new school aites; one achool to be known as Number 6, the
property deacr3bed as the South 12 acrea of the Bast 30 acrea of the
NS} of the NW~ of Bection 13, T4S, Ri1W. S.B.S. & M„ and Schooi No.
7, the South 10 ucres of the B~ of the NW~ of Seetion 13, T4S,
R'1W, S.B.B. & M.
Upon a motion by Cummiasioner Thompaon, seconded bq Commissioner
Summers, and carried, it was moved that the above aitea be recommen-
ded to the Magnolia School District as being suitable for thia uae.
TBNrATIVE MAp OP - A Tentative Map of Tract No. 1782 was presented to the Commisaion,
TRAGT N0. 1782 T~9.~ 3,ract ia iocated east of South Placentia Avenue, oa Weatport
Street. The aubdivider is the Wagner Resity Compaay~ 1022 South
~ La Cienega Boulevard, Los Aageles, California. The Lzact coataias
17 R-3 lots.
A repreaentat,ive of the Wagner Coastruct3on Company, owner of the
tsact, appeared before the Commissioa and stated they plaa to erect
two-story buildinga oa these lots and that there would be 40 feet
in depth to the rear of the property 1ine, A repreaeatat3ve of
property owners in Tract No. 2688 appeared before the Commieaioa
and preaented a petitioa containing S3 names and 10 iettera from
property ownera in the tract opposing two-story deve2opment near
their R-1 residencea. Thie apokeaman atated that they feel the
area ia suitable for R-3, but it ahould be 1imiLed to one story.
Mr. Nerenbsum, as Hngineer for the tract 1782, appeared be~ore the
Commisaion and atated that the queatiun evolVed of the approVai of
the Tract Map only, and not a queation of tblull~tl~. He s4ated that
-7-
(~ .--- .
i
~--.~
~ ~
.._._.e...-...~.,,..-.~....,._....e,s.,.m.......»..........~_,._._
~ ;
..~._...._... ~---.~..~.._ .... '~
i
_
~
~~
~I~AIf~, ADJWAlIDD lt~tlAR A~BfING, CITY PL#NNING COhAlISSION, APRIL 21, 1958, coat'd:
TBKfATIVB NA8 OF - privacq could be obtaiaed by piacing the wiadows on the aecond
'!'RA(,T I~10. 1782 story aa long and aarrow at a height of 6 faet, 8 iachea, or they
renld eii4iaate the windowa eatirely. Mr. RoberL J. Hali, S10
Priacilla ATay, appeared before the Commisaicn and stated that h~
eauid like to see Priacilia Way atay as a deud-end street, It wes
poiated out that in the origiaai deaign of Tract No. 2688, that the
:;atq inteaded this atreet to be exteaded northerly i~ order to get
circuiation for the water aystem, aewera, trash collection aad fire
protection. It was the opinioa of the Commisaion that Priac:ilia
ldap rould aot be used to any extcnt by the reaideats of the muitipie
fawily d~relliags, as they would go directly out Westport Street to
Placeatia, or North to Anaheim-Olive Road on a atreet tt:at will be
provided at the Sasterly end of Tract No, 1782, THH HBAItING WAS
CI.aSBD.
IIpon ~ motion by Commiasioner Thompson, seconded by Commisaioner
Summera, aad carried, it was moved that the Tentative Map of Tract
No. 1782 be approved~ aubject to:
1. ThaL Priseilla Avenue be made a 60 foot etreet. fl
2. That the owaer of the aubject tract contect the owner of the
property to the Hast in an attempt to reach an a~reemeat to
develop proposed '~A" Stneet as a fuii 60 foot width street.
In the event of the failure of the ownera to agree upon said
street, Street °A" to be constructed as a 30 foot a11ey with
fu12 sidewalk developa~nt oa the West side.
3, That in the eveat Teatative Tract No. 3288 to the Weat ia
aot construeted prior to the coastruction of the aubject
tract, a 30 foot easement with aubseqqent full improvementa
thereof for street purposes be obtained along the Bast boun-
dary of the existiag ahopping ceater to connecL propoaed "A"
Street with Aaaheim-Olive Road.
4, That Lota 1-8 iaciueive faciag Westport Street be iimited to
multipi~ family dweliiaga of only one atosy in height.
5. 8ngia~ering requirementa.
~II'ATISB 11A~' OF - A Tentative Map of Tract No, x988 was preaented to the Commisafon.
TRAL.T H~O. 1988 This is the Trect conaidered uader Reclasaification No. P-57-58-37,
and upon a mot3.on bq Commiseionei° Mauerhaa, aeconded bq Commisaioner
ThoOpson, and carried, it was mo~~ed that Lhe Tentative Map of Tract
No. 1988 be approved, subject 20:
1. The elimination of ti;a a~iey on the 8est si3e of the Tract.
2. Hagiaeeriag requiremeats.
(The tract is located oa the North aide of Orange Avenue, 335 feet
east of Bsoothurst Street~ contaiaiag 18 lota proposed for R-3,)
1'SH1'ATIVB 11AP OF - This t=act ia located aouth of Orangewood Avenue, 330 feet Bast of
1RA(,T IdO. 2026 Loara Street. The subdivider is thz Hintz Conatruction Company,
1545 Hatella Avenue, Anaheim, California, Coataias 29, R-1 lota.
Upoa a motion by Commieaioner Mungali, aecoaded by Commiesioaer
Hapgood, aad carried, it ticae moved that the Teatative Map of Tr:.ct
No. 2026 be approved, subject to:
i. That ahould th3s aubdivision be deveioped as more than one
aubdiviaion, each auccesaive aubdiviaion thereof aha11 be
aub4itted in Tentative fozm for approval.
2. Hngiaeeriag requirements.
TEt~ifATiVB DIAp OP - a Tentative map of Tract No. 2031 was preseated Lo the Commisaion.
TRACf I90. 2031 T6e tract ia iocated on the weat aide of Nutwood Street~ approxi-
nateiq 372 feet north of Cerritas Aveaue, Subdivider, Moore Buiit
Homea, 10401 5outh MagnoYia Avenue, Anaheim, Califoraia, Contair~s
S0, R-1 lota.
-8-
,s - --- ---- - - --- -_ __ __..... _----- -- --___ _~_ ---------~ ac
t _.~
i
~ ~
, .
~`
~i
- ,~~
°J '
MIN[1TPS, ADJWRNSD RHGUTAR l~BTING, APRIL 21, 1958, CITY PLINNING C01~9+IISSION, CONT'D:
TENTATIVS MAP aP - Upon a motion bq Commissioaer NauerLaa, seconded by Commissioner
TRACE N0. 2031 Alired, aad carried~ it was aoved that the Tentativ~ Map of TracL
No. 2031 be approved, snbject to:
1. That shouid this subdivision be developed as aore than one
subdivisioa, each successive subdivisioa thereof shall b¢
submit•!rd ia teatative for4 for approvai,
2. Bngineering requi=eaeats.
TSNfATIVB MAP OF - A Tentative Map of Tract No. 2757 xas subsitted to the Commission.
'TRACE N0. 2757 This tract is located on the 3ast side of Sou3h Los Angeles Street,
approximately 1100 feet sarth of Reraont Avenue. The subdivider is
Bernier lYealty, 1014 South Los Angeies Street, Anaheim, California.
Contains 12 lots, one lot zoned C-2, aad the balaace of il lots
zoned R-3.
It was found upon examination of the map ttiat lots 3- 9 ia-clusive
;uere under the aiaimun 70 foot frontage required bq the Anaheim
Municipai Code; therefore, a sotion ~ras sade by Commissioner Thomp-
son, seconded bq Comeissioner Mauerhan, and carried, that approval
of this map be defezred until the meeLiag of May 5, 1958, am that
the subdivider be required to file for a variance of the under
sized frontage lots.
PROPOS~D RHVISION--It was the consensus of npinion .~f the Cu~ission tLat further study
OP ~8(.TION 9200.7 shouid be givea to the proposed chaage before reco~nendatioa to the
R-3, MULTIPLB PAM- City Couacil.
ILY. R831DBNrIAL
~ONB
P80POSHp CHANG83 - General Provisions a~ Bxcegtioas; A. Use; 2. Parking Requiremeats;
TO SHCTION a. Area.
9200.14
Upoa a motion by Co~issioner Thompson, seconded bq Comaisaioner
Hapgood, and carried, it vr~s aoved by Resolution No, 245, Series
2957-58, that this proposed change requiring a car port or garage
for each ldnltipie Family Residentiai Unit be recammeaded for
adoptioa by the City Council, a~ that it be put through as an
urgency ordinaace.
The vote on the above Resolution~ No. 245, Series 1957-58, was as
follows:
AYES: COI~AlISSIOAffiBS: Allred, DuBois, Gauer, Hapgood~ Mauerhan,
Morris, ~osers, Thompsoa and Mungaii.
NOBS: COt~9~lISSIQI~ffi&S: None.
ABSBNT: COA9~SISSIOlIDRS: None.
~1~11RN1~Nf - The Meeting adjourned at 5:50 0*Clock P.N,
Respectfuliy subaitted,
. ,
R. . bBTNGAI.L, Sec e ary
~
/
-~.._.__..-__.._.... =
_. Y~ , a .
-_.. . .--.- -- - ~
;
i
~
~,