Resolution-PC 89-110. ._ ,.. . . ~'~',3~;. "' ~ ';.~ ~ ~ . . . < < i i
~t.-,,'h
~
RE~o~4~.~~ P~ _~i.~
1e RLSOLUTION ~F TH~ 1-.NAH~IM CJTY PLANNI~IG COMMISSIO~i
THA'~ PETTxTO~I F~P CONDTTIONAL USE PEFtMI'C N0. ~146 HE GRANTED, IN PART
WI3Ek2EAS, the Anaheim City Planning Commis~ion did receivca a
ver.i.f.i.eci Petition for Conciitiona]. Use Permit f.rom xRINITY I,U'rHERAN CHURCH,
4101 E. Nuhl Ranch R~ad, Anaheim, CA 92A07, owner, and GOODMAN CHURCFi
BUTLAERS, 3535 W, CommoiiwQalth Avenue, StQ. 2Q9, Fullerton, CA 92633, agent
for cartain renl property situated in tkze :,ity o£ A~aheim, Cour.cy of Orange,
State oF Califoi•nia, described as:
THAT NORTION OF TIi~ LAND ALLOTTEll TO THE HEIRS OF
LEANDRO SERRANO, IN SECTTON 9, TOWNSHIP 4 SOUTH,
R1~IGE 9 WEST, IN THF CI'PY OF ANAHEIM, COUNTY OF
ORANGE,. S'rATE AF CALIFORNIA, AS SHOWN ON TH~ MAQ OI'
PARTITION OP' THE FAI3CFI0 SANT7AG0 UE SANTA ANA,
RECORDED IN JQOK "B" OF JUDGMEN'tS OF TT~E ~7th
JUDiCIAI~ llISTRICT COURT UF CALIF6RNIA, DESCRIB~D AS
FOLLOWS:
BEGINNING AT THE SOUTHERLY TERMII~US OF THAT CERTAIN
COiJRS~ IN THE EASTERLY F30iJNDAFY OF TRACT NO • 54' 99, AS
SHUWN ON A MAP RE(;ORD~D 7N BOOK 2U1 PAGES 46 ANA 47
OF bfISCELLANFOUS MAPS, IN THE O~FICE OF THE CUUi1TY
RECORDER OF SAID pRANGE C0:1l7TY, SFIOWN TT3EREON AS
FIAVING A BEA~2INC OF NORTH 2 DEG. 25' 35" EAST AND A
~ENC~TH UF 2Q6.84 FEFT; T.HENCE ALONG SA7:D EASTERLX
aOUNDARY NORTH 2 DEG. 25' 35" FRST 206.84 .F~ET;
TFiENGE IdpRT:i 5 DEG. 37' 35" EAST 112.9A FEET TO THF
HEGINNII~G OF A T1~NGENT C[~RVE THEREYN SHOWN AS BEINC
GONCAVF TO THE WEST AND HAVING A RADTUS OF 309.88
FEET; THENCE NORTFIERLY A.LONG SAID CURVE 50 , t78 FEET, A
RADIAL TO SAID POINT BEEIRS NORTH 86 DEG. 22' 00"
~AST; THENCE NORTH 86 Dr~G. 22' 00" 167.62 FEET TO TFIE
BEGINNIt;G UF A TANGENT CURVE, CONCAV~ TU '~'HE NORTH
AND a3AVING A RA,DTUS A 300.00 FEET° THENCG EASTERLY
ALONG S:~IV CURVF 113.62 FE~T; THENCE TANGENT TO SAID
CURVF NpRTIi 64 DEG. 4p' 00" EAST 9~.37 FEET; TH~:NCE
SOUTH 25 Di:C. 20' 00" EASt 26.00 FEET; 'SFIENCE SGUTFI
2G ~,RG. 3~J' 00" F.AST 140.00 F~E'P; THENC~ SOUTFI 50
DEG. 50' 12" EAST 150.60 FEET; TIiENCE SQUTH 27 DEG.
30' 00" WEST 123.00 FE~T; THLNCE SOi7TH 1. DF.G. 29' 24'
WFST 97 . Ct7 FEET TO TFIE IN'~ERSECTION WI7.'H A LTNE
FiAVING A BEARINr, OF Sai;TH 88 DEG. 3~J' 36" EAST ANU
WF3ICH PASSE~ THRO'UGff THE POIrTT OF BEGIN2vING; THENCE
;lORTH 88 AF.G. 30' 36" W.~S:'' 51J.00 FEET TO THE FO=NT
dF BEGtNNING.
~~
083Gr -1- PCt39-110
.~
~
^
~
, y,~ , ~7,~
-~;i~ ~+> 1~
~~:r
WAEREAS, the City P?aniiing Ccmm~ssian did hold a puhlic hNar3ng nt
the Civic Canter in the City af Anaheim on Apr.il 10, 1989, at 1:30 p,.m.,
notico of said public hearing having been duly gican as requirod bX l~ r and in
accorclance with t.he provasions of r,he Anaheim Municipal Code, Chaptez 18.03,
to hear and consicier evidence for and agains~t said proposed condition~l use
permit and to izzve~tigato and make f'indings and recommendations in connection
thorewi~h; and said public hearing wa~s continued to th~ meeting of ~pril 24,
1489; and
WHEREAS~ said C~mmission, aEter due i.nspectio~i, investigation and
~tudy rr~ade by it;sel£ and in its behalF, ar~d aEt~r due ~onsiderati~n uf aZl
evidence and report.s affered at said hea.rinn, doos find ana determint. the
£ollowing• facts:
7.. Z'hat i:ha peti.Lioner reguests approval of a Conditianal Use
Yermit unaer ~ut.i~ority of Code Section 1a.29.050.030 to perma,t a 9, g2a sq. f.t,
a3dition to ~~n existing church f~ci~.ik,~ with waiver of the following;
(A) SE~TIONS 18.Q6.050.0266 - Mini_ mum numb~r Q~arking snacg~.
1$ . 06.. ~$Q ("~41 required; 21 pr~posed )
anci 18.34.O~f~i~~10
~~? S~CT~N 1~~A~4?.011 - M~xi~m ~truvtural. heigh~.
~?~`r_~~@~ per:nitted; 3~fs~ pro~,~osed)
2. That the r~quested w~iver (a) is hereby grantod on the~ basis
~hal•. the ~~nrking waiver w~i11 not cause an increase in traffS.c ccnges~ion in
the immediate vic.inity nor ac]ver.sely affect any adjo.ini.ng land uses and
granting of ~he parking waiver under the condition;, imposed, if any, wi11 not
~~e detz•imenta7. to the poar_~, hpa'.th, safety and genaral wQlf~re of tha
cxt;i.zens of the City oE Anz.heim.
3. That the requeste~i waiver (b) is hereby grauted, in Parc, to
pPrm~t a ma.ximum structural height ~f thirty {30) feet for the .propoaed
sanctuary building on tha basis thaL- there are special circums~~nces
applicable ta the property sucti ~s size, shnpe, topography, location and
surrounoings which do not anply to othsr. identical.ly zoned ~roperty in the
sam~ vicinity; and that strict app7.iGation of the Zoning Cc-de dQprives the
property oI privilagos enjoyed by ather properti.QS in th~ identical zone and
cl~sszfication in the ~~icinity.
4. That t2ie proposed use ~a.i11 not adver;~ely affect the ~djoining
land uses and the growth and developmHnt o~ the dr.Qa in wlnich it is p.roposed
to be located.
5. That the size ~nd shape of thc si~:e proposed for thA use is
aiequate to ailow the full dc~velonmc~n~ of the, proposed u3e in a manner not
cletrimental to the particu.lar area nor to ~lie peace, health, saFety, ancl
general welfure of the t:xtiaens c~ the City oY Anaheam.
6. xhat the proposed use, a5 granted, will not adversely bfEect ~he
adjoining land uses at~d t2ie growth and development o~: t:ne area in whach it is
proposRd to be located.
^
-2- PCi.9-1J.d
~
~
7. ThaL• thQ s::ze t~na S11R~0 0~ the aite proposod for the uoe, as
granted, 3.~ ~dequate ta allow tlhe tull develupment o£ tho proposed use in a
manner not detrime,ital to the particulAr r~•rea n~r tn tt~e peace, health, s~aYQt;~
and <7er:eral wolEare of tk~e Citizens of tho City of Anaheim,
A. ThAt th~3 grant.ng of the Conditional tlso Per.mit •uncier Lhe
conditions imposod, if any, rrill nor be detrimental to ~:he p~aca, bealth,
safaty and qeneral weliar.e of tha Cil•,izens of the l:i~y of Anaheim.
9. That three (3) peopl,r i.nd3cated th~i.r presence at 3Kid public
hearing i.n opposition= and th~t no correspondence was recoived in oppQSition
to the subject petition.
~AT~IFQR~I~~NV~RQ.~IJT IA, QU~L~~~t~~T F~t~~tTG: That the Anaheim City
Plnnning Commission has rev3.ewed thg proposal to permit a 9,925 ~4q. rt.
ac?dition to an exi~ting church f.t~cili~y w.ith waivers of minimum numbsr of
parkinqs spaces and ~naximum structural height on a frregularly-s~aped parcc~~
of land cons.istinq of approximahcly 9 acres .locaked at the aortheast corner of
Nohl Ranch Road and Nohl Canyon R~JF,ICl, and further doscribed as 4104 Eaot Nahl
Ranch ktuad (Trinfty Lutherar. Church); and ~?.oes hereby approve th~ Negativ~
Declaration upon finding l•hat it has considered thQ Nagativq Declaration
toqether with any comnents received during tli~ public review procass and
furrher finding on the basi3 of L•:-e initial stur~y and any comments racoived
that tharQ is no substantial evidQnce tha~ thQ project will have a signrficant
offect on tkle environinocit.
t70W, '1HEREFO[tE, BE iT RESOL.'VEU that the Anaheir.e Cit,y Planning
Co~Y-mission 3oes hersby gran.: ~abje~t Petition fur Condit.i~na1 t)se P~rmit, upon
the £ollowing conditions which are horeby found ko bo a necessary prerequ:tsite
to the propored use of the subject p:operty fn order ~to pr.erequisitQ ~o the
proposo3 uae of the subject proporty in order ko preserve the safety and
general welfare of the Citizen~ af Lhe City of Anahe.rr:
x. Thar a parkinq ~ian showinq compl.iance with Cil~ parkin~ ).ot design
stan3ards stiall be subn-itted Cu and approved by tho C.ity Tra.f~ic
Enqinoer. Said plan shall eliminat~ any small c:ar parl.ing spa~es located
on oiti~er side of any clriviny aislo.
Z. That rrior ta issuanr.e of a buil.c~fng pQrmit, trie ~ppropriato tr~ffic
signal t~ssc~ssment fee ~hall bn paid to Lhe C3L•y of Ai~ahefm .ir. an amount
as esr.abiished by City Cou»cil resalur,ion.
3. That f3.r~ qprinklers shall be .ins.:alle~' as requirUd by the City Fire
Departmont.
4. Th~t Fire Jepartrr.enC :.CC@38 a»d ovacuation routos to all on-site
structur~s shall hd reviowed and approved by trie City Fire Departmenr.
This shal; inclucle a twenky (2U) fcc~t NidP unobstructed access wtsy f:om
tho education buildings r,~ a public street right-of-way.
5. T~iat the total maximum onrollanent fur the on-site school facility siiall
not oxceed ~w~ hundred fiEtean (215) studonta, a~ specifiecl by
Con(!itianal Uae Perrr.it No. 2615.
-3-
FC89-110
~1
~r~~ ~~
6. That unle:~s proof of oxemption is ~ubmittod in compliance with City
Council Rosuluti~n No. 85R-423, prior tio isauar~ce oF a building pRrmit,
th~ appropriate major. thoroughfaro and bxidgc~ fee ~sht+ll ~~e paid to thc~
City oE Anaheim in an amount ~s spgcified in Lho Major Thoroughfare t~nd
Bridge Fee Program for the ~anL•hi'l1/Ea~tern Transportation Corridor, as
approved by City Council Rosolution No. 85R-A23.
7. Tiiat gates shall not be installod acrass the driv~way in a mannar which
may adversely aFfect vehiculF+r traffic in tha adjacen~ public street.
InstallRtion of any gates shall ronform ~o the ~ngineering D~partment's
Stan,dard P1An No. 4U2 and shall be subject to the review an~ approval of
ttie City T.raffic Enc,~ineer.
8. T23at in tha event a parking de.ficioricy or.cu.r~ follo~!ing occupancy of the
subject addition (said deficiency having been demonstrate3 in a parking
clomand at~.~dy to be funded by the ~~roporty owner/develo~er at ~tie requa~t
of the City Tr~f_ic Rnginec~r an~3 to be rc~vfewed and a~provod by the City
Traffic Enginec~r), additi~nal on-~itg parking (noC ~o exceed an
add.itional one hiindred thirlx or~e [131] spaces for a total at three
hundred fort,y one [341 spaces]) shal]. be provi3^d in a manr~~r approved by
the CIt~ Traffic Engineert and that a cov6nant shall be recorded in a
form approvad by the City Attor.ney's Uffice oblfgatinq the petitioner and
any future assignees to provide such parking if a c~eficiency is fou:,d to
exi9t. Said coveriant s}iall be recorded with the Of£a.ce of tho Oranqe
County Recnrder. ~ copy of rhe recorded covonant shall be aubmfthod to
the Zoninq Division.
9. Thnr the new construction authorizou by thia resolution shall be served
by underqround utilitiec.
10. 'Phat all lor.kab.lR pddestriar. and vehicular access gatos ahal.l be eauipped
wi~h a"knox box" device, if• rr.quireci by the Flre and/~r Po11ce
Departmants and to tk-e satisfactien of said clapartn-ents .
11. Tha~ trash storage ai•~as rthall bo pravidnd and maintazned in a 7location
acceptable to the ~treet Maiutenance ~nd Sanirat~on Division ancl in
accardancu with approved plans on file wi.th s~id Division.
12. That all air condikic,r=r~a facilities an~ other ground moun~ed aquipment
shal]. be prc,~~erly shi.elded from view, and the sound buffored from
adjact.~:: res~c;enri3l properties.
13. ThaY. tbe proposal sh~-11 comply with all signi.nq xequirements of the
R5-HS-10,000 (SC) "R~sidential, Sing2e Family, Hi1).sic]e - Scenic Corridor
Over).ay" ZQne, unlea~ a varianc~ allowi_ig sign waivers Is nppraved by tha
City Council, Pla--ning Commission or Z7ninq Administrator.
1A. That any proposed pnrkiiig area lightin~ f.ixturea adjacent Co the Fibu~ting
residential propert3ea sha11 be eown-lighted with c- maxi.mum height o~
twelve (~2) feet. Said liqhting fixtures shall be d.irected away from tho
adjacent resi~ential property lines to pr.oteck the residenti.ai integrity
of the area.
15. That no rooE-mo~hLBd aquipmcsnt, whatsoever, shall be parmitte~l, as
~pecified in Anaheim Munici.~al Cor)Q S~ction 18.84.042.012.
_4_ ?C89-110
~ a +.r . ~~ ,
~ - , {~ , i . ~~~ - . .. ~~.~'il~ Y~ ~ ,'~Fl f i A ~ \~~: ~t ~ f r~ ~~
r,~ 3bT~a
~ ~ 74~~ ,
,r ,~~'~'~.~
':: r.
~~,~ `.~'
,
~ _
1G. That the on-c~i~e lands~api.ng shall be muinLr~fxied 3n aompli.ance with Ci.ty
standards.
17. Tk,at subject prop~.rty shall be d~ve2opecl substantially 3n accordanae with
plans ancl spacii~cations on f31a wi~h tha City of Anpheim markr~d of
Exhibit Nos. 1 through 4.
18. That prior to issuance of a bailc~ing permit or vrithin a perioQ of one (1)
~Qar from tho date of this xesolution, whichever oocurs first, Gondi~ion
t1os. 1, 2, 4, 6, 8 and J.2, ab~ve-mentioned, s~all be comp].ied w~th.
Extensians fur fur~liez timo to complete said c~nditions may bo grantod in
accordanco with Section 18.03.d90 of tho Anuheirn Munir,ipal Code,
'19. That prior to final bui.lding nnd aoning in~pections, Condition No~. 3, 9,
11, 1;:, Z4 and 17, above-mention~sd, shall be complied with.
~0. That approval of thib ap~ltcation constitutes approvaZ of the propos~d
request only to the extent.'that it comglies wit~i the Anaheim Mtinicipal
Zon.ing Code and ~ny other applicable City regi~lations. l~pproval does n~st
iu~~lude any action or findings as to comglianco or npprovctl of ttio
request regarding any other appli.cable or~.inance, regulatir~n or
requ.iremQnt.
BE IT FURTHER ItGSOLVLD that the Anahe.im City Planning Cammi~s3an
doQS hereby £ind and determine th~t adoption cf this Resolution 3s expressly
pred.ic~-ted upor~ applicant'~c complianco wfth oach and all of the conditians
hereinabove set• forth. Sh~u1d any such condition, or any part thereof, be
dec~ared invalid or unenf.orceable by the final judgmen~ of any r.aurt of
r.o~r~petent jurisdiction, thei~ this Resolution, and any soprovals herein
contained, shall be deemed null and void.
T.FiE FOREGOING RESOLUTION is signed t+nd approved b~ me this A~ri.l 24,
1989.
__-,~,,;~!- -"-'~' -_ _/ v ,~1..1: i ~`_-sL_
CFiAIRWOMAI~,; IWAHEIM ~~ITY F'LANNTNG COMMISSION
AT.TEST: /~
` ~ ~-~t~
- ~ LL.__ ~G,ri
SEGRETARY, ANAHEIM CITY PLANNING CObiMTSSION
r~
-5-
PC89-110
~• :
- ---- _ . . , : :.~
~.'~'s~~
Yf ?'
~ iY ~~
. ' ., ~~'',+.;f
~',~,
i}
STATE OE' CALIFOfiNIA
COUNTY OF ORANGE ) s.y.
CITY OF ANAfTExM )
I, Edith L. Harris, Secie;tary of thQ Anaheim C:tty Planning
Commission, do her~by certi~y that the forogoin,q r.esolution was passc~8 and
adopted at a,neoti.ng of thQ Axxaheim Ci.ty P1t~nn,ing Commissi.on he].d on April 24,
1989, by the fo'llowing v~te of tho mombers khereof:
AY~,SS COIrIIrfISSIONERS: BpUAS, BOYASTUN, F~LDHAUS, T3ERBST., MESSE ~~
NOES: COI~tISSIONERS: NQNE
ABSRNT: Cdt~StSSIONERS: CARUSZLLO, MC BI.fRNEY
'~
IN WITNESS WHEREOr', I ha~vQ hereunto aot my hand th3s 24th aay o~f ''
April, 1919. `'
, ~~~.~- ,_ ~ ' ~
~~
SECRETARY, ANAHEIM CITY PI,ANNIDIG COMMISSI~JN
~s
-6- PC89-110