PC 84-128'"\
RLSOLU`i':ION N0. ~C84-J.2(3
A KESULU`l'I~JIJ UE '.PHk~ ANAHGTM CT.'Y PLANN:IN~ COMMISSION
TfiA`l' PLTITTON I~OTt VARIAN~E NG. 3408 ElL b~N.IEU
IaHPkEn;, t.h~ Anahei.in Cil:y i~l.anni.ng Cc~mmi.sSion did r~cei.ve a verifi.ed
PEti.ti~ii For Var, iance 1 rom ~JUN NISE~iINU, D. D. S. AND MARCIA .1. NISElINO, 1.780
NoCth Win.lock, Orangc, Ca].ifor.nia 9'L665, owner.s, ~nd P. Fl. I. UEVELOPMENT
CQR~ORATIUN, 2UJ.0 "C" South FasL-wood, S~nt.a An~a, Cal.ifor.nia 92705, agent .Eor.
cerkain t~~l proper.L•y siL•uated in the Cit;y of Anahci.m, Count,y u£ Ozange, 5take
of Cal.ifornia descr.•ibt:d as:
PARCEL 1;
'1'klOSG POI?TIU~1S O[' LI~T 1 OF MRS. $U5H'S SU[3DIVISION U[' A POI~'.i'ION
OF TfiE BUSH TRACT, AS PGFt MAP RECOItDLD TN BpOK 36, PAGF 52 OT'
MTS~ELLANI;OU5 RECORDS IN ~i'fiE OFI'ICE OE TH~: COUNTY RFCORPER OF LOS
A~GELES CUUN`rY, CALIE'~RNIA, OE 'THE iYIRD CLASS LANll AI~LOT.'1'ED TO
Y. Y. DE CO`PA ACCORDING TU A MAP i1T'rA~~HE;ll 'PO ANn IdADG h PA~T OI'
`.CHE DECREE OF PARZ'I'" TQN OL' 'rHE RANCFiO CANON L'E SANTA ANA RENDERED
IN C?1SE N0. 197~ OF iEiE 1.77'H JUDICIAL DISTRICT COURT OF
CRLIEORNIA, A CERT.IFIGD COPX OF WHTCH IS RECGRDED I~1 BOOK 28,
PAGE ].5$ OF UEEnS J:N '.~"r1E OL'I'ICG Oh SAID rpUNTY RECORD~R AND OF
'1'Hk: 'LANA ALLUT'i'ED 'i'O MARIA P~RALZ'A UE ALVp~ZEZ IN DF;CREE OF
PAI~TITION OE THE RANCHO SANTIAGO DE SAP~TA AP]A, RECORUFA IN BOOK B
OF J~JUGML•'NTS OE' SATD i.7TH ,IUDTCIAL DISTRICT COUHT, DLSCRIBEA T1S
FOi~LOWS :
E~EGINNING A'1 AN "X" IN `.I'HE PAVL•'MEN'1 [~1ARKJ[VG 'rHE INTEKS~CTION OG'
'1:HE CEtaTERLINE pE' TtlE SANTA ANA CAN'LON RUAD AS SURVEYED IN .1926
BY 'rHE COUNTY OE' ORANG;E WITH `rHE SUUiEIERLY EXTENSION OF.' THL•' EAST
LtNE Oh' SAIA LOT ]. UF MRS. 13USH'S SUBDIVISION~ ,SAID POI[~1T BF:ItdG
~O.OU FEF'T NORTHGRLY 1:"ROM THE NORZ'HWEST CORNER OF L~J`1' l. OF 7'RACT
NG. 936, AS 9HOWN ON A MAP FtECORDED IN E300K 30, PAGES ]. ANU 2 OF
MISCELLANGOUS [r:APS, Rk.CURllS OE' ORANGE CQUN'Z'Y, CAi.II'OFtNIA; TE{ENCE
NOR'1'H 0° J.2` 3U" WE.~'iT A~,UNG SAiD EXTENDED LIIJE :,ND RLQNG T[•lE
EAS`i'EI2LY LINE Ult SAID LQT 1 UF' MRS. E3USH'S SUBDIVISSON A~~D THL•'
NOFtTHERLY ~X:CCNSIQN THERCOE 1~51.74 EE~T, MORF: OR LES5, TQ TEIE
SUU'I'H~AS'P CORNER OF 'PHE I,AND L'ESCRIT~ED IN THE DEEU TO ORANGF
COU'NTX WA~'ER DJ~T22ICT, RE(:OFtDED AUGUST 29, 19h0 IN BOOK .1059,
PAGE J.93 QI' OFF'ZCIAL R~CORDS, S?11D POI~!'.C BEING 28.5-4 FEE'r NORTH
0° J.'l' 3U" W~:ST FRGM THE NORTHEAST CORNER OE' SAIG I,OT ]. OF MRS.
BUSH'S SUBUIVISION; 'r[:FNCE NORTH 8].° 92' 05" WES'.i J.8G.55 ~EET
ALUNG THE; ~OU't'HE:RLY L1NE OF TH~ LANJ DF:CRIBL•'D IN SAID DEED;
THGNC:F. NOFt1'[{ Fi4° 29' 5S" WES'I' 233.'l5 ~J~ET nz,or~c THE SOUTHERLY
LINE OF TH~ .(.,:1ND DFSCRIa~;U IN ~A'LD UGL•'D, SAID POINT BEIt+G ."'.3.50
FEG~' NOK'PH 0° 7.5' 3U"WES'r FROM 'rHE NOR'SEiWEST COEZNEK Ok SAIJ LUT ).
OL' MRS. f3USH'S S[3E'DIVT.SION; 'rHi:NCE SUUTH U° 3.5" 30' i:A5T ].322.~1
FE~T ALONG '.CIiE NOR2'tiEftLY EX'PL•:N;;ION OF' THL•' WESTERLY LINE OC SAID
':~U~' l. 0'r~ MAS. BUS:i' S ~UE3~IVISIUN AND ALUNG 'THE WE~TERL~' GZNE AND
TH~' SOU7'HERLY f:X'.:ENSION THEREOC' 'PO 'I'HE CF.lJTE;RLIN~, OE SAlD SAN`PA
ANA CAt3YUN f20AD; `I'H~NCE NOI2TH 87° U1.' UO" F.AS'P 415.46 PE.::`I' TO THE
PUINT OE BEGINNING.
~0255r
PC84-328
:, ~
EXCEF''i' '1'I-lA'r POI~`i':f.UN LYING NGIt'.CH Uf~' THL SUUTH I.,:CNC OF THE MATN
CANAL nl `i'[~F' SAN`.CA ANA VAI~t,GY TRRIGATIQN COMI~ADIY.
X1GSU EXCEf~`i' '1'E1F~ PU.RTIUN CONVEXLU TO ~iAN7.'A ANA VAL,L~Y :[I2RIGr,`1'ION
COMPANY KY ~Lk,D FtLCOkDEll JULY 18, ].934 IN f3UUK 685, PAGE 255 UF
Ol'E'ICIAL ftECORDS.
ALSU F'XCF'P'i' `1'HAT PUR'I'IUN OF SAIq ~,ANI) CONVGYED TO THE STATr (~F
CALZFOFtNIA SY 1~E;ED ItECOIIDGU MARCH 2~ ].948 IN BOOK ].73J.o nAGE 5J.7
UP' OG'1.TCIAL Rf:;CUE2US.
NQTL•'. PART OF SAIll LANll IS W:I`i'HIN TRAC'I' NO„ 4958, AS P~R MAP
RECORllEU IN BOUK ZOB, PAGF 4$ OF M?SCE~LLANEUUS MAPS, IN THI~
OI'FI(:F ~~E' THE c:UUN`PY i2.ECORDLR C~I' SATp ORANG~ CUUN'i'Y.
PA~tCEL 2:
THAT POR`.PION OF 't'Elk~ LANA ALLO`.CT~D TU THE HLTRS OE' DOMINGUEZ IN
AECRLL UF' PARTITION UF THE kANCI•i0 SANTIAGO DE S~N7.'A ANA, R.ECO~tUED
IN BOOK "B" UF JUDUMENTS Ok' THE l.7TH JUDTCTAL DISTRZCT COURT OF
CALIFORNI~~~ DESCRIBED AS i~'OLLOWS:
BFGTNNINC AT '.i'Hk~ TNTGRSEC2'ION OF THE NORTEIERL~Y PROLONGAT'!UN OE'
'i'HF; WESi LING OE LOT l. O.F 1'RAC'T NO. 936, AS P~F MAP RECORDED TN
bUOK 30, PAGF J. OF hiISCELLANI:OUS MAPS, IN '.I'HE OFf• ICE 01~ 'Y'HE
COUNTY RECORllE?. OF uA:.~ CCUN'rX, WITH THG CEN`.PER LINE pF SA@ITA A~.~
CAIJYUCV ROAD AS SfiOWN UN SAIll MAP; TIiENCE f~ORTH a7° 07.' 00" WEST,
].17U.dEi FFE`x; 'PH~NCE SOUTH 85° 5~' 35" WE3T~ 650.52 E'EET; THENCF
NOR7'H 82° 47' 30" WEST, 599.1.0 CEFT TO TEiE WEST ~.INE OI' SA1D
AI~LO'CMENT; THFNCE SOUTH}sRLY J.284. a0 EGE'C AL,ONG SAID WEST I.,1NE 7'U
THE POIN'P OF B~;G:iNNING.
EXCE;PT '!'HAT PORTION THEREOC CQNVEYED TO THE SANTA ANA VALLEY
IftRiGATION COMFANY k3Y UFBD RECORDED JULY 19. ].934 IN B~OK 6$5,
PAGE 255 0~ OFFiCIAL RECORDS.
ALSO EXCEP~i' THAT NORTION ~~HERGOF INCLUDED WI~.rHIN THE E30UNDARTES
OF THE LAND CONVEYE' TO OR~NGE COUNTY WATH;R UISTRI~~T 6Y AEED
RECORDED QCTOBER 29, .L938 IN f300K 951., YAGE 579 OI' ~FFICIAL
KECURDS.
ALSO EXCEL ~ Z'HI~T l~OR'!'ION THEREUF DESCRI SGD AS FOLLOWS :
IIEGINNING A'P 'I'HE 1N'I'ERSECTION OF '.CHE NORTH~RLY PRULONGATTUDI Oc
TIiE EASTEFt1',Y T,INE: OF SAID LOT ]. WITH ~AID rENTER LIN~'.; 2'HENCE
50UTH 87° 16' 00" WEST, 4~6.10 FE~T ALONG SAJD CENTER L'II~IE TO THG
NQRTfiEEtJ.,Y PFOLONC~ATIG'N Uft THG WI;STERLY L1NE OF' SAID .LOZ' 1.; TEfGNCE
NORTH 0° 02' OU" WFS'i', 44..13 FEL•'T AL7I~G SAID PROLUNGAZ'ION; Z'HENCI;
NGRTH 87° 39' 3~" EA:.;T 'PO TkiL SOUTt1ERLY LINE Of 'rHE LAI3U
UESCRIBED IN THG DH'i:U `1'0 '1'ti~ SAN'I'r. ANA ~~ALL~Y IftFIGATION COMPANY,
RGCORDED .T.N E30UK 68`~~ PAGE 255, OFE'ICZAL RECORUS; 'I'NL['1CG EASTERL~
ALUNG SAID SOU`PHEkLY LING UN A C~,iRVE C:ONCAVE i7pR'PE{EE2LY, HAVING A
RADtUS OE 355. UU f'EE'P TO Tl~E NUI2Tl~ERL7 PROLONGATtON UF THE
E:ASTERLY LINE OF SAID I,uT 1; THENCE SOU2'EIERLI AL,ONG SAID EAST~RLY
LINE `r0 THE pOIN~ OF ::is'GINNING.
AL~U :,XCEPT 'i'HA'i' P~~RTIUN LY~t~~:, tdUR'rf~ OF '!'EiE SOUTH LINE O.E THE
MAIN CAC~AL OF :HE SANTA ANA VALLEY II'RIG:~TION COMPANY.
-'l- PC64-' 48
~
PAItC1;L 3:
~
ALL TEIA'1' CEI2`1'A:LN kEAI.~ PRQ1'GPTY LYItdG WI'.CHIN TEIE I~ANll ALLOTTFll TO
`I'EiFs HEIRS ~JE UOM:[NGUGZ ANll ';p '['HL, E~IGRS OE LFAND120 SERRANO IN ~'HE
DECREE UF Y[1RTI'1'ION OF ~.1'E!~ RAN(:HO .;.'1N'i'IAGO DG SANT;A f1NA RFC:ORDGD
IN f30GK "B" Pr..;E 4].U OF JUllGM~NTS QP 'CEIr llIS2'RICT COURT OF THL
:~ /TH ~7UAICIAL llISTRICT TN A~IU b'OR L(); ANGGI.,ES COUNTY, CALT~'ORNIt•.,
AND In'T`i'HIN LUT J. OF MHS. CiIJSH'S SUF31?IVISION OF A POkt'i'ION Ub' TNF,
BUSH TRAC'i' L~EK THE MAP IiGCOFtUED IN f~00K 36, PAGE 52 OF
MISCELLANEC~US RECQftDS OF SAID T~OS ANGf3LES ~UUN'!'Y, Sf{OWN AS
"S.A.V.I~ CANAL", 46.00 ~EET TN WIDTH, ON TF:IE MAP UI~ '.P12ACT N0.
~1958 Rk;CORllED IN BUOK 208, PAG,?~S 4G, ~9 AND "a0 C)P' NI; SCEI.LANEOUS
INA~'S, RECqRD~S OL' SAID Of2AtJCE; COUN'CY~
EXCEI~'!'ING `i'Hk;~tk~FFOt+( AN't POR`i'IUN OF SAID L~AND LYING rASTEF2LY OF
`.CHr SOUTHLRLY PROLONGATION UP TElb~ FAS'1'ERLY LINL OE~ L~OT ].3 OF SAID
TRACT NO. 495a AND LYTNG WESTERLY Ot' THE EAS'i'F'RLY I,ING Ul' PINNEY
llRIVE, 64.OU FEET IN WIDZ'H, AS SHOWN ON Sf1ID MAP.
WHEREAS, thP City P].anning Comir.ission did ho7.d a public hear.ing ~t
the Civic Centec in t.he City of Anat~eim on June 25, 1.9p4, at .1:30 p.m., notice
of sa9.d pub.lic hearing havi,ng been dul.y given as required by l.aw and fn
accozdance tiiith the provisions of th~ Anahe.im Munic:ipal Code~ Chapter .18.03~
to hear and consic~er evi.dence for ancl against sai;7 proposEd variance and to
i.nvestigate and make ~indings and recommend~~ttons in c:onnection therewith; ~~nd
4Jf~~REAa, sai.d Cornmissa.on, aiter. du~ inspPC;tior,, inv~stigai:i.on and
study madP by i.ts~_l.E an~ in its behal.f, and after due considzr.ation Uf a].1
~~~~idetlce and re}~orts off•erec! at said hearing, doES f ind and deter.min? the
f:oJ.J.ow.ing fac.ts:
J.. That the petit~,oner pr.opoaes a wai.~~er. °o.f the fo].l.qwing to
construct a 35~foot l~igh, 2-story commerc.ial. uffice bui.ldi.ng:
SECTION 18.84.04'l.OJ.I. ~- t~-in~irnum ].andsca~eca building setback.
~ ( 100 fee~ re~~uired f r.om a sceni,~ h ighway;
20 Eeet propns~d)
2. That the above-ment~oned wa:ivec ia her..eby deni.ed on the basi.s
that ther.e are no spec:ial cir.cumstances appl.icabl.e to the ~~r.uperty ;;uch as
size, shape, t~poyr.aphy, .location or. surruur.d:ings, which do not app3_y to other
identi.calJ.y zoned prope.~L•ies in the vicin.it;~; and that: strict app].ication oE
the Z~n.ing Cade does nol depr.i.ve the proper.•t;y oL• prYVi.].eg~s enjayed hy athez
pr.oper.ties in identica.l zonin~ ct.assification in the v.icinily; anc that
Rec.lassificat~ion No. 83-84-34, to rexone subject pr.opert;~ CO (Commer.c.ia).,
OfL•i.ce) , was proposed i.n conjunct ~.on wxth thi.~ var. iance ar~d wa3 den ied.
3. That ther.F are no exce~tior~a.l or.. extr.aor.d~.nar,y cir.cum~tan~es or
conc;i.tior-s app].icable to tt~~ nroper.ty ir~vol.ved or t~~ th~ ineencled use o£ the
proper.ty thak dc not appl.y ge~er.a_lly to thc property ~r. cl.asa oE use tn ':hP
~ame vicinity and zone.
4. ~i'h~t tt~e r.equeste~.] varianc:e i.:; not ri~c~ssar.y for. the
pre:.~rvation arid enjoyment oI a substantial. pea~:~r.tX ri.ght po~sessed by other.
proper,ty i.n the ~ame vi.cinity and zone, ar.d denied r.o tF.e pr.opErty i.n qaest~~n.
-3- P~ :;-.128
,-~--..
~
t
{
i
f
,
~
~..,.. ....
5. 7'hat the rc~c7uesLed var.ir~nce wi].]. b~ mat~r.•i.a].].y d~tr.i.mnr.taJ. to
tY~e puU7.ic we7.far.e or injur.tc~us ^o the proper.ty or. impr.ovements ~in such
vic:lnity and zone .in which the pr,operty i.s l.ocated.
G. That 34 ~er.;;ons indicatPd ~hei.r presence at said pub7.ic hear.ing
a.n ~ppusition; and thak a p~t~.i~i.on r_ontaini.ng approxir~iately 7.C9 s~.gn~tur.es was
rP~eiv~d in op~osition to suuject pctition.
ENVTItONMEN`1'AL IMPACT L INDING: 'l~hat thc~ Anahei.m Cii:y nl.anning
Commission 'sias r.evieweci the proposal. t:o rec].~ss~ify subjec~ pro~erty £r.om the
Ru•-A-43,000(SC) (Resident.ial./Agricu;.tura]., Scen.ic Cor.~:idor. Over7.ay) Zone ~o
the CO(uC) (Commerci~l., OLiice and Pr.otessional., Scenic Coreidor Over].ay) 2one
f:o con:,truct a 35-foot t-.igh, 2-story commer.ci.il. of.L•ice bui.iding wi.th a waiver
aF m9.nimum J.andsca~e~ buil.d:ing setback on an ir.r.~guJ.arl.y-shaped parce]. of l~nd
COC18:lating of. apProx.imately ~.8 acr.es loc~ted at the nor.thea~t corner, of Santa
~~na Canyocl Road and Pinney Dr.i.ve; aitd doES her.ebl approve thc Ne~at:ive
Dec~aration upon findin~ t~hut i.t h~;s considered the Negati.ve Dec].ar.aki..on
together with any comment~ r.eceived durin4 thE ~~ubl.~i.c rl?V7.PW process and
further finding on tt,e b~si.s ot the i~.itia7. study and any c~mments r.eceived
that the~e is no ~ubstantia7. ev:iden~e that che project will. ha~~a a signtficanl-
eFfect ori the Envi.ronment.
NOW, TH~;Ftf:FORL, E3E IT KESOLVEU that the Anaheim Gity P].anni.ng
Commiss~.on does h~reby deny subject Petil-.ion for Variance on th~ basis of the
afor.ementioned findings.
THE FORGGOING RESULUTION is signed and appzoved by me this 25th day
af June, 1-9840
i' /~
~
'' l~ L'~'- . ,t~ ~~~..'~-~"._-~z.--,_
CHAIRWO AN, /A/I~~HEIM CITY PLANNING COMMISSION
AlTES2': ~ !/
~ ~~~~ ~`~__!~~1•`°
SECFiE:TAEtY, ANAHEIM CITY' PLANNING COMMISSION
S'CAT.F: (`F CALIFO~tNIA )
COUNZ'Y OF ORANGE ) ;s.
CITY UN ANAHEIM )
I, Edith L. Har.ris, Secr.etary oF the Anah~im C~.ty P1aniling
Commissi.on, do h~reby certify that the tor.eqc~i.r,,y resol.ution was passed and
adopted at a m~:eti.ng of the Anaheim CiLy Pl.anni.ng Commiss~.on held ~n June 25,
1989, by tihe £oJ.l.owing vute of the member.s ther~of:
AYES: COMMIiSIUNGP,S: B(?UAS, BUSHORG, PRY, HERBST~ KiNG, LA CLAIRF.
MC BURtvEY
NOES: (:QMMZSSIONER~: NONE
ABSENT: COMMISSIONCRS: NONL•'
IN WIZ'NESS ~~HERGOF, I have h~reunto ser my h~~nd this 25th day of
June, 19f34.
l~ . ~ i~~~
SGCRE'PAItY, ANAEiEIM CITY PLANIJ2NG CGM~4ISSIUN
-4-
PC84-1.28