Minutes-PC 1960/01/18----:--
t
Y'
i '
.__..._""__"..._.._..~.._~__.~...~.....,........~.-r~.+i~vsv~enewDAtallSd!GIZ'+vAm!!nrdtn!~s.nriwm.we~w.w -• __----=.._T
~ ~ ~~ ,
City Hall
Jaeuary 18, 1960
Anaheim, California
REGUIpR MBBTING OP Tl~• CFTY:~Idi~IF:~..Et~IY~ZSSION
RHG[IIAR MBSTING - A Regular Meetiag of the Citg. P1a~iag .Caa~ni.e4io~.a~aa•.called to order
af 2;10 0•Clock P.M. by Chairmatr ~auer, s quorun being present.
PRBSBNT - Chairma:r-fianer, Cbmmiseinoersti~,DeBoia,:. ilazeaa~c,..Naueshan, Morris,
3ummers, -Mungal'1. •°L•bmmiasioaes Hepgo~od entered..the•.meetiag at 2:50
0'C1ocIrP:M. ~ • • • • • . '
AHBSNT - Commis:~ioner Alired. '
MINiITES ~. - The mtnutea•-of• •tiae -Aegular Meetiag.of_ January-a,-.1960••ivere approved
., as printed.
VARIANCS r0. - PUBLIC HBARING, P3TITION sut~mitted by ALLSN B. RBLLY~ 1517 Hast '
1189 ' Olyapic Boulevard, Los Angeles 21, California, as Owner, requesting
permisaioa to OPBRATE AN P. W. WOOLW~tT:f COMPANY GARDHN CBNTBR POR
WTDOQt DISPIAY, AND RBTAIL SALE, on the property described as being
•• on the easti aide f Western Aveaue between Lincola Avenue and Del Monte
fr
~ ty is preaently ciassified C-1, t~IGHBatEi00D C~-
Drive. The prope
~ CIAL. .
A repreaentative of Allea E. He11y appeared before the Commisaion and ~
presented plot plaas arid showed a perspective of the proposed nursery ;
• instalistion. 1t-e bu31'ding to be erected will occupq 2904 square feet ~
• or 6.3~. The otrtdoor plant dispiays will occupq 3886 square feet or j
12.7~. The open garden saies wili occupy 12,544 aquare feet or 27.1% ~
••- and parking and'driveways ~ili occupy 25,044 aquare ft. or 53,996 of-the }
plot. 11ie P. N. Noolwarth Company aow has a aumber of these in- ~
ataliations ia aorthern California and plaa to have twelve ia southern ~•
California. ~
No oaa a~peared ia opp~aition to the graatiag of the Variance. THS ~
HBARING WA3 CLOSHD. ~
1959
60 t
i
i
4
f ~
o
-
on No. 1
9~ Ser
ea
Commias~loner Morrin,~ o
fered Aesolut
grant Variance No. 1189 in accordaace with piot pian sad buiiding ,
plana preaented. . ~
,~
~
1]~is reaolution was seconded by Comm3esioner DuBoia and carried.
1be vote on the above reaolution wea as foliowa: ~
AY38; COMMIBSION~3: DuHois~ Gauer, Marcoux; Mauerhaa, Morris, '
Summers, Muagall. '
NOBS: COI~lISSIONBR3: None.
AH9HNT: COhAlIS3IONffit3: A11red and Hapgood. ;
VARIA*iC6 N0, - PUBLIC HBAAING. PSTICIQid aubmitted b!~ ALLBN B. SP,i.LY, 1517 Hast ~
1190 Olympic Boulevard, L~s Angelea 21, Caiifornia, as Owner, requeatiag ~
permissioa to C(~N817.UCT AND OYBRA173 A GASOLINH SHRVICB STATION on t3~e '~
propertq deacribed us the soathwea~! coraer of Topaaga Drive and ~
Liacoia Aven~e. ltie preperty ia preseatly claseified C-1~ N8I(~IDORHOOD
Cd~CIAL. I
Ms. Robert B. 3cott, 794 Hast Wallace St., Pasndena, Caiif., appeared ~
before the Commission, repreaenting Mr. Ailen S. ~eliq. He atated
that thi8 would be a aervice atation oaly with no repair work and ,
primarily for the sale of gasoline only. lfie service staticn will be I
the aelf aervice 4y~e. ~
No one appeared in opposition to t~e grantiag of the Vgriance. TFffi '
HBARII~ iKA3 CLOSBD.
_1_
~
~-~ ~ ~
RHGUTAR I~BIIHG .- CITY PIdIB~iII~i OONISSION - JANUARY 18. 1960 -.CONTINUHD:
VARIANCB N0: - Cosissivner l(anerhan offered Resolution No. I50, Series 1959~60,
1190 tLat Variam~e Na. II90 be granted, sabject to~the plans presented ai:d
tCONTINU~iD)' t~xt it be a self service station.
1Lis resolution vas seconded bq Commissioner DuBois and carried.
1he vote oa the above resolutioa was as follows:
AYffi: ~t70~NIS3I0l~tS:DuBais, Mauerhan, Suomiers, ~9anga1l.
I~1~S: -~OdiQSSIQ~ffitS: Gauer. Marcoux, Marris.
ABSffi~f: 00~(ISSIOD~1tS: Allred and Hapgoed.
SPHCIAL USB- - PUBLIC HBA~ING. PBTTTION submitted by CBN11tAL CHURQi OP CFIAIST, 1590
YffitMTT N0. ~9 ifest Ball 8oad, Anahein. California, as Owner, requesting pz*.~mission
to OONSIItpCT p(7~R(~i AUDIT(~tIUM on the property described as being
on the south side of Ball Rd, betMeen Eaclid Avenue and Walnut Street,
and fnrther described as 2540~ West Bail Road. 1he property is presently
classified R=A, RBSIDHNfIAL AQtICULTURAL.
~e Rev. Jaaes C. Di~con. pastor of the Central Church of Christ
appeared before the Comission and stated that after purchas:ng their
original property on Ball Rd, they found thaL there was another half
acre available to the south. ~is parcel wiil be used for aa suditorivm
or parting space. He further stated that bonds for street improvements
had been filed.
No one appeared in opposition to the granting of the Special Use Permit.
~iH HBA1tI~IG M~A~+ CI.06SD.
Cac~issioner llungall offered Resolution No. 151, Series 1959-60, that
Special IIse ~er~it No. 59 be approved, subject to:
1, Providing drainage for property to the east.
2. ~e dedication of 53 Leet from the center line of Ball Rd. to the
City cf Anaheia.
3. Prepue str<:xt iaprovemeat plans and install all improvements in
accordance rith approved standard plans on file in the offi'ce
of Yl~e City Engineer.
4. 1b: papeent of SZ.00 per front foot for street lighting purposes.
5. Referr to Special IIse Permit No. 45 for plans and layout.
~is resolution ras seconded bp Commissioner Summers aad carried.
~e vote on the above resolution was as follows:
AYBS: Op01ISSIa1~tS: DnBois~ Gauer~ Marcoux, Mauerhaa, Morris,
~mmers, Mungall.
I~P''.~BS: OdYQ33I0l~t3: Noae.
B.Lt4H~r: OOMdISSZ~S: A21red and Hapgood.
RHCU33IPIGTIa1 - POBLIC F~ARING. A Telephone request was received from the attorney
N0. F-59-60-53 for J. ,j. Lou. 225 btall May, Anaheim, California asking that this re- j
classification be held ovex until April 18, 1960.
Upon a aotion by Ccr~issioner Morris, seconded by Commissioner Mauerhan
and carried, it was voted to grant this request to hoid Reclassification ;
llo. F-59-60-53 over natil April 18. 1960.
RBCIA9SIPICATI~i - PUBLIC EBARIYG. A letter ras received from the law office o€
N0. P-59-60-64 liyron lieyers, Long Beach. Califo*nia representiag M. S. and D. LeVinP,
requestireg thxt the petition for ct-ange of zone be piaced off calendar
natil fnrther aotice or request by Mr. LeViae or by said law office.
A~otioa ras ~ade by Comvissioner Summers~ seconded by Commissioner
fdorris aad carried, that this request be granted and the reclassifica-
tion placed of€ calendar until further notice by Mr. LeVine or the
office of MTron lleyers.
-2-
G ~t
~ .. _ - - __
f
1 '
1
~ ~~ ~
RHGULAR MH~TIN!'G - CITY FLANNING COh-MI33I~1 - JANUARY 18, 1960 - OONfINUBD:
RBCIA39IPI~lCTZ'OTl =-'YUBLI~~iBF-RING. pSTIT10N subait'teQ by GatDON M. HICBS ~ LLOYD B.
" N0. P=59-60+-"69 ' MWNf;'823 North Parton; 5anta Ana, California, as Owaers, requesting
•~that'the property'described as`being the northwesY corner of Melrose~and
-~• ~° Brottdway Streets, aad further described as 421 Bast Broadway Street,
be reclassified from R-3,~MULTIPLS PAMILY RBSIDSNTIAL to C-1~ NSIGHBOR-
HOOD COhafffitCIAL. ~
° • Mr: L. 8. Mount appeared before ~the Commission aad s~tated that he feels
-that slong Broadway shovld•aow be zoned for commercial offices, east of
Los Angeles St. He °stated ~he propm-ed-to put in a real estalte offi~e
~ ~ on this~corner remove the existing ganges and provide parkiag at-the
resr of the property. lhere was sor~ Z'~?~ussion amoag the Coamissioners
as to whether or not the entire bloct frou Olive Street to Melrose
- should not be changed to C-1 and two of the owners of other properties in
° the area signified that theq wouYd~like to have C-1 and py so doiag
• Mr. Mount or other owners would have a larger parcel of property to
-• redevelop with business offites and eventually make a much better
development for the area. 1he a licant, Mr. Lloqd H. Mount stated
that with the pri es of property~selling f~ee-in the area the owaers
could afford to r~~their present structures and erect new baildings.
No one appeared in opposition to the granting of the retlassification.
1HB HBARING WAS CLOSED.
Commissioner Morris o~ffered Resolutian No. 152, Series 1959-60 that
Reclassification No. 1P-59-60-60 be approved, subject to:
RHCLASSIPIGTION -
N0. P-59-60-70
1. The filing of C-1 Deed Resi:rictions as standard with the City of
Anaheim and approved by the City Attorney.
2. That the es?istiug garages at the rear of Lhe property be removed
and that the area back of the building be blacttoped to provide
off-street parktng. S~D~, f(pblrt
3. l~epair and replace ~ and curb as directed by the Public Works
Dept.
4. 'fhe paymeat of $2.00 per front foot for st., lig:.ciag purposes on
Melrose Street.
5. lhat a 90 day time limit be set for the accomplisbment of coaditions
1, 2, 3, and 4.
This resolution was seconded by Com~n3ssioner Mungall and ca~•ried.
The vote on the above resolution ~ras as follows:
AYS3: COMMI3SION~tS: Hapgood~ Marcoux. 3ummers, Morris~ Mungall.
li0~B9; COMMI93IOI~BR3: DuBois, Mauerhan, Gauer.
p83BNT; CCIMMISSIONBR3: Allred.
PUBLIC HBARING. PBTITION submitted by blR. 3~S MQtRIS AND :.~tS. ANNA L.
MOitRIS, 2528 Wallace Avenue, Pullerton~ California, as Qwuers, requesting
that the property described as being 220 ft. east from the southeast
corner of Brookhurat and Orange and ruaning 115 ft. east aad 133 ft.
south and further described as being in tbe 2100 bloct oa Orange Ave.,
be reclassified from R-A, RBS~IDSNTIAL AQtICUL'RIRAT. to C-1, NBI(~ffiO~tHO~
COh9~ISRCIAL.
Mr. James Morris appeared before Lhe Cemmission and stated that he
would like to erect a building oa the subject pro~erty contaiaing six
profesaional offices as shown on the plot plan and elevation stetch
provided. There has been considerable publicity ia the paper that
directly back of this property a very large office bui2ding would be
erected in the near future by the Wells Bros., however this property is
not zoned for such a use. Several years ago a variance was graated for
the erection of a restaurant oa this property which never materialized.
Commiasioner Morris offered Resolution No. 1.53~ Series 1959-60 tnat the
Commisaion recommend to the City Council that the subject property be
rezoaed to C-1, I~IGHBORHOOD COM~IBRCIAL, subject Lo:
-3-
\
RHGtJLAR MHSTING.- CITY PIANNING.CObNlI3SION - JANUARY 18. 1960•- CONTINUHD:
RHCIA3SIPICRTI034~-- °°I: The filtng of Gl Deed Restrictions as standard by the City of
~NO."P=59=6'0'-70 Anaheim, approved by the City Attorney.
(Cp3VTINUHD)• 2: ''ltrat -the building be erected 3n accordance with the plot plan and
rende=3ng pr.esented.
°• 3:--Zhat th~re~be a dediration-to the City-o, Anaheim of 32 ft. 1;ron;
the cen4er line of Orange Aveane.
4. Prepare street improvement pl~ns and instail all improvements ia
•-~- -ac~ordance wi~h approved~statl3ard pians on file in the office of-
the City Hngineer.
• ~ 5. The psymeat of ~2•.U0 per ~fro:rt ~ft. ~for -street lighting purposes.
• ~ -~6,- -Thzt a 90~daq time limit be set for the accomplishmen} of the above
• conditions.
1Lis resolution was seconded by Commissioner 1~lauerht.n and carried.
The vote on the above resolution was as foliows:
~ AYH3: COMMISSIONHRS: DuBois, Gauer~ Hapgood, Marcoux, Mauerhan,
-•• Morris, Summers, Mupgall.
NOB3: COMMISSIONBRS: None.
pBSENT: COhMI33I~NBRS: Alired.
RBCIAS3iPICATION - PUBLIC.H'BARING. PHTITION submitted by JAMHS AND JACQUBL:t.~ MHSNARD,
N0. F-59-60-72 302 Bast Hroadway Street~ Anaheim, California, as Owners, requesting
that the property described as being on the south side o: Hroadwaq
between Philadeiphia and Olive Streets, and further described as 302
Bast Broadway, be reclassified from R-3,'MULTIPLB PAMILT RBSIDBNTIAL to
' C-1, NBIGHBORHOOD COMMSRCIAL.
Mr. Mesnard, 302 B. Hroadway appeared before the Commission and
stated that he desired to establi,sh a public accountant's office
in a portion of this residence wY~ich will be used as a resideace
and office bq himself. He further stated that there are other•
business offices already establiyhed in ~,the same block conaisting of
a beauty salon, real estate and 3asurance office, He ferther stated
that the property backs on a a11Gy anA there is ample xoom for parking.
No one appeared in opposition to the granting of this reclassificatioa.
1}1H HHARING WAS CIASED. '
Coiamissioner Summers offesed Resolution No. 154~ Series 19S9-6Q that the
Commissioa recommend to the City Council, that the suh3ect proper~,y be
reclassified to C-1, Ns7IQiB0RH00A CQMMBRCIAL, subject to:
l. The filing of C-1 Deed Restrictions as standard with the City of
Anahe~m approved by the City Attorney.
2, l~epair and replace sidewalks on Broadway and Philadeiphia Stsaet as
directied by !he Pubi~~ Works Department. I
3. The payment of $2.~0 per fro~t foot for stieet.ligbfiirg purpnsea on __'
. Philadelp~-ia Street.
4. 11iat a 90 day ti~ae itmit.be set for the accomplishment of the above
cpndib3.ons.
This resolutioa was seconded by Comm3~siouer Morris and carried.
The vote on the above resolutioa was as followse
AYHS:' COh1MISSION~tS: Hapgood, Marcoux, Mauerhan, Summers, M~.ngail.
NOS3: C:q~4~lI3SIONffitS: PuBois; Gauer, Morris.
AHSBNT: COMMISSIONBRS: Al.~.red.
TBNTATIVB MAP - A tentative map of tract qo. 3591.was presented to the Commission. This
OP TRACT trac# is located 53 ft. west of $siott Avenue and 302.94 ft, sa;ith of
N0. 3591 Orar.ge Ave. 1he subdivider is M. ~.. McGaughy, 2966 Lincoln Ave.,
Anaheim, California and contains 16 R-3 proposed lots.
Commissiomer Mauerhan moved that the teatative map of tract no. 3591 be
approved, subject to:
-4-
~' ~ . . ~
(YtgGQ7AFt MBBTING CITY PLANNING CONINIISSION - J~'NARY 18, 1960 - OONTINUBD:
•TSNTpTIVg MAp - 1. Reclassification.
- pg-Zgp~ °~ 2. Street ta be provided-northeriy from tract boundary to Hast West
~°Np: 3591 Sfis:eRt to a line with North South Street as shovcn by tentative tract
~•filed in the~City of Buena Park, pr.nding recordation of Buena Park
tract.( If this tract is not recorded by the time this tract is
started the street pattern wiil remain as shown.)
3. That pertinent plot and buiiding plans be submitted to the City
Council for review.
4. Reqyire that should this subdivision be developed as more than
one subdivision, each subdivision thereof shall be submitted in
tentative form fo~ approval.
5. That the approval of the Piood Control District be obtained.
This motion was seconded by Commissioner DuBois and carried. ~
Tgp~pp~ivg MA~ - A tentative map of tract no. 3439 was forwarded to the Commission by the ~
OF TRACT ~ Orange County Planning Commissi~n for recommendation and suggestions. i
N0:"3439 This tract is located st the°southwest corr_er of Rio Vista and South ~
Street. The subdivider is the Terra Casa Development Company, 800 l
Downeybrook St., La Habra, California. 1he tract contains 15.9 acres
with 65 R-1 lots. These lots will average 70 ft. frontage with from ;
7200 to 9660 sq. ft. with the majority at approximately 7200 sq.ft.
Although the property is in the county, one of the requirements would
be annexation to the City of Anaheim in order to obtain sewers and
water. P~rt~e~r, this area is outlined by the City of Anaheim and being ,
suitable hi.gher grade homes with 10,000 sq.ft, lots. i
Upon a motion by Commissioner Mauerhan, seconded by Commissioner Morris ~
and car~ied, it was voted that the Pianning Department forward to the ~
Orange County Planning Commission a map showing Anaheim's proposed lot ~
sizes i~ this area and that the present map of Tract No. 3439 be re- ~
commended to the Oran~e County Planning Commission for disapproval. ~
i
pgpNGg CpIINTy - A letter was received from the Orange County Street Naming i;ommittee ±
SIRBST NAMING that in accordance with the recommended Master Plan of Street Names for ,
~q,q,~i~gg Arterial Highways of Arange County '~hat the Commission take formal -
action to recommend to the City Council that the name of Carson Avenue
be used for State Highwa.y :3. This highway is presently named Lincoln
Avenue, Center Street,.anaheim-Olive ltoad and Santiago Boulevard depend-
in~ upon what juri6diction passes thrbugh. This highway also bears the
name of Carson in Los Angeles County and is a direct continuation
of that route to Orange County.
ORANGE COUNTY USB
VARIANCH N0. 4459
After considerable discussion by the Commission, a motion was made by
Coromissioner Mauerhan, seconded by Commissioner Marcoux and carried that
the name Lincoln Avenue be changed from the Anaheim City limits on the
west to the present junction of Center Street and Lincoln Ave, at
WeSt Street in Anaheim. That Center Street remain as Center Street
and that at the Sast end whexe Center Stseet and Anaheim-Olive Road
come together that Anaheim-Olive Road be changed to Carson Avenue to the
east city limits of Anaheim.
Use Variance No. 4459 was forwarded to the Commission by the Orange
County Planning Commission. This relates to the proposal to erect
a Veterinary Hospital on the north side of Lincoln, approximately
1250 feet east of Gilbert Street. At the time of consideration no
buiiding or plot plan was available by the Commission and it appeared
that the building to be erected on the property wouid back up to a
single family residential tract not be compatible inasmuch as we recently
t~xned one down in another commercial zone i^ the city where protests
were received from the commercial property owm~:rs on either side of the
property under consideration.
Upon a motion by Commissioner Mungal~., seconded by Commissioner Summers
and carried, it was moved that the Commis~ion recommend to the Orange
Copnty Placming Commission that Use Variaxlce No. 4459 be disapproved.
-5-
~.
v
U
,~
_ _ . _ _. .
_ ~
RHGUTAR MHBTING -.CITY_.P7~TNING COkldISSION - JANUARY 18, 1960 - CONTINUHD:
_ ~t,
~
~
~
'~QtANGB CWN1Y U3BY"-3ince the meeting a bir3Sding and plot plaa was rec~ived aud•in view
" VARIANCB°NQ:~4'4S9"'-of 'the ~iocati~n of the' building w~th parktng fietween the buil~ding and
~"~~CC~TINUBD~"' '" the siag2e~family residea~es at the rear, some of the objett~ons might ~
~ ~''be~e2iminated:''Therefore;-if ~ttse Orange Connty Planning Commission-would ;
~` ~ tare- ta~ tsoid'~th3s over uatil~~the -next meeting of the •Anaheim Planning i
°•. - Co~ission on Pebruax~y 1, 1960, the Secretary will again present the use ~
~ variance.
ADJOURNIl~NT: 1Y~e meetii~g ad3ourned at 4:15 0'Clock P.M. ,
Respectfu submitted,
i
. i
I
. . MUNGALL Secretary
-6-